Jump to content

The Edge of Glory: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Browse history interactively
← Previous editNext edit →
Content deleted Content added
VisualWikitext
Undid revision 435494594 by Ravlo2004 (talk) The Daily Mail is a legitimate critical source, their opinion is to be heard, despire what you may think of it. Thanks for your contrib.
Ravlo2004 (talk | contribs)
69 edits
→Reception: i''m gonna keep insisting on having the daily mail "critique" removed, It adds nothing of credible value. If you insist of having so much on this page, make a JOKE category, and put it under that.
Line 75: Line 75:
|author=|first=James|last=Montgomery|date=2011-06-17|accessate=2011-06-17|publisher=[[MTV News]]}}</ref> Sal Cinquemani of ''[[Slant Magazine]]'' gave the video a positive review, calling it a "visual triumph," with "breathtaking" art direction, and a "gray-blue-black color palette carefully calibrated by Gaga's vibrant lipstick and nail polish, a red painted stripe on the curb, and the gold of her jewelry and the studs on her leather, not to mention Clarence Clemons's brass." The video was compared to Michael Jackson's "[[The Way You Make Me Feel]]," [[Janet Jackson]]'s "[[When I Think of You]]," and ''[[Crimes of Passion (1984 film)|Crimes of Passion]],'' all iconic 1980s videos and films. He did, however, criticize Gaga's "half-convincing" lip-synching, which "adds to the proceedings' deliberate air of artifice."<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.slantmagazine.com/house/2011/06/video-review-lady-gaga-the-edge-of-glory/|title=Video Review: Lady Gaga, "The Edge of Glory"|author=|first=Sal|last=Cinquemani|date=2011-06-17|accessate=2011-06-17|publisher=''[[Slant Magazine]]''}}</ref> Sarah Anne Hughes of ''[[The Washington Post]]'' called the video "shockingly simple...a solo Gaga dances up and down a fire escape and a city street. And that’s pretty much it. No [[Born_This_Way_(song)#Live_performances|egg]]. No [[Meat dress of Lady Gaga|meat dress]]. No [[Born_This_Way_(song)#Music_video|live birth to a gold liquid]]."<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/celebritology/post/lady-gagas-the-edge-of-glory-video-is-shockingly-simple/2011/06/17/AGpy9kYH_blog.html|title=Lady Gaga’s ‘The Edge of Glory’ video is shockingly simple|author=|first=Sarah Anne|last=Hughes|date=2011-06-17|accessate=2011-06-17|publisher=''[[The Washington Post]]''}}</ref>
|author=|first=James|last=Montgomery|date=2011-06-17|accessate=2011-06-17|publisher=[[MTV News]]}}</ref> Sal Cinquemani of ''[[Slant Magazine]]'' gave the video a positive review, calling it a "visual triumph," with "breathtaking" art direction, and a "gray-blue-black color palette carefully calibrated by Gaga's vibrant lipstick and nail polish, a red painted stripe on the curb, and the gold of her jewelry and the studs on her leather, not to mention Clarence Clemons's brass." The video was compared to Michael Jackson's "[[The Way You Make Me Feel]]," [[Janet Jackson]]'s "[[When I Think of You]]," and ''[[Crimes of Passion (1984 film)|Crimes of Passion]],'' all iconic 1980s videos and films. He did, however, criticize Gaga's "half-convincing" lip-synching, which "adds to the proceedings' deliberate air of artifice."<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.slantmagazine.com/house/2011/06/video-review-lady-gaga-the-edge-of-glory/|title=Video Review: Lady Gaga, "The Edge of Glory"|author=|first=Sal|last=Cinquemani|date=2011-06-17|accessate=2011-06-17|publisher=''[[Slant Magazine]]''}}</ref> Sarah Anne Hughes of ''[[The Washington Post]]'' called the video "shockingly simple...a solo Gaga dances up and down a fire escape and a city street. And that’s pretty much it. No [[Born_This_Way_(song)#Live_performances|egg]]. No [[Meat dress of Lady Gaga|meat dress]]. No [[Born_This_Way_(song)#Music_video|live birth to a gold liquid]]."<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/celebritology/post/lady-gagas-the-edge-of-glory-video-is-shockingly-simple/2011/06/17/AGpy9kYH_blog.html|title=Lady Gaga’s ‘The Edge of Glory’ video is shockingly simple|author=|first=Sarah Anne|last=Hughes|date=2011-06-17|accessate=2011-06-17|publisher=''[[The Washington Post]]''}}</ref>


