Islamic flag
An Islamic flag is the flag either representing an Islamic Caliphate, religious order, state, civil society, military force or other entity associated with Islam. Islamic flags have a distinct history due to the Islamic prescription on aniconism, making particular colours, inscriptions or symbols such as crescent-and-star popular choices. Since the time of the Islamic prophet Muhammad, flags with certain colours were associated with Islam according to the traditions. Since then, historical Caliphates, modern nation states, certain denominations as well as religious movements have adopted flags to symbolize their Islamic identity. Some secular states and ethnic or national movements also use symbols of Islamic origin as markers of heritage and identity.
History
[edit]Early Islam
[edit]Before the advent of Islam, banners as tools for signaling had already been employed by the pre-Islamic Arab tribes and the Byzantines. Early Muslim army naturally deployed banners for the same purpose.[1] Early Islamic flags, however, greatly simplified its design by using plain color, due to the Islamic prescriptions on aniconism.[2] According to the Islamic traditions, the Quraysh had a black banner and a white-and-black banner.[3] It further states that Muhammad had a banner in white nicknamed "the Young Eagle" (Arabic: العقاب, al-ʿuqāb); and a flag in black, said to be made from his wife Aisha's head-cloth.[4] This larger flag was known as the "Banner of the Eagle" (Arabic: الراية العقاب, romanized: al-rāyat al-ʿuqāb), as well as the "Black Banner" (Arabic: الراية السوداء, romanized: al-rāyat as-sawdāʾ).[5] In the Islamic tradition, Muhammad used the white flag to represent both the leader of the Muslim army and the Muslim state.[6] Other examples are the prominent Arab military commander 'Amr ibn al-'As using a red banner,[7] and the Khawarij rebels using a red banner as well.[8] Banners of the early Muslim armies in general, however, employed a variety of colors, both singly and in combination.[9]
The Umayyad Caliphate, which ruled the largest geographical extent of the medieval Islamic Empire,[10] adopted white flags.[11] During the Abbasid Revolution, the Abbasids incorporated the Black Standard based on the early Islamic eschatological saying that "a people coming from the East with black banners" would herald the arrival of the messianic figure Mahdi.[12] The Shiite Alids chose the color of white to distinguish themselves from the Abbasids,[8] but also adopted green flags.[11] Thus in 817, when the Abbasid caliph al-Ma'mun adopted the Alid Ali al-Ridha as his heir apparent, he also changed the dynastic color from black to green. The change was reverted when al-Ma'mun had Ali killed, and returned to Baghdad in 819.[13] The Abbasids continued to use black as their dynastic color. However, their caliphal banner was made of white silk with the Quranic inscriptions. The white color was then adopted, in deliberate opposition to the Abbasids, by the Ismaili Shiite Fatimid Caliphate, and cemented the association of black and white with Sunni and Shia respectively.[14] It was also used by the Almohads.[15] The Fatimid caliphal banner was decorated in red and yellow, sometimes emblazoned with the picture of a lion.[14] Early Muslim rulers are generally not known to have used emblems of a distinctly dynastic, religious, or personal nature.[16]
-
Black standards are attributed to Muhammad and were used by the Abbasid Caliphate
-
The Umayyad Caliphate, Fatimid Caliphate and Almohad Caliphate used white standards. White flags are also attributed to Muhammad.
-
Green flags were sometimes used by Shi'ites.
-
The Kharjites used red standards
Middle Ages
[edit]The Ayyubids and Mamluks, succeeding the Fatimid caliphate, retained the association with yellow. The Ayyubid founder Saladin carried a yellow flag adorned with an eagle. Mamluk sultanic banners were yellow, but on occasion they used red banners.[14] Mongol and Turkic dynasties to the east, including the Ilkhanate, Oghuz Turks and the Seljuq dynasty, preferred the white banner.[17] Religious flags with inscriptions were in use in the medieval period, as shown in miniatures by 13th-century illustrator Yahya ibn Mahmud al-Wasiti. 14th-century illustrations of the History of the Tatars by Hayton of Corycus (1243) shows both Mongols and Seljuqs using a variety of war ensigns.
