Talk:Persecutory delusion/GA1

GA Review

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch

Reviewer: Pi.1415926535 (talk · contribs) 19:55, 25 July 2023 (UTC)

Close to GA quality; placing on hold to allow improvements. My main concerns about the article relate to Wikipedia:Identifying reliable sources (medicine) (MEDRS). All cite numbers are from this revision.

• Cite 1 isn't a MEDRS, and doesn't actually indicate that "persecution complex" is synonymous with "persecutory delusion".

 Removed the entry; couldn't find anything in Google Scholar.

• Cites 9/17 are identical, and not MEDRS.

 Removed them and respective content for the 9th; couldn't find other source.

• Cites 10 and 16 are marginal for MEDRS - replace them with journal articles or other MEDRS if possible.

 Question: Unfortunately I only found a partial alternative source for 10, it would only cover this part, People with this delusion often live a more inactive life. Should I cite, leave it as it is or remove the content?

I would leave the text as is, but add the additional cite.

Y Done

• Cite 23 needs to be properly filled out with publisher/website (the name, not the partial url currently used), date, etc.

Y Done

• remarkably higher is vague - either give numbers (e.g. 26% higher) or remove "remarkably"

 Question: changed "remarkably" to "significantly" (source wording), does that work?

Sounds good.

• The first sentence under "Diagnosis" is a run-on sentence

Y Done

• it's → it is

Y Done

• him or her → them

Y Done

• If possible, add a sentence or two discussing how prevalent the condition is (e.g. 1 in 10,000)

Y Done, added that 70% of first case psychosis are persecutory delusions.

• In addition to those mentioned above, one other source (Freeman and Bebbington, currently #5) needs to be properly filled in/formated.

Y Done

• Standardize date format in citations - the article currently mixes dmy and yyyy-mm-dd.

Y Done

Overall

1. Well-written
2. Verifiable with no original research
3. Broad in its coverage
4. Neutral
5. Stable
6. Illustrated

@SpaceEconomist192: Good work. I made a few minor citation formatting copyedits, ready to pass now. Pi.1415926535 (talk) 20:58, 26 July 2023 (UTC)