''[[Rolling Stone]]'' gave a mixed review of the video, calling the song "over-the-top" with a "lackluster" and "understated" video. The magazine complimented the 1980s visual feel to the video, but criticized that "there's not much more to the video [besides from the 1980s, New York scenery], which spends far too much time lingering on shots of Gaga dancing around on a fire escape and prancing down the street." Clarence Clemons's limited role in the video was also criticized, especially since "Gaga and her fans clearly love Clemons."<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.rollingstone.com/videos/new-and-hot/lady-gaga-and-clarence-clemons-lackluster-video-for-edge-of-glory-20110617|title=Lady Gaga and Clarence Clemons: Lackluster video for 'Edge of Glory'|date=2011-06-17|accessate=2011-06-17|publisher=''[[Rolling Stone]]''}}</ref> [[Peter Robinson]] of [[Popjustice]] gave the video a negative review, stating that it was "complete shit" and that "we just need to accept that Gaga has released an awful video."<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.popjustice.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=5493&Itemid=206|title=She's on the Edge of Boring|author=|first=Peter|last=Robinson|date=2011-06-17|accessate=2011-06-17|publisher=[[Popjustice]]}}</ref> [[Dose (magazine)|''Dose'']] magazine's Leah Collins was more neutral in her review, questioning if Gaga was simply "swooning with nostalgia for other pop culture nuggets that have featured the same NYC backdrop of fire escapes and brown-stone steps" or just attempting to "be saving a metric buttload on the budget."<ref name="Dose">{{cite web|url=http://www.dose.ca/Watch+Lady+Gaga+Edge+Glory+Video+Stripped+Down+Messed/4964046/story.html|title=Watch Lady Gaga's 'Edge of Glory' Video (Stripped Down or Messed Up?)|author=|first=Leah|last=Collins|date=2011-06-17|accessdate=2011-06-17|work=[[Dose (magazine)|''Dose'']]|publisher=[[Postmedia Network]]}}</ref> Collins commented on the missing sets "for a hospital scene, Brooklyn Bridge, and a big underwater mermaid scene" which were confirmed to have been created for the video and how those ideas were scuttled after the fallout with the video's former director, Joseph Kahn.<ref name="Dose"/> The ''[[Daily Mail]]'' criticized Gaga for seemingly copying Madonna again, saying, "the 25-year-old singer has seemingly gone one further and boldly copied the Queen of Pop yet again. Provocative, raunchy and reminiscent of a number of Madonna's iconic chart hits, Gaga has today released what would appear to be the ultimate 80s tribute video...Channelling looks from Madonna's performance in ''[[Who's That Girl (1987 film)|Who's That Girl]]'', with cropped blonde hair, leather studded attire and flat cap, Gaga's appearance has many comparisons to Madonna's iconic role as Nikki Finn in the 1987 hit movie.
''[[Rolling Stone]]'' gave a mixed review of the video, calling the song "over-the-top" with a "lackluster" and "understated" video. The magazine complimented the 1980s visual feel to the video, but criticized that "there's not much more to the video [besides from the 1980s, New York scenery], which spends far too much time lingering on shots of Gaga dancing around on a fire escape and prancing down the street." Clarence Clemons's limited role in the video was also criticized, especially since "Gaga and her fans clearly love Clemons."<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.rollingstone.com/videos/new-and-hot/lady-gaga-and-clarence-clemons-lackluster-video-for-edge-of-glory-20110617|title=Lady Gaga and Clarence Clemons: Lackluster video for 'Edge of Glory'|date=2011-06-17|accessate=2011-06-17|publisher=''[[Rolling Stone]]''}}</ref> [[Peter Robinson]] of [[Popjustice]] gave the video a negative review, stating that it was "complete shit" and that "we just need to accept that Gaga has released an awful video."<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.popjustice.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=5493&Itemid=206|title=She's on the Edge of Boring|author=|first=Peter|last=Robinson|date=2011-06-17|accessate=2011-06-17|publisher=[[Popjustice]]}}</ref> [[Dose (magazine)|''Dose'']] magazine's Leah Collins was more neutral in her review, questioning if Gaga was simply "swooning with nostalgia for other pop culture nuggets that have featured the same NYC backdrop of fire escapes and brown-stone steps" or just attempting to "be saving a metric buttload on the budget."<ref name="Dose">{{cite web|url=http://www.dose.ca/Watch+Lady+Gaga+Edge+Glory+Video+Stripped+Down+Messed/4964046/story.html|title=Watch Lady Gaga's 'Edge of Glory' Video (Stripped Down or Messed Up?)|author=|first=Leah|last=Collins|date=2011-06-17|accessdate=2011-06-17|work=[[Dose (magazine)|''Dose'']]|publisher=[[Postmedia Network]]}}</ref> Collins commented on the missing sets "for a hospital scene, Brooklyn Bridge, and a big underwater mermaid scene" which were confirmed to have been created for the video and how those ideas were scuttled after the fallout with the video's former director, Joseph Kahn.<ref name="Dose"/> Gaga's kissing the New York City ground was even compared to her "current political bid to pass marriage equality in the State of New York."<ref name="Dose">{{cite web|url=http://www.dailymail.co.uk/tvshowbiz/article-2004566/Lady-Gaga-steals-Madonnas-iconic-80s-style-new-music-video-Edge-Glory.html|title=Copycat Queen: Lady Gaga steals more of Madonna's iconic 80s style in her new music video Edge of Glory||date=2011-06-17|accessdate=2011-06-17|work=''[[Daily Mail]]''}}</ref>
Gaga's dance moves are also reminiscent of the 1983 musical, ''[[Flashdance]],'' proving there is little originality in the entertainer's latest video offering."<ref>[http://www.dailymail.co.uk/tvshowbiz/article-2004566/Lady-Gaga-steals-Madonnas-iconic-80s-style-new-music-video-Edge-Glory.html Lady Gaga Steals Madonna's Iconic 80s Style]</ref> Gaga's kissing the New York City ground was even compared to her "current political bid to pass marriage equality in the State of New York."<ref name="Dose">{{cite web|url=http://www.dailymail.co.uk/tvshowbiz/article-2004566/Lady-Gaga-steals-Madonnas-iconic-80s-style-new-music-video-Edge-Glory.html|title=Copycat Queen: Lady Gaga steals more of Madonna's iconic 80s style in her new music video Edge of Glory||date=2011-06-17|accessdate=2011-06-17|work=''[[Daily Mail]]''}}</ref>