The crescent appears in flags attributed to Tunis from as early as the 14th century Book of Knowledge of All Kingdoms, long before Tunis fell under Ottoman rule in 1574. The Spanish Navy Museum in Madrid shows two Ottoman naval flags dated 1613; both are swallow-tailed, one green with a white crescent near the hoist, the other white with two red stripes near the edges of the flag and a red crescent near the hoist.[18][unreliable source]
The hexagram was also a popular symbol among the Islamic flags. It is known in Arabic as Khātem Sulaymān (Seal of Solomon; خاتم سليمان) or Najmat Dāūd (Star of David; نجمة داوود). The "Seal of Solomon" may also be represented by a five-pointed star or pentagram. In the Qur'an, it is written that David and King Solomon (Arabic, Suliman or Sulayman) were prophets and kings, and are figures revered by Muslims. The Medieval pre-Ottoman Hanafi Anatolian beyliks of the Karamanids and Jandarids used the star on their flag.[19][full citation needed]
The Mamluks served the Custodian of the Two Holy Mosques during their reign. During this time, they deployed what was believed to be the genuine relic of the Islamic prophet Muhammad's banner. The banner was later captured by the Ottomans, who called the flag the "noble banner" (Sancak-ı Şerif) and used it during their military campaign. The flag was made of black wool, according to the Ottoman historian Silahdar Findiklili Mehmed Agha, but there is no further information available.[20]
-
The Ayyubid yellow standard
-
A flag of the Mamluk Sultanate according to the Catalan Atlas
Pre-modern era
[edit]- Ottoman Empire
War flags came into use by the Ottoman Empire in the 16th century, gradually replacing (but long coexisting with) their traditional tugh or horse-tail standards. During the 16th and 17th centuries, war flags often depicted the bifurcated sword of Ali, Zulfiqar, which was often misinterpreted in Western literature as showing a pair of scissors.[21] A Zulfiqar flag used by Selim I (d. 1520) is on exhibit in Topkapı Palace.[22] Two Zulfiqar flags are also depicted in a plate dedicated to Turkish flags in vol. 7 of Bernard Picart's Cérémonies et coutumes religieuses de tous les peuples du monde (1737), attributed to the Janissaries and Sipahis.
Tanzimat of 1844, the flags of the Ottoman Empire were redesigned in the style of European armies of the day. The flag of the Ottoman Navy was made red as red was to be the flag of secular institutions and green of religious ones. As the reforms abolished all the various sub-sultanates, pashaliks, beyliks and emirates, a single new flag was designed to replace all the various flags used by these entities with one single national flag. The result was the red and white flag with the crescent moon and star, which is the precursor to the modern Turkish flag. A plain red flag was introduced as the civil ensign for all Ottoman subjects.
-
An early 19th-century example of a Zulfiqar flag
-
The flag of the Ottoman Empire (1844–1922)
- Mughal Empire
The Mughal Empire had a number of imperial flags and standards. The principal imperial standard of the Mughals was known as the alam (Alam علم). It was primarily moss green.[23] It displayed a lion and sun (Shir-u-khurshid شیر و خورشید) facing the hoist of the flag.[24] The Mughals traced their use of the alam back to Timur.[25] The imperial standard was displayed to the right of the throne and also at the entrance of the Emperor's encampment and in front of the emperor during military marches.[25]
According to the Ain-i-Akbari, during Akbar's reign, whenever the emperor rode out, not less than five alams were carried along with the qur (a collection of flags and other insignia) wrapped up in scarlet cloth bags. They were unfurled on the days of festivity, and in battle.[26] Edward Terry, chaplain to Sir Thomas Roe, who came during the reign of Jahangir, described in his Voyage to East-India (1655) that the royal standard, made of silk, with a crouching lion shadowing part of the body of the sun inscribed on it, was carried on an elephant whenever the emperor travelled.[27][28]
-
Alam of the Mughal Empire
-
Flag of the Mughal Empire (1857)
- Persian Empires
The Safavid dynasty (1501–1736) employed various alams and banners, especially during the reign of the first two kings, each with a different emblem. Ismail I, the first Safavid king, designed a green flag with a golden full moon. In 1524 Tahmasp I replaced the moon with an emblem of a sheep and sun; this flag was used until 1576. It was then that Ismail II adopted the first Lion and Sun device, embroidered in gold, which was to remain in use until the end of the Safavid era. During this period the Lion and Sun stood for two pillars of the society: the state and Islam.
