Talk:Aron Stevens/GA1
GA Review
[edit]| GA toolbox |
|---|
| Reviewing |
Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch
Reviewer: Ikhtiar H (talk · contribs) 14:11, 7 January 2016 (UTC)
This will be my first significant review and I might take some time. As a pro wrestling fine, I would love to review this article!
Note 1: When I quote things, you can use ctrl+f to search the page for the specific line I quoted.
Note 2: Make sure to mention your corrections when you are done correcting.
Lead Section
[edit]- It would be great to remove the parameter references.
- Slammy Awards achievements should be included.
Early career (2001–2002)
[edit]- Sentences should be less compressed.
Early years (2002–2003)
[edit]- "He also worked an angle where he had his fingers "broken" by Raven on Heat." - citation needed.
Ohio Valley Wrestling (2003–2006)
[edit]- "He later was reassigned to WWE's developmental territory Ohio Valley Wrestling (OVW), dubbed Aaron "The Idol" Stevens." - the sentence should be made more constructive.
- How Stevens won the match should be shortened.
SmackDown (2006–2007)
[edit]- The name of this sub-section should be altered with a better title.
- Last para needs to be illustrated.
Independent circuit
[edit]- Citation needed in this section.
Return to OVW (2008–2009)
[edit]- "Stevens returned to OVW on November 12, 2008 surprising and defeating OVW Heavyweight Champion, Anthony Bravado, in a non-title bout." - the word "surprising" should be made more meaningful.
- "On December 3, 2008 he teamed up with U-Gene to take part in OVW Southern Tag Team Championship number one contendership tournament, in round one they defeated Theta Lampda Psi. A week later, they lost to Anthony Bravado and The Buck. Stevens lost the title to Vaughn Lilas at the January 14, 2009 television taping. In February 2009, he lost to Mike Mondo in an OVW Television Championship match which also included Johnny Punch." - citation needed.
World Wrestling Council (2009–2010)
[edit]- Various title wins and loses need citation.
Money in the Bank; slump (2013–2014)
[edit]- "Rhodes dominated the feud between him and Sandow; throwing Sandow's briefcase into the Gulf of Mexico,[which forced Sandow to introduce a new custom-made briefcase; thwarting Sandow's attempt to cash-in on a vulnerable Alberto Del Rio; and defeating Sandow twice in singles matches, one of which was at SummerSlam." - the activities should be made more clear; it is unnecessary to mention he failed cash in on Del Rio since he did not made any attempts. (Evidence are shown in the article SummerSlam (2013).)
- "In January 2014, Sandow entered the 2014 Royal Rumble and was eliminated by CM Punk, becoming the first man eliminated from the match." - grammatical error.
Impersonations; 'Damien Mizdow' (2014–present)
[edit]- "He turned face for the first time in his WWE career, when he finally split away from The Miz at WrestleMania 31 in the Battle Royal, only to be eliminated last by the winner, Big Show." - how they split?
- A new section should be made after his feud with The Miz or the better title should be given to this sub-section. This is because the 'Damien Mizdow' gimmick stays only half way mark.
Other media
[edit]- "Haddad regularly appears in Xavier Woods' YouTube channel UpUpDownDown." - citation needed, I would suggest the YouTube channel itself.
In wrestling
[edit]- "Diving elbow drop – 2015; parodied from "Macho Man" Randy Savage" - citation needed.
- Reference to The Miz and Curtis Axel working as Sandow's manager is not given as parameters in this section.
- Why Cody Rhodes isn't mentioned in the list of wrestlers he managed and his managers. They were a long time tag partner.
- "The Stunt Double" nickname parameter reference needed.
- Many parameter references are needed in the "Championships and accomplishments" section.
Additional Comments
[edit]"Personal life" section is less informative. This article might just become a good piece if my desired minor changes are made. Therefore, I keep this on hold for 7 days.
- Edits are going on well, so the deadline is expanded to more 3 days. It is on 17 January. Ikhtiar H (talk) 08:11, 15 January 2016 (UTC)
Result
[edit]The review was kept on hold for 10 days but only half of the problems are solved. The deadline has been crossed and time has come to finalize: it fails. Certainly, I am a censorious reviewer! I hope this article will pass one day in the future. Ikhtiar H (talk) 16:24, 18 January 2016 (UTC)