==Live performances==
==Live performances==

Revision as of 17:47, 21 June 2011

"The Edge of Glory"
Song

"The Edge of Glory" is a song by American recording artist and songwriter Lady Gaga, taken from her second studio album Born This Way (2011). The song was released digitally on May 9, 2011, and was added to the United States mainstream radio playlists on May 17, 2011. Alongside with "Hair", it was originally released as one of two promotional singles before the release of Born This Way. Following the success of the song in digital outlets worldwide, it was announced that it would serve as the album's third official single.[1]

"The Edge of Glory" features production from Lady Gaga, Fernando Garibay and DJ White Shadow. Recording sessions for the song took place at The Living Room Studios in Oslo, Norway and Germano Studios in New York City. "The Edge of Glory" is a dance song that speaks of the very last moments of living on Earth. According to Gaga, lyrical inspiration came from the death of her grandfather, whom died in September 2010. The melody of the song resembles much of the musical works of Bruce Springsteen, and contains several qualities similar to that of electro rock and synthpop musical works. It is notable for the incorporation of a saxophone solo, performed by late saxophonist Clarence Clemons, who was a prominent member of The E Street Band.

Contemporary critics praised "The Edge of Glory", with many deeming the song as an album highlight. Much of the praise went to the song's chorus and the musical production. Critics also complimented Gaga's vocals, describing it as "soulful". The song charted on the top-ten in several major music markets, including Canada, Belgium, Norway, Spain, and New Zealand. In the United States, it debuted at number three on the Billboard Hot 100, becoming Gaga's tenth consecutive top-ten single in the United States.[2]

A music video for the song was filmed in late May, co-directed by Gaga and the Haus of Gaga. The video is notably simplistic in contrast to much of Gaga's previous work. Such dramatic differences include the lack of intricate choreography, lack of back-up dancers, and the use of only one outfit designed by Versace. Critics commended the simplicity of the video, while several music critics went on to compare the music video of "The Edge of Glory" with the works of Michael Jackson and Madonna, notably "Billie Jean" and "Papa Don't Preach", respectively.

Background and release

Clemons' saxophone solo was a notable feature in "The Edge of Glory".

"The Edge of Glory" was written by Lady Gaga, Fernando Garibay and DJ White Shadow, and it was produced by Gaga and Garibay.[3][4] The origins of the song first came about in January 2011, when Gaga teased the fans with a preview of the lyrics.[5] Stephen Hill, the Music Programming VP of BET, later followed suit in regards to the song in the form of a tweet.[6] Hill regarded the song as "crazy" and "phenomenal" when first heard.[6] More information in regards to "The Edge of Glory" was revealed by Gaga, in an interview with Google. She stated that the song is "about your last moment on earth, the moment of truth, the moment before you leave earth." In the same interview Gaga stated that she wrote "The Edge of Glory" after the death of her grandfather.[7][8]

"One of the songs on the album that is truly one of my favorites, it's called 'Edge of Glory' and it's kind of a sad story. Sorry to be a downer. But my grandpa died about five months ago, and my dad and I were going to say goodbye to him at the hospital, and I got out a big thing of agave tequila and my dad sat next to me at the piano and we started to doing shots back and forth, and I wrote 'Edge of Glory' on the piano and my dad and I cried. The song's about your last moment on Earth, the moment of truth, the edge of glory is that moment right before you leave the Earth. So that song can be played on the piano, but it's actually set to this giant, huge, techno rock, Springsteen-esque dance beat. I actually had Clarence Clemons from the E Street Band come in and play saxophone on it. It's fucking beautiful."

On her Twitter account, Gaga confirmed the news the day before the scheduled release, and also revealed the cover for the promotional single.[5][9] It was supposed to serve as the first song in the "Countdown to Born This Way" promotion on the iTunes Store, but due to its quick success it was confirmed to be the third official single from the album. The next promotional single, which was released on May 16, is "Hair".[10]

The song is also featured in one of a series of advertisements for Google's Chrome web browser, featuring both Gaga and various fans singing, dancing to and lipsyncing the song.[11]

Composition

"The Edge of Glory"
A 28-second sample of "The Edge of Glory" featuring the end of the chorus and the beginning of the bridge which contains the saxophone solo.
Problems playing this file? See media help.