The Afsharid dynasty (1736–1796) had two royal standards, one with red, white, and blue stripes and one with red, blue, white, and yellow stripes. Nader Shah's personal flag was a yellow pennant with a red border and a lion and sun emblem in the centre. All three of these flags were triangular in shape.[29][30] Nader Shah consciously avoided the using the colour green, as green was associated with Shia Islam and the Safavid dynasty.[31]
-
Flag of Safavid dynasty after Ismail II (1576–1732)
-
An Imperial Standard of the Afsharid dynasty
Modern history
[edit]- Flags of the Mahdiyya
Muhammad Ahmad declared himself al-Mahdī al-Muntaẓar (the Expected Rightly-guided One, successor to the prophet Mohammed) in 1881 and lead an Islamic revolution against the Ottoman-Egyptian rule of Sudan until his death in 1885.[32] During the Mahdist War, the followers of al-Mahdi (Anṣār or ‘helpers’) adapted a traditional form of flag used in prayer by followers of Sufi religious orders, for military purposes.[33] Sufi flags typically feature the Muslim shahada – “There is no God but Allah; Muḥammad is God’s Messenger” – and the name of the sect's founder, an individual usually regarded as a saint.[33] The traditional form of Sufi flag was adapted by adding a quotation from the Quran – “Yā allah yā ḥayy yā qayūm yā ḍhi’l-jalāl wa’l-ikrām” (O God! O Ever-living, O Everlasting, O Lord of Majesty and Generosity) – and the highly charged claim - “Muḥammad al-Mahdī khalifat rasūl Allah” (Muḥammad al-Mahdī is the successor of God's messenger). The flags were specifically colour coded to direct soldiers of the three main divisions of the Mahdist army – the Black, Green and Red Banners (rāyāt).
- Star and crescent
By the mid 20th century, the star and crescent was used by a number successor states of the Ottoman Empire, including Algeria, Azerbaijan, Mauritania, Tunisia, Turkey, the Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus and Libya. Because of its supposed "Turkic" associations, the symbol also came to be used in Central Asia, as in the flags of Turkmenistan and Uzbekistan. The star-and-crescent in the Flag of Pakistan is stated as symbolizing "progress and light" (while the green colour is stated as representing Islam). The star-and-crescent in these flags was not originally intended as religious symbolism, but an association of the symbol with Islam seems to have developed beginning in the 1950s or 1960s.[34] By the 1970s, this symbol was embraced by both Arab nationalism or Islamism, such as the proposed Arab Islamic Republic (1974) and the American Nation of Islam (1973).[35]
- The Pan-Arab flag and colours
The Pan-Arab colors were first introduced in 1916, with the Flag of the Arab Revolt. Although they represent secular Arab nationalism as opposed to Islamism, the choice of colours has been explained by Islamic symbolism in retrospect, so by Mahdi Abdul Hadi in Evolution of the Arab Flag (1986): black as the Black Standard of Muhammad, the Rashidun Caliphate and the Abbasid Caliphate, white as the flag of the Umayyad Caliphate, green as the flag of the Fatimid Caliphate and red as the flag of the Khawarij. On 30 1917 Hussein bin Ali, Sharif of Mecca, leader of the Arab Revolt replaced his plain red flag with one horizontally striped in black, green, and white with a red triangular area at the hoist. This was seen as the birth of the pan-Arab flag. Since that time, many Arab nations, upon achieving independence or upon change of political regime, have used a combination of these colours in a design reflecting the Hejaz Revolt flag. These flags include the current flags of Iraq, Syria, Yemen, Egypt, Kuwait, United Arab Emirates, Jordan, Palestinian National Authority, Algeria, and Sudan, and former flags of Iraq and Libya.
-
The flag of the Arab Revolt (1916)[36]
-
The flag of the Arab Islamic Republic (1974)
Contemporary flags
[edit]Islamic states
[edit]This section needs additional citations for verification. (February 2024) |
The modern conceptualization of the Islamic state is attributed to Abul A'la Maududi (1903–1979), a Pakistani Muslim theologian who founded the political party Jamaat-e-Islami and inspired other Islamic revolutionaries such as Ruhollah Khomeini. Six internationally recognized states identify as Islamic states: Saudi Arabia (formed 1932 out of the Wahhabist predecessor states), Pakistan (since 1947), Mauritania (since 1958), Iran (since 1979), Yemen (since 1991). The majority of countries of the Arab world define Islam as their state religion. Most of these states have national flags that include Islamic symbolism. Besides these, there have been unrecognized jihadist de facto states, such as the Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant which at one time controlled parts of Iraq and Syria, the unrecognized government of the Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan, and Al-Shabaab and Boko Haram ruling parts of Somalia and Nigeria respectively, which use jihadist flags.
