Jump to content

Moving the goalposts

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
(Redirected from Post disputation argument)

Moving the goalposts (or shifting the goalposts) is a metaphor, derived from goal-based sports such as football and hockey, that means to change the rule or criterion ("goal") of a process or competition while it is still in progress, in such a way that the new goal offers one side an advantage or disadvantage.[1]

Etymology

[edit]
Look up move the goalposts or shift the goalposts in Wiktionary, the free dictionary.

This phrase is British in origin and derives from sports that use goalposts.[2][3] The figurative use alludes to the perceived unfairness in changing the goal one is trying to achieve after the process one is engaged in (such as a game of football) has already started.[1]

Logical fallacy

[edit]

Moving the goalposts is an informal fallacy in which evidence presented in response to a specific claim is dismissed and some other (often greater) evidence is demanded. That is, after an attempt has been made to score a goal, the goalposts are moved to exclude the attempt.[4] The problem with changing the rules of the game is that the meaning of the result is changed, too.[5]

Use

[edit]

Some include this metaphor as description of the tactics of harassment. In such cases, a re-defining of another's goals may in reality be intentionally devised so as to assure that an athlete, for example, will ultimately never be able to finally achieve the ever shifting goals.[6] In workplace bullying, shifting the goalposts is a conventional tactic in the process of humiliation.[7]

Karl Popper coined the concept conventionalist twist or conventionalist stratagem in Conjectures and Refutations with similar use as this fallacy but in the context of the falsifiability of certain scientific theories.[8]

Non-metaphorical use

[edit]
Goalposts in ice hockey may be knocked from their moorings during a game.

Deliberately moving the goalposts constitutes a professional foul in rugby football and an unfair act in gridiron football. The officials are granted carte blanche to assess whatever penalty they see fit, including awarding the score for any attempt at a goal missed or invalidating any goal scored as a result of the moved goalposts. In both rugby and gridiron, goalposts are anchored into the ground; the distance they can be moved (most easily in gridiron by pulling down on one end of the crossbar to tilt both posts either to the left or the right) is far more restricted.[citation needed] Inadvertently moving the goalposts in a touchdown celebration is an unsportsmanlike conduct penalty of 15 yards against the offending team.

Moving goalposts is common in ice hockey, where physical contact with the posts is common. If the goalposts are knocked off their moorings in the course of play, play is stopped until the goal is put back in place. If the goalposts are deliberately moved to stop an opponent from scoring, the opponent may be granted a penalty shot; if the goaltender does so, the goaltender may be ejected from the game, a rule imposed at most levels of the game in 2014 after David Leggio deliberately moved the goalposts during a two-person breakaway, believing he would have a better chance of stopping a penalty shot.[9][10] Leggio later used the tactic in the Deutsche Eishockey Liga, where he had played since 2015; that league had not yet outlawed the maneuver,[11] but promptly did so after Leggio's first attempt at using the tactic.[12] The DEL instead automatically awards the goal to the opposing team.[12] The National Hockey League approved this rule in 2019.[13]

In 2009, Danish goalkeeper Kim Christensen was recorded on camera moving the goalposts in order to gain advantage over the opposing team. Christensen's moving the goalposts was discovered by a referee about 20 minutes into the game, but Christensen did not suffer a suspension or any fines for his actions.[14][15]

In May 2022, a scandal erupted when video published by Aftenposten showed Viking FK's goalkeeper Patrik Gunnarsson reducing his goal size by moving the goalposts by 15–20 centimetres (6–8 in), after the referee inspection but prior to kickoff, in home games during the 2022 season.[16][17][18]

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
  1. ^ a b "Moving the goalposts". Phrases.org.uk. Retrieved 2011-12-20.
  2. ^ "move/shift the goalposts". Merriam-Webster.com Dictionary. Merriam-Webster.
  3. ^ Safire, William (28 October 1990). "On Language; Moving the Goalposts". The New York Times. Retrieved 1 February 2017.
  4. ^ Clark, Jef; Clark, Theo (2005). Humbug! The Skeptic's Field Guide to Spotting Fallacies in Thinking. p. 101. ISBN 0-646-44477-8.
  5. ^ Hobbs, Jeremy (November 21, 2011). "Moving the Goal Posts". The New York Times. Retrieved February 19, 2013.
  6. ^ Royal College of Psychiatrists, "On Bullying and Harassment" retrieved 2012-2-19.
  7. ^ Field, Tim. (1995). Bully in Sight: How to Predict, Resist, Challenge and Combat Workplace Bullying, p. 60.
  8. ^ Popper, Karl. "Conjectures and Refutations". Internet Archive. Retrieved 29 September 2024.
  9. ^ Dhiren Mahiban (November 6, 2014). Report: AHL changes rule following Leggio incident. ProHockeyTalk.com. Retrieved November 7, 2014.
  10. ^ "Video:AHL goalie Leggio intentionally dislodges net". CBS Sports. 2014-11-02. Retrieved 2014-11-02.
  11. ^ Schlager, Brandon (2017-12-09). "David Leggio is up to his old tricks". Sporting News. Retrieved 2017-12-10.
  12. ^ a b Leahy, Sarah (13 December 2017). "Another league changes its rules, thanks to David Leggio". NBC Sports. Retrieved 13 December 2017.
  13. ^ Hardev (June 20, 2019). "Gary Bettman announces new rules for next season". Pension Plan Puppets. Retrieved September 29, 2023.
  14. ^ "Keeper guilty of moving goalposts". BBC Sport. 24 September 2009. Retrieved 1 February 2017.
  15. ^ Rose, Ellie (25 September 2009). "Kim Christensen admits moving the goalposts". The Guardian. Retrieved 1 February 2017.
  16. ^ "Goalkeeper Patrik Gunnarsson accused of making his goal smaller!". Marca. 31 May 2022.
  17. ^ Stig Nilssen; Alexander Larsen; Mats Haugland (30 May 2022). "Se video og bilder: Viking-keeperen flytter stolpene og gjør målet mindre: – Ser ikke bra ut" (in Norwegian). Aftenposten.
  18. ^ "Scandalo nel calcio norvegese, il portiere del Viking FK Patrik Gunnarsson accusato di 'truccare' la sua porta" (in Italian). La Stampa. June 2022.
Retrieved from "https://wiki.riteme.site/w/index.php?title=Moving_the_goalposts&oldid=1248541642"