"The Edge of Glory" is a dance-pop song,[12] and includes a saxophone solo. It was written by Gaga, Fernando Garibay, and DJ White Shadow.[3] It was mixed at Germano Studios in New York City.[3] Gaga stated during her interview with NME that "I'm perpetually unhappy with what I create. Even though I might tell you that 'The Edge Of Glory' is a pop masterpiece, when it's all said and finished there will be things I dread, and every time I listen to it I'll hear them".[13] The song opens with Gaga's voice over a keyboard, singing "I need a man who thinks it's right when it's so wrong/ Tonight, yeah, baby, right on the limits/ Where we know where we both belong/ Tonight."[14] After the first verse, she moves into the chorus, where she belts, "I'm on the edge of glory/ And I'm hangin' on a moment of truth/ I'm on the edge of glory/ And I'm hangin' on a moment with you/ I'm on the edge."[14] In the middle of the song, as Gaga sings, "I'm on the edge with you," Clarence Clemons begins his sax solo, and he continues to play until the end of the song.[14] The song is "less electro and more straightforward pop" and shows a "softer" side to the album, compared to the previous singles, which were "harsher and more industrial sounding," according to Jocelyn Vena of MTV News.[14] According to sheet music published by Sony/ATV Music Publishing, "The Edge of Glory" is written in common time with a tempo of 120 beats per minute. Set in the key of A major, it follows the basic chord progression of A–E–D, while Gaga's voice spans from A3 to D5[12] The lyrics of the song are "about your last moment on earth, the moment of truth, the moment before you leave earth,” according to Gaga herself.[15]

Critical reception

Gaga performing "The Edge of Glory" on Good Morning America.

An hour before kicking off the final leg of The Monster Ball Tour, Gaga sent four tracks to Rolling Stone magazine, including "Scheiße", "Yoü and I", and "Hair", to have an advance preview. Matthew Perpetua wrote a positive review of the song. "This one sounds crazy in print—it's a massive power ballad with heavy club beats that features Clarence Clemons of the E Street Band wailing on his saxophone—but somehow it all seems totally natural when you actually hear it. There's an element of cheesiness to it, but it's totally captivating and incredibly catchy. If any of these new Gaga tunes demands to be a big fat hit this is it. The inclusion of Clemons is an inspired touch that amplifies the song's Eighties stadium rock vibe, but his (Clemons's) actual performance is amazing and ranks among the best of his career."[8]

Since its release, 'The Edge of Glory' has received mostly positive reviews from critics. NME gave a positive review of the song, stating "It feels like a pop moment without her trying too hard." later adding "‘The Edge Of Glory’ is simple. And it is, quite simply a Great Pop Moment." Further, in his review of Born This Way, Dan Martin of NME praised "The Edge of Glory," describing it as "the most ecstatic pop serenade [Lady Gaga] has ever come up with."[16][17] In a review of the song, Popjustice stated "It is a beautiful song that made us almost cry a bit when we first heard it and we are looking forward to hearing it again."[18] Bill Lamb at About.com gave the song a 9/10, stating "'The Edge Of Glory' is a sweeping, anthemic dance-rock power ballad that truly cuts loose and feels free." going on to say it contains "bubbling and smoldering dance elements that will please core fans while rocking hard enough to convince skeptics that there is timeless talent here."[19] Billboard gave positive review of the song, comparing it to "Born This Way" saying "[it] leans upon sunny electronica that ramps up during its anthemic chorus" adding that "while [the song] also glorifies risk-taking, it's focused on romance rather than individual inspiration." [20] Amy Sciarretto of Artistdirect gave it a positive review, calling it an "uptempo, dancefloor banger, full of beats and Gaga's throaty, soulful voice."[21] Robert Copsey of Digital Spy said, "the woman [Gaga] herself heightened our anticipation [of Born This Way] even further with the release of its third cut 'The Edge of Glory'. The track combines stadium-sized air guitars with club-pumping synths to make for a straight-up fists-in-the-air feel-good anthem that is less cheesy than 'Born This Way' but equally (if not more) euphoric."[22]

Time Magazine, however, gave the song a mixed review, calling the song "Saxophoney! But, also, boring" and that the song was disappointing along with the first two singles from Born This Way.[23] Matthew Cole of Slant Magazine also gave a mixed review, calling saxophones "sleazy" and called Clarence Clemons's solo the song's "high point" and "one of the more original ideas Gaga has had of late." He found that song again lowered his expectations for Born This way.[24] Will Hodgkinson of The Times gave a more negative review of the song, calling it "a truly horrible rock ballad that even Cher would dismiss as being in bad taste".[25]

Chart performance

On the issue dated May 18, 2011, "The Edge of Glory" debuted at number two on Hot Digital Songs chart with 266,000 copies sold.[26] The song debuted at number three on the Billboard Hot 100, becoming Gaga's tenth consecutive top-ten single in the United States.[2] It has spent four weeks in the top ten, and it currently sits at number 6.[27] The song debuted at number 31 on the US Pop Chart, and made the top-ten after four weeks.[28] It has peaked at number 8.[29] It has also peaked at number 14 on Adult Pop Songs, number 38 on Latin Pop Songs, and number 46 on Hot Dance Club Songs.[30][29][31]