Some flags of Muslim states use inscribed flags, either with the shahada, as in the flags of Saudi Arabia, or in the case of the 1979 Islamic Republic of Iran, stylized writing of the word Allah. The flag of Iraq uses the pan-Arab colours since 1921, with the addition of the takbir since 1991. The practice of inscribing the shahada on flags may go back the 18th century, used by the Wahhabi religious movement.[37] In 1902 Ibn Saud, leader of the House of Saud and the future founder of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, added a sword to this flag.[37] The current flag of Saudi Arabia is a continuation of the flag of Emirate of Nejd and Hasa introduced in 1902. The First East Turkestan Republic of 1933 used it on their flag, and the Taliban introduced it on their flag of Afghanistan in 1997.
With inscription
[edit]-
The flag of Saudi Arabia (1932, based on a 1921 variant), the shahada and a sword on a green field
-
The flag of Afghanistan, displaying the phrase: "There is no god but Allah. Mohamed is the messenger of Allah" in Arabic
-
The Flag of Iran (1980), a highly stylized emblem representing the word Allah
-
The Flag of Iraq containing colors of the Arab Liberation flag, with takbīr ʾAllāhu ʾakbaru (ٱللَّٰهُ أَكْبَرُ), meaning "God is greater / the greatest[38] in Kufic script written in the center.
With crescent and star
[edit]-
The Flag of Mauritania (2017, variants since 1959), star-and-crescent on green
-
The Flag of Pakistan has a dark green to symbolize the Muslim-majority population, and it is also one of the many Muslim flags with a star-and-crescent.
With crescent
[edit]-
Flag of Maldives
With Eagle of Saladin
[edit]-
Flag of the President of the Kurdistan Region, Iraq
-
Standard of the President of United Arab Republic (1958–1971)
With Hawk of Quraish
[edit]Without religious symbolism
[edit]-
The flag of Yemen (1990), in spite of the constitutional definition of Yemen as an Islamic state, does not include religious symbolism.
Multinational organizations
[edit]Denominational flags
[edit]Although a flag representing Islam as a whole does not exist, some Islamic denominational branches and Sufi brotherhoods employ flags to symbolize themselves. Among specific Islamic branches, Nizari branch of Ismaili-Shia Islam employs an official flag made of green which represents Muhammad's standard and Ali's cloak, as well as a red stripe meaning blood and fire. The flag was ordained by the Aga Khan IV as a part of the new constitution in 1986. The flag is flown on the Ismaili Jamatkhana, a place for congregational worship for Ismaili Muslims during the festive occasions.[39] The Ahmadiyya movement also employs an official flag (Liwaa-i Ahmadiyya) with black and white colors, first hoisted in 1939.[40] Mirza Tahir Ahmad, the fourth caliph of the Ahmadiyya Caliphate, explained the symbolism of the colours black and white in terms of the concept of revelation and prophethood.[41] Muslim African-American religious movement Nation of Islam deploys an official flag known as "The Flag of Islam" which symbolizes universal peace and harmony.[42] Some Muslim communities organized on a national basis by official corporate bodies that have specific denominational commitments, such as the Islamic Community in Bosnia and Herzegovina or the Chief Muftiate (Главно мюфтийство) of Bulgaria, also have flags.
In Shia Muslim traditions, flags are a significant part of the rituals for the Mourning of Muharram. Mourners take round the flags or banners in the ritual known as Alam Gardani as a performance for the mourning ceremonies. Mourners also use flags to signal the beginning and the end of the mourning. All flags have guardians and they are passed down through generations.[43]
-
The Nation of Islam flag (1973)
-
The Khatmiyya tariqa flag
-
Flag of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jama'at (AMJ)
-
Flag of the Islamic Community in Bosnia and Herzegovina
-
Flag of the Chief Muftiate of Bulgaria
See also
[edit]References
[edit]Footnotes
[edit]- ^ Hathaway 2003, p. 95.
- ^ Flag. Britannica. Retrieved February 15, 2019.
- ^ Hinds 1996, p. 133.
- ^ Nicolle 1993, p. 6.
- ^ Hinds 1996, p. 108.
