R. B. Braithwaite

This article is about the philosopher. For the poet, see Richard Braithwait.

R. B. Braithwaite FBA
Born	Richard Bevan Braithwaite (1900-01-15)15 January 1900 Banbury, England
Died	21 April 1990(1990-04-21) (aged 90) Cambridge, England
Alma mater	King's College, Cambridge
Spouse	Margaret Masterman ​ ​ (m. 1932; died 1986)​
Era	Contemporary philosophy
Region	Western philosophy
School	Analytic philosophy
Academic advisors	G. E. Moore
Doctoral students	Imre Lakatos, Stephan Körner
Main interests	Philosophy of religion
Notable ideas	The existence of logical features common to all the sciences The nature of religious belief Half-belief

Richard Bevan Braithwaite FBA (15 January 1900 – 21 April 1990) was an English philosopher who specialized in the philosophy of science, ethics, and the philosophy of religion.

Life

Braithwaite was born in Banbury, Oxfordshire, son of the historian of early Quaker history, William Charles Braithwaite. He was educated at Sidcot School, Somerset (1911–14), and Bootham School, York, 1914–18. As a conscientious objector in the First World War, he served in the Friends' Ambulance Unit.

He entered King's College, Cambridge, in 1919 to study physics and mathematics, became an Apostle, and gained a BA in 1923 and MA in 1926. He was a Fellow of King's College, Cambridge from 1924 to 1990. He was appointed Cambridge University Lecturer in Moral Sciences in 1928.

He was a lecturer in moral science at the University of Cambridge from 1934 to 1953, then Knightbridge Professor of Moral Philosophy there from 1953 to 1967. He was president of the Aristotelian Society from 1946 to 1947, and was elected a Fellow of the British Academy in 1957.

He was married (secondly) to the computational linguist and philosopher Margaret Masterman, with whom he founded the Epiphany Philosophers a group of (largely) Anglicans and Quakers seeking a new view of the relationship between philosophy and science.

Work

Although he was positivistically inclined, Braithwaite was a Christian, having been brought up a Quaker and becoming an Anglican later. According to theologian Alister McGrath, Braithwaite's 1955 Eddington Memorial Lecture "An Empiricist's View of the Nature of Religious Belief" is to date the most widely cited publication (e.g. by Anglican priest Don Cupitt) in a genre of 1970s–1980s theological works arguing that "God" and "religion" are human constructs—having no independent reality of their own—and that human dignity and freedom may best be advanced by systematic deconstruction of these two ideas, although Braithwaite himself had little sympathy for vague claims like these.

Braithwaite believed that religious utterances had to do with emotions and were therefore not descriptions in the sense that a hypothesis is, religious belief is not "ordinary belief" like a belief in a proposition. He argued that religious utterances are to be understood as "declarations of adherence to a policy of action, declarations of commitment to a way of life". A religious belief is an "intention to behave in a certain way together with the entertainment of certain stories associated with the intention in the mind of the believer". These stories "might psychologically support the resolution but it does not logically justify it". He also spoke about religious contradictions, which Braithwaite believed were permissible, in contrast to contradictions of empirical propositions where believing contradictions is "disastrous" due to the "courses of action appropriate" to these propositions being incompatible.

Braithwaite remarked on a difference between secular morality and religious morality, with secular morality being focused on conduct or 'external life' whereas religious morality focused on both inner life and "outward conduct". This meant that "the superiority of religious conviction over the mere adoption of a moral code in securing conformity to the code arises from a religious conviction changing what the religious man wants. It may be hard enough to love your enemy, but once you have succeeded in doing so it is easy to behave lovingly towards him. But if you continue to hate him, it requires heroic perseverance continually to behave as if you loved him. Resolutions to feel, even if they are only partly fulfilled, are powerful reinforcements of resolutions to act". He also argued that one aspect of all 'moral theistic religions' which was of "great psychological value", in that it enabled religious individuals to persevere, was that they are performing the will of God.

His major work was his book Scientific Explanation: A Study of the Function of Theory, Probability and Law in Science (1953) but, like his Eddington Lecture it was his inaugural lecture ("Theory of Games as a Tool for the Moral Philosopher") that was his more original contribution: although a logician and philosopher of science, he had been elected to a chair of moral philosophy (ethics) about which he considered he knew little. His inaugural lecture attempted to bring what he did know about the theory of games into some relation with ethical reasoning and, in doing that, he effectively started a whole new field of study, namely, how game-theoretic considerations are related to ethical ones. The topic of the lecture was the bargaining approach to distributive justice. In early writings, he called game theories 'a tool for the moral philosopher'.

After his retirement in 1967, Braithwaite was a visiting professor at Johns Hopkins University where he lectured on game theory and encouraged one of his students, Alexander Rosenberg, to apply the approach of Scientific Explanation to economics.

It was Braithwaite's poker that Ludwig Wittgenstein reportedly brandished at Karl Popper during their confrontation at a Moral Sciences Club meeting in Braithwaite's rooms in King's. The implement subsequently disappeared. Braithwaite was a friend of Frank P. Ramsey (about whom he was interviewed by D.H. Mellor on BBC Radio in 1978) and, after Ramsey's early death, edited a collection of his papers.

A Festschrift, Science, Belief and Behaviour: Essays in Honour of R. B. Braithwaite, edited by D. H. Mellor, was published in 1980. It included essay contributions from Mellor himself and Ian Hacking amongst others.

Select publications

• Moral principles and inductive policies (1952) [from Proceedings of the British Academy 36 (1950): 51–68.]
• Scientific Explanation: A Study of the Function of Theory, Probability and Law in Science (1953)
• Theory of Games as a Tool for the Moral Philosopher (1955)
• An Empiricist's View of the Nature of Religious Belief (1955)

For a more complete list of works see "Bibliography of the philosophical writings of R. B. Braithwaite" or his entry at PhilPapers.

Further reading

• Mellor, D. H. (1990). "R. B. Braithwaite (1900–1990)". The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science, 41(4), 579–580.
• Hesse, M. (1993) 'Richard Bevan Braithwaite, 1900–1990' Proceedings of the British Academy, 82, 367–80.

External links

• "Laws of Nature and Explanation" (1973) – filmed discussion between Braithwaite and Kenneth Baublys chaired by Oswald Hanfling for the Open University transcript
• Richard Bevan Braithwaite – 1930s photographic portrait by Ramsey & Muspratt at the National Portrait Gallery, London