"The Edge of Glory" made its first chart appearance debuting at number 19 on the Finnish Singles Chart[32] and climbing then up to number 14.[32][33] In the United Kingdom the song debuted at number six on the issue dated May 21, 2011.[34] In Canada, the song has peaked at number three.[35]

Music video

Development

The music video was shot May 28-29, 2011,[36] on a New York-styled backlot.[37] Originally, Joseph Kahn had been hired to direct the music video. Kahn had previously worked with Lady Gaga on "LoveGame" and "Eh, Eh (Nothing Else I Can Say)."[38] After rumors of an argument between Gaga and Kahn, Laurieann Gibson, Gaga's creative director, said on Twitter that there had been issues on the set and Kahn no longer was involved in the production.[38] Interscope Records confirmed that Gaga is the director of the clip, with the Haus of Gaga as collaborative directors.[38] The stylist for the video is Nicola Formichetti, who tweeted the week of the filming, "so excited of 'edge of glory' shoot this week!! OMG..."[36] At the 2011 BMI Pop Music Awards, when asked about the video's concept, Laurieann Gibson told Rap-Up TV, "I just know that we'll be feeling very fishy."[36] E! News managed to get a casting call notice for the video. The casting notice asks for a "Puerto Rican or Dominican type badass" who "must be willing to kiss Lady Gaga", "Couture Doctors" who will wear smocks and black gloves", a "male or female on-air reporter", and a group of military men to hold M16 rifles."[36] The original concept, which included the people in the casting notice, as well as other New York City sets, such as the Brooklyn Bridge, was scrapped after Gaga's feud with Kahn.[39] The video premiered June 16 on So You Think You Can Dance.[40]

Synopsis

File:Theedgeofglorystill.jpg
Lady Gaga and Clarence Clemons in the music video for the Edge of Glory.

The video is considerably more simplistic than Gaga's previous work. Her wardrobe throughout the entire video primarily consists of only one outfit which was designed by Versace. Also notable is the absence of back-up dancers, elaborate choreography, or a symbolic plot: components that have all been predominant in Gaga's other music videos. Aside from Gaga herself, Clarence Clemons is the only other person to appear in the video.

It begins with Lady Gaga slowly appearing from behind a building on a deserted street corner in New York City, while a bright pink smoke obscures the city background. When the first verse of the song begins, Gaga emerges from a bright pink-lit window of an apartment onto the fire escape while smoke begins to billow out of the window. The video is mostly interchanging shots of Gaga dancing and singing on the street, on the fire escape, and on the steps in front of the apartment building with Clarence Clemons. Near the end of the video, after Clemons's saxophone solo, Gaga crouches in front of the building's steps and kisses the sidewalk. The video concludes with Gaga reentering the window into her smokey apartment.

Reception

Entertainment Weekly described the video as a "one-woman ‘80s revue" and expressed surprise at the "relatively small, but perhaps more intimate, scope of [Gaga's] vision". They considered that the video contained references to Michael Jackson and Madonna and concluded that "all the references in “The Edge of Glory” are so overt, there’s no way it could be shameless cribbing. It has to be a winking homage to the artists, songs, and videos that meant a lot to Gaga growing up—like a college-student who brings his action figures to his dorm."[41] MTV News compared the video to "Papa Don't Preach" and "Billie Jean," and complimented the simplicity of the video, opposed to her previous ones. "Edge' is little more than five-and-a-half minutes of classic pop, brimming with imagery, style (and moves) that could've been lifted from millions of videos in the pop heyday of the 1980s."[37] MTV also made similarities between the video and the musicals Rent and West Side Story.[42] Sal Cinquemani of Slant Magazine gave the video a positive review, calling it a "visual triumph," with "breathtaking" art direction, and a "gray-blue-black color palette carefully calibrated by Gaga's vibrant lipstick and nail polish, a red painted stripe on the curb, and the gold of her jewelry and the studs on her leather, not to mention Clarence Clemons's brass." The video was compared to Michael Jackson's "The Way You Make Me Feel," Janet Jackson's "When I Think of You," and Crimes of Passion, all iconic 1980s videos and films. He did, however, criticize Gaga's "half-convincing" lip-synching, which "adds to the proceedings' deliberate air of artifice."[43] Sarah Anne Hughes of The Washington Post called the video "shockingly simple...a solo Gaga dances up and down a fire escape and a city street. And that’s pretty much it. No egg. No meat dress. No live birth to a gold liquid."[44]

Rolling Stone gave a mixed review of the video, calling the song "over-the-top" with a "lackluster" and "understated" video. The magazine complimented the 1980s visual feel to the video, but criticized that "there's not much more to the video [besides from the 1980s, New York scenery], which spends far too much time lingering on shots of Gaga dancing around on a fire escape and prancing down the street." Clarence Clemons's limited role in the video was also criticized, especially since "Gaga and her fans clearly love Clemons."[45] Peter Robinson of Popjustice gave the video a negative review, stating that it was "complete shit" and that "we just need to accept that Gaga has released an awful video."[46] Dose magazine's Leah Collins was more neutral in her review, questioning if Gaga was simply "swooning with nostalgia for other pop culture nuggets that have featured the same NYC backdrop of fire escapes and brown-stone steps" or just attempting to "be saving a metric buttload on the budget."[39] Collins commented on the missing sets "for a hospital scene, Brooklyn Bridge, and a big underwater mermaid scene" which were confirmed to have been created for the video and how those ideas were scuttled after the fallout with the video's former director, Joseph Kahn.[39] Gaga's kissing the New York City ground was even compared to her "current political bid to pass marriage equality in the State of New York."[39]