- ^ The Islamic Imagery Project The Combating Terrorism Center Retrieved 27 May 2023
- ^ Nour, “L’Histoire du croissant,” p. 66/295. See also Ibn Khaldun, Muqaddimah, pp. 214–15.
- ^ a b Wellhausen 1927, p. 533.
- ^ Hathaway 2003, pp. 95–96.
- ^ Nardo, Don (12 September 2011). The Islamic Empire. Greenhaven Publishing LLC. ISBN 9781420508024.
- ^ a b David-Weill, J. (1960). "ʿAlam". In Gibb, H. A. R.; Kramers, J. H.; Lévi-Provençal, E.; Schacht, J.; Lewis, B. & Pellat, Ch. (eds.). The Encyclopaedia of Islam, Second Edition. Volume I: A–B. Leiden: E. J. Brill. p. 349. doi:10.1163/1573-3912_islam_SIM_0497. OCLC 495469456.
- ^ Muhammad b. Yazid b. Maja (d. 887), Sunan, ed. Muhammad Fu˘ad ˜Abd al-Baqi, 2 vols. (Cairo: Halabi, 1372/1952), vol. 2: 1366–67; ˜Ala al-Din ˜Ali b. Husam al-Din al-Muttaqi (1477–1567), Kanz al-˜ummål, 8 parts (Hyderabad: Da˘irat al-Ma˜arif, 1312/1894–95), part 3: 203; part 4: 38, 39, 45, 53
- ^ Kennedy, Hugh (2004). The Prophet and the Age of the Caliphates: The Islamic Near East from the 6th to the 11th Century (Second ed.). Harlow: Longman. pp. 152–153, 161. ISBN 978-0-582-40525-7.
- ^ a b c Hathaway 2003, pp. 96–97.
- ^ Amira K. Bennison (2016). Almoravid and Almohad Empires. Edinburgh University Press. p. 101. ISBN 978-0-7486-4682-1.
Pascal Buresi, Hicham El Aallaoui (2012). Governing the Empire: Provincial Administration in the Almohad Caliphate (1224-1269). BRILL. p. 76. ISBN 978-90-04-23333-1.
Amira K. Bennison, Alison L. Gascoigne (2007). Cities in the Pre-Modern Islamic World The Urban Impact of Religion, State and Society. Routledge. p. 88. ISBN 978-1-134-09650-3. - ^ Grabar 2005, p. 252.
- ^ Hathaway 2003, p. 98.
- ^ Nozomi Karyasu & António Martins, 8 October 2006 on Flags of the World.
- ^ The Muslim Empires of the Ottomans, Safavids, and Mughals, By Stephen F. Dale, 2009
- ^ Hathaway 2003, pp. 97–8.
- ^ e.g. Jaques Nicolas Bellin, Tableau des Pavillons de le nations que aborent à la mer (1756).
- ^ "Ottoman Empire: Flags and coats of arms shown in the Topkapi Museum (Istanbul)". www.crwflags.com.
- ^ "Zoomify image: A panorama in 12 folds showing the procession of the Emperor Bahadur Shah to celebrate the feast of the 'Id. f. 59v-A". Bl.uk. 30 November 2003. Archived from the original on 23 March 2019. Retrieved 17 April 2022.
- ^ "Alam – The Flag of the Mughals". Mumbai: Khadi Dyers & Printers. Archived from the original on 21 November 2010. Retrieved 26 February 2010.
primarily moss green and some flags were scarlet. Against a green field it displayed a rising sun, partially eclipsed by a body of a couching lion facing the hoist
- ^ a b Singh, K.V. (1991). Our National Flag. New Delhi: Publication Division, Ministry of Information & Broadcasting, Government of India. p. 14.
- ^ Blochmann, H. (tr.) (1927, reprint 1993). The Ain-I Akbari by Abu'l-Fazl Allami, Vol. I, Calcutta: The Asiatic Society, p.52
- ^ Foster, William (ed.) (1921) Early Travels in India, 1583–1619, London: Oxford University Press, p. 306
- ^ Terry, Edward (1777) [1655]. A Voyage to East-India. London: J. Wilkie. p. 347.
- ^ "Flags of the World: Persia (Iran) from XVI to XVIIIth century". Retrieved 11 November 2010.
- ^ "The Lion and Sun Motif of Iran: A brief Analysis". Retrieved 12 November 2010.