Live performances

Gaga performing "The Edge of Glory" at 2011 Much Music Video Awards

Gaga first performed an acoustic version of "The Edge of Glory" at Radio 1's Big Weekend 2011 in Carlisle, United Kingdom along with a selection of past hits including "Bad Romance", "Just Dance", "Alejandro", "Telephone" and "Poker Face", and new additions from the Born This Way album, "Judas", "Born This Way" and "Yoü and I".[47] Gaga sang part of "The Edge Of Glory" on May 21, 2011 at Saturday Night Live, before performing "Judas" and then later performed "Born This Way".

Clarence Clemons joined Lady Gaga on the American Idol's tenth season finale on May 25, 2011, performing the song live for the first time[clarification needed]. Gaga performed the song on top of a small, man-made cliff on the Idol stage, with dancers surrounding the cliff. While Clemons played his saxophone solo to the side of the stage, Gaga and a male dancer did highly energized dance number. The song ended with Gaga and her partner jumping off the cliff behind a pile of fake rocks.[48] The performance drew complaints from the Parents Television Council, which named American Idol the worst television show of the week because of the performance. The rendition of "The Edge of Glory" was called "a sexually provocative live performance during what should have been a family-friendly show." Gaga's outfit, a studded black bra and panties, was singled out as being inappropriate for prime-time television, as well as a "suggestive" dance number with a "bare-chested male dancer."[49] On May 27, 2011, Gaga also performed the song on Good Morning America as a part of their 'Summer Concert Series'.[50]

On June 9, 2011, Gaga performed the song on the finale of Germany's Next Top Model. Wearing a teal wig, she sang a short version of her song "Scheiße" and played a rendition of "Born This Way" on the piano before performing "The Edge of Glory." During the performance, Gaga walked under two guillotines labeled "sex" and "money" respectively, and purposely bypassed a third guillotine labeled "vanity."[51]. Gaga also performed the song on June 11 2011 at the EuroPride 2011[52]. Gaga performed on the X Factor in Paris on June 14, 2011, as a part of a medley with "Judas". The performance started with Gaga playing a keytar for "The Edge of Glory", wearing a fringed coat as well as a teal wig. She then removed the keytar and fringed coat, revealing a lingerie outfit which included a thong, and transitioned into "Judas".[53][54]. On June 15 2011, Gaga also performed the song on the french show 'Le Grand Journal', being dressed as a mermaid during the performance. [55]. On June 19 2011, Gaga opened the 2011 MuchMusic Video Awards with a performance of the song. [56]

Track listing

  • Digital download[57]
  1. "The Edge of Glory" – 5:20

Credits and personnel

The credits for "The Edge of Glory" are adapted from Born This Way album liner notes.[3]

Charts

Chart (2011) Peak
position
Australian Singles Chart[33] 11
Belgian Singles Chart (Flanders)[33] 6
Belgian Singles Chart (Wallonia)[33] 2
Canadian Hot 100[35] 3
Danish Singles Chart[33] 8
Finnish Singles Chart[33] 14
French Singles Chart[33] 7
German Singles Chart[58] 7
Irish Singles Chart[59] 10
Italian Singles Chart[33] 2
Netherlands Single Top 100[33] 9
New Zealand Singles Chart[33] 3
Norwegian Singles Chart[33] 2
Scottish Singles Chart[60] 2
Spanish Singles Chart[33] 5
Swedish Singles Chart[33] 36
Swiss Singles Chart[33] 30
UK Singles Chart[34] 6
US Billboard Hot 100[2] 3
US Adult Pop Songs[30] 14
US Hot Dance Club Songs[31] 46
US Latin Pop Songs[29] 38
US Pop Songs[61] 8

Radio and release history

Country Date Format
United States[57] May 9, 2011 Digital download
United Kingdom[62]
South Korea[63] May 10, 2011
Italy[64] May 13, 2011 Airplay
United States[65] May 17, 2011 Mainstream radio

References

  1. ^ "Lady Gaga Makes 'The Edge Of Glory' Next Official Single".
  2. ^ a b c Trust, Gary (2011-05-18). "Adele Stays Atop Hot 100, Lady Gaga Makes 'Glory'-ous Start". Billboard. Prometheus Global Media. Retrieved 2011-05-18.
  3. ^ a b c d (Media notes). {{cite AV media notes}}: Missing or empty |title= (help); Unknown parameter |Format= ignored (|format= suggested) (help); Unknown parameter |PID= ignored (help); Unknown parameter |Publisher= ignored (|publisher= suggested) (help); Unknown parameter |Type= ignored (|type= suggested) (help); Unknown parameter |Year= ignored (|year= suggested) (help)
  4. ^ Blauvelt, Christian (2011-05-09). "Lady Gaga releases new single 'The Edge of Glory': Listen here". Entertainment Weekly. Time, Inc. Retrieved 2011-05-09.
  5. ^ a b Vena, Jocelyn (2011-05-05). "Lady Gaga Teases 'The Edge Of Glory' Release On Monday". MTV (MTV Networks). Retrieved 2011-05-09.
  6. ^ a b http://ksfm.radio.com/2011/01/26/new-details-for-lady-gagas-born-this-way/
  7. ^ Google Goes Gaga. Google. 2011-03-13. {{cite AV media}}: Unknown parameter |artist= ignored (|others= suggested) (help)
  8. ^ a b Perpetua, Matthew (2011-02-18). "Preview Six Songs From Lady Gaga's 'Born This Way'". Rolling Stone. Jann Wenner. Retrieved 2011-02-20.
  9. ^ Martin, Dan (2011-05-08). "Lady Gaga to debut new song on iTunes Monday". The Guardian. London: Guardian Media Group. Retrieved 2011-05-09.
  10. ^ "Lady Gaga's 'Edge of Glory' Single Premieres, 'Hair' Coming Next Week". Billboard. Prometheus Global Media. 2011-05-09. Retrieved 2011-05-09.
  11. ^ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sDPJ-o1leAw
  12. ^ a b "Lady Gaga – The Edge of Glory Sheet Music". Musicnotes.com Sony/ATV Music Publishing. Retrieved 2011-05-26.
  13. ^ "Gaga NME Interview".
  14. ^ a b c d Vena, Jocelyn (May 9, 2011). "Lady Gaga's 'Edge Of Glory' Premieres". MTV News. Retrieved 2011-06-17.
  15. ^ "Lady Gaga releases new single 'The Edge of Glory': Listen here". Entertainment Weekly. Retrieved 2011-06-17.
  16. ^ http://www.nme.com/reviews/lady-gaga/12061
  17. ^ Elan, Priya (May 10, 2011). "Lady Gaga's 'Edge Of Glory' Is A Great Pop Moment — Track Review". New Musical Express. nme.com, IPC Media. Retrieved May 13, 2011.
  18. ^ "Review by Popjustice".
  19. ^ "Lady GaGa - "The Edge of Glory"".
  20. ^ Billboard Reviews new Lady Gaga single :http://www.billboard.com/#/news/lady-gaga-s-edge-of-glory-single-premieres-1005175582.story
  21. ^ Sciarretto, Amy (May 10, 2011). "Lady Gaga Releases "Edge of Glory"". Artistdirect. Retrieved June 17, 2011.
  22. ^ Copsey, Robert (May 9, 2011). "First Listen: Lady GaGa's 'The Edge of Glory'". Digital Spy. Retrieved June 17, 2011.
  23. ^ Gibson, Megan (2011-05-11). "Hey Lady Gaga, Can You Please Go Back to Being Awesome?". Time. Retrieved May 12, 2011.
  24. ^ Cole, Matthew (May 10, 2011). "Edge of Corny: 10 Awesomely Unironic Sax Solos". Slant Magazine. Retrieved June 17, 2011. {{cite web}}: Italic or bold markup not allowed in: |work= (help)
  25. ^ Hodgkinson, Will. "Lady Gaga: Born This Way". Retrieved May 24, 2011.
  26. ^ Caulfield, Keith (2011-05-18). "Lonely Island Sets Sail at No. 3 on Billboard 200, Adele Still No. 1". Billboard. Prometheus Global Media. Retrieved 2011-05-18.
  27. ^ Grein, Paul (2011-06-15). "Week Ending June 12, 2011. Songs: The Odd Couples". Yahoo Music. Yahoo!. Retrieved 2011-05-17.
  28. ^ http://www.billboard.com/charts/hot-100#/charts/pop-songs?chartDate=2011-06-18
  29. ^ a b c http://www.billboard.com/charts/hot-100#/song/lady-gaga/the-edge-of-glory/25465779
  30. ^ a b "Adult Pop Songs: Week Ending June 18, 2011". Billboard. Prometheus Global Media. 2011-06-18. Retrieved 2011-06-13.
  31. ^ a b "Hot Dance Club Songs: Week Ending June 18, 2011". Billboard. Prometheus Global Media. 2011-06-18. Retrieved 2011-06-13.
  32. ^ a b "Suomen virallinen lista – Lady GaGa: The Edge Of Glory" (in Finnish). Retrieved 2011-05-20.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: unrecognized language (link)
  33. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n Steffen Hung. "Lady GaGa – The Edge Of Glory" (in Dutch). dutchcharts.nl, Hung Medien; GfK. Retrieved 2011-05-27.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: unrecognized language (link)
  34. ^ a b "Archive Chart". UK Singles Chart. The Official Charts Company. Retrieved 18 May 2011.