- ^ "Encyclopædia Iranica: FLAGS i. Of Persia". Retrieved 12 November 2010.
- ^ Mahdi Flag. National Portrait Gallery. Retrieved December 19, 2020.
- ^ a b Flags of the Mahdiyya. Making African Connections. Retrieved December 19, 2020.
- ^ The symbolism of the star and crescent in the flag of the Kingdom of Libya (1951–1969) was explained in an English language booklet, The Libyan Flag & The National Anthem, issued by the Ministry of Information and Guidance of the Kingdom of Libya (year unknown, cited after Jos Poels at FOTW, 1997) as follows: "The crescent is symbolic of the beginning of the lunar month according to the Muslim calendar. It brings back to our minds the story of the Hijra (migration) of our Prophet Mohammed from his home in order to spread Islam and teach the principles of right and virtue. The Star represents our smiling hope, the beauty of aim and object and the light of our belief in God, in our country, its dignity and honour which illuminate our way and puts an end to darkness."
- ^ Edward E. Curtis, Black Muslim religion in the Nation of Islam, 1960–1975 (2006), p. 157.
- ^ Pan-Arab Colours, crwflags.com; Mahdi Abdul-Hadi, The Great Arab Revolt Archived 2014-05-05 at the Wayback Machine, passia.org
- ^ a b Firefly Guide to Flags of the World. Firefly Books. 2003. p. 165. ISBN 978-1552978139. Retrieved 12 September 2012.
- ^ Engber, Daniel (12 September 2006). "Why do Muslims say, "God is great?"". Slate Magazine. Retrieved 26 December 2021.
- ^ Ismaili flag & New Ismaili Constitution of 1986. Ismaili. Retrieved February 16, 2019.
- ^ "A Brief History of Ahmadiyya Movement In Islam". Alislam.org. 28 December 1939. Retrieved 23 March 2016.
- ^ "Question: Why do Muslims use black flags if the color black is associated with death and mourning?". Askislam.org. 22 October 1984. Retrieved 23 March 2016.
• "Audio Answer". Askislam.org. Archived from the original on 30 June 2015. Retrieved 27 June 2015.Black absorbs total light, [it] does not emit an iota of light, so from looking heavenly-wards black indicates that we absorb entire light from heaven, and white reflects total light without being dishonest about it, so a Messenger has two aspects. One of receiving things from Allah, in that respect he's nabi [prophet], whatever he receives he completely, totally absorbs, and when he speaks to the others he reflects the entire light without being dishonest or stingy about it, so that reflection makes it white. So reception that is a complete reception without leaving anything out and reflection that is a complete reflection without leaving anything out, they are witnessed only in two colours: black and white. So both have been employed in Islam as flags.
- ^ Brief history on origin of the Nation of Islam. Nation of Islam. Retrieved February 16, 2019.
- ^ Muharram mourning traditions in different lands – 31. Parstoday. Retrieved February 16, 2019.
Bibliography
[edit]- Grabar, Oleg (2005). "Fatimid Art, Precursor or Culmination". Early Islamic Art, 650-1100, Volume I: Constructing the Study of Islamic Art. Hampshire: Ashgate. pp. 243–255. ISBN 978-0-86078921-5., originally published in Ismaili Contributions to Islamic Culture (1977), Imperial Iranian Academy of Philosophy, pp. 207–224
- Hathaway, Jane (2003). A Tale of Two Factions: Myth, Memory, and Identity in Ottoman Egypt and Yemen. Albany, New York: State University of New York Press. ISBN 978-0-7914-5883-9.
- Hinds, Martin (1996). Studies in Early Islamic History. Darwin Press. ISBN 978-0-87850-109-0.
- Nicolle, David (1993). Armies of the Muslim Conquest. Osprey Publishing. ISBN 978-1-85532-279-0.[permanent dead link ]
- Hrbek, I. (1997). "The disintegration of political unity in the Maghrib". In Joseph Ki-Zerbo; Djibril T. Niane (eds.). General History of Africa. Vol. IV: Africa from the Twelfth to the Sixteenth Century. UNESCO, James Curry Ltd., and University of California Press.
- Sparavigna, A.C. (2016). The Sun, the Moon and the Mughal Emperors. SSRN Electronic Journal.
- Wellhausen, Julius (1927). The Arab Kingdom and its Fall. Translated by Margaret Graham Weir. Beirut: Khayats.