  35. ^ a b "Canadian Hot 100". Retrieved 2011-05-20.
  36. ^ a b c d Vena, Jocelyn (2011-05-26). "Lady Gaga's 'Edge Of Glory' Video Details Possibly Revealed". MTV News. MTV. Retrieved 2011-06-16.
  37. ^ a b Montgomery, James (2011-06-16). "Lady Gaga's 'Edge Of Glory' Video: Glory Days". MTV News. {{cite web}}: Unknown parameter |accessate= ignored (|access-date= suggested) (help)
  38. ^ a b c Corner, Lewis (2011-06-16). "Lady GaGa fires 'Edge of Glory' video director on set?". Digital Spy. Retrieved 2011-06-16.
  39. ^ a b c d Collins, Leah (2011-06-17). "Watch Lady Gaga's 'Edge of Glory' Video (Stripped Down or Messed Up?)". Dose. Postmedia Network. Retrieved 2011-06-17. {{cite web}}: Italic or bold markup not allowed in: |work= (help) Cite error: The named reference "Dose" was defined multiple times with different content (see the help page).
  40. ^ Vena, Jocelyn (2011-06-15). "Lady Gaga To Premiere 'Edge Of Glory' Video On 'So You Think You Can Dance'". MTV News. MTV. Retrieved 2011-06-15.
  41. ^ "Lady Gaga debuts 'Edge of Glory' video: Watch her one-woman '80s time-warp fantasia here-VIDEO". Entertainment Weekly. 2011-06-16. Retrieved 2011-06-17.
  42. ^ Montgomery, James (2011-06-17). "Lady Gaga's 'Edge Of Glory': A Pop-Culture Cheat Sheet". MTV News. {{cite web}}: Unknown parameter |accessate= ignored (|access-date= suggested) (help)
  43. ^ Cinquemani, Sal (2011-06-17). "Video Review: Lady Gaga, "The Edge of Glory"". Slant Magazine. {{cite web}}: Italic or bold markup not allowed in: |publisher= (help); Unknown parameter |accessate= ignored (|access-date= suggested) (help)
  44. ^ Hughes, Sarah Anne (2011-06-17). "Lady Gaga's 'The Edge of Glory' video is shockingly simple". The Washington Post. {{cite web}}: Italic or bold markup not allowed in: |publisher= (help); Unknown parameter |accessate= ignored (|access-date= suggested) (help)
  45. ^ "Lady Gaga and Clarence Clemons: Lackluster video for 'Edge of Glory'". Rolling Stone. 2011-06-17. {{cite web}}: Italic or bold markup not allowed in: |publisher= (help); Unknown parameter |accessate= ignored (|access-date= suggested) (help)
  46. ^ Robinson, Peter (2011-06-17). "She's on the Edge of Boring". Popjustice. {{cite web}}: Unknown parameter |accessate= ignored (|access-date= suggested) (help)
  47. ^ Ferrier, Morwenna (2011-05-16). "Lady Gaga at Radio 1's Big Weekend, review". The Daily Telegraph. London.
  48. ^ Graham, Adam (May 25, 2011). "Lady Gaga Dives And Dazzles On 'American Idol Finale'". MTV News. Retrieved 2011-06-04.
  49. ^ "Worst TV Show of the Week". Retrieved 2011-06-04.
  50. ^ http://abcnews.go.com/Entertainment/lady-gaga-makes-zipline-arrival-good-morning-america/story?id=13694695&page=2
  51. ^ http://thatgrapejuice.net/2011/06/lady-gaga-performs-germanys-top-model/
  52. ^ http://www.ladygaga.com/news/default.aspx?nid=35732
  53. ^ Marcic, Mike (2011-06-15). "Gaga Has The X Factor". Sydney Star Observer. Gay and Lesbian Community Publishing Limited. Archived from the original on 2011-06-15. {{cite news}}: Unknown parameter |accssdate= ignored (help)
  54. ^ "Lady Gaga can't speak French, so she lets the funky music do the talking". Heat. Bauer Media Group. 2011-06-15. Retrieved 2011-06-15.
  55. ^ http://www.canalplus.fr/c-divertissement/pid3349-c-le-grand-journal.html?vid=478705
  56. ^ http://www.ctv.ca/CTVNews/TopStories/20110619/mmva-muchmusic-video-awards-gaga-110619/
  57. ^ a b "The Edge of Glory - Single". iTunes Store. Apple Inc. Retrieved 2011-05-13.
  58. ^ "Suche" (in German). charts.de, Media Control GfK International. Retrieved 2011-05-24.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: unrecognized language (link)
  59. ^ "Top 50 Singles, Week Ending 12 May 2011". GFK Chart-Track. Retrieved 2011-05-13.
  60. ^ "Archive Chart – Scotland – 28 May 2011". The Official Charts Company. 2011-04-30. Retrieved 2011-04-25.
  61. ^ http://www.billboard.com/news#/news/adele-rolling-along-atop-hot-100-jason-aldean-1005237392.story
  62. ^ http://itunes.apple.com/gb/album/the-edge-of-glory-single/id436765981
  63. ^ "The Edge of Glory". Universal Music Korea. Universal Music Group. Retrieved May 20, 2011.
  64. ^ "Playlist RDS Lady Gaga - The Edge of Glory". RDS.it.
  65. ^ "Top 40/M Future Releases". All Access Media Group. Archived from the original on 2011-05-11.
Retrieved from "https://wiki.riteme.site/w/index.php?title=The_Edge_of_Glory&oldid=435495681"