Jump to content

Écône consecrations

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
(Redirected from Ecône consecrations)

Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre

The Écône consecrations were Catholic episcopal consecrations in Écône, Switzerland, on 30 June 1988 performed by Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre and Bishop Antônio de Castro Mayer. The bishops consecrated were four priests of Lefebvre's Society of Saint Pius X (SSPX). The consecrations, performed against the explicit orders of Pope John Paul II, represented a milestone in the troubled relationship of Lefebvre and the SSPX with the Church leadership. The Holy See's Congregation for Bishops issued a decree signed by its Prefect Cardinal Bernardin Gantin declaring that Lefebvre and De Castro Mayer had incurred automatic excommunication by consecrating the bishops without papal consent, thus putting himself and his followers in schism.

On 24 January 2009, Pope Benedict XVI lifted the excommunications of the four bishops Lefebvre had consecrated in 1988, but the SSPX has not returned into full communion with the Holy See.

Canon law

[edit]

Under the Catholic 1983 Code of Canon Law, canon 1013, the consecration of a bishop requires the permission of the Pope;[1] and according to canon 1014 (unless a papal dispensation has been granted) at least three consecrating bishops are needed.[2] Violation of the rule requiring the Pope's permission entails automatic (latae sententiae) excommunication of both the consecrator and the recipient of the consecration.[3] In this case there was not only an absence of permission but an actual prohibition by the Pope.

Lefebvre and his supporters argued that the circumstances under which the consecrations took place were such that none of the clergy involved was truly excommunicated. One of their arguments was that a "state of necessity" existed in which the ordinary provisions of canon law could be set aside. The Pontifical Council for Legislative Texts rejected this argument, stating in a 1996 explanatory note that "there is never a necessity to ordain Bishops contrary to the will of the Roman Pontiff".[4] Consecrating a bishop without papal approval was also condemned by Pope Pius XII after the Chinese government set up the state-sanctioned Catholic Patriotic Association in 1957. Pius XII stated in Ad Apostolorum principis that the sacramental activity of illicitly consecrated bishops was "gravely" so, "that is, criminal and sacrilegious", and rejected the defence of necessity put forward by those involved.[5] Pope Pius IX, while condemning an ongoing schism in the Patriarchate of Cilicia, declared in 1873 that the right to appoint Bishops belongs to the Holy See by divine law,[6] while Pius VI, regarding the French bishop who had endorsed the civil constitution of the clergy in 1790, stated that episcopal appointments need to be confirmed by the Roman Pontiff.[7]

Announcement of the consecrations

[edit]

In the 1980s, Lefebvre's stance changed. In 1983 (at the age of 78), while in the United States, he reportedly sounded out his American priests about the prospect of him consecrating bishops. Those superiors who objected to the idea were removed from their posts as a result.[8] In 1986–1987, the Society's adherents in St Mary's, Kansas, were required to attend a series of catechetical sessions in which they were prepared for the forthcoming consecrations and their fallout.[9]

At the age of 82, Lefebvre first publicly announced his intention to consecrate bishops in a sermon at an ordination Mass in Écône on 29 June 1987, in which he declared that "Rome is in darkness, in the darkness of error", and that "the bishops of the whole world are following the false ideas of the Council with their ecumenism and liberalism". He concluded: "This is why it is likely that before I give account of my life to the good Lord, I shall have to consecrate some bishops".[10]

Discussions with the Holy See

[edit]

Lefebvre and the Holy See engaged in dialogue and, on 5 May 1988, Lefebvre and Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger (the future Pope Benedict XVI) signed the text of an agreement intended to end the dispute and open the way for the consecration of a successor to Lefebvre. In the first, doctrinal, part of the document, Lefebvre, in his own name and on behalf of the SSPX, promised fidelity to the Catholic Church and to the Pope, accepted the doctrine contained in section 25 of the Second Vatican Council's Dogmatic Constitution Lumen gentium on the Church's magisterium, pledged a non-polemical attitude of communication with the Holy See on the problematic aspects of Vatican II, recognized the validity of the revised sacraments, and promised to respect the common discipline of the Church and her law. The second, legal part of the document envisaged that the SSPX would become a Society of Apostolic Life with certain exemptions, it would have the faculty to celebrate the Tridentine rites, a special commission including two members of the SSPX to resolve conflicts, and a member of the SSPX to be consecrated as a bishop.[11]

This document was to be submitted to the Pope for his approval. However, Lefebvre quickly came to the view that he was being enticed into a trap. The very next day, he declared he was obliged in conscience to proceed, with or without papal approval, to ordain on 30 June a bishop to succeed him.[12]

A further meeting took place in Rome on 24 May. Lefebvre was now promised that the Pope would appoint a bishop from among the members of the SSPX, chosen according to the normal procedures and that the consecration would take place on 15 August, at the close of the Marian year. In return, Lefebvre would have to request reconciliation with the Pope on the basis of the protocol of 5 May. Lefebvre requested in writing that the consecration of three bishops take place on 30 June and that the majority of the members of the special commission must be from the SSPX. On the Pope's instructions, Ratzinger replied on 30 May to Lefebvre concerning these requests, "[O]n the question of the commission, whose purpose was to favour reconciliation, not to make decisions, the Holy Father [i.e., the Pope] thought it best to keep to the agreement that Lefebvre had signed on 5 May"; on the question of the ordination of bishops, the Pope reiterated his readiness to speed up the usual process so as to nominate a member of the Society to be consecrated on 15 August, and Lefebvre was asked to provide the necessary information on candidates for this purpose, but, Ratzinger added, "Since you have announced again recently your intention to ordain three bishops on 30 June with or without the agreement of Rome, you must state clearly that you entrust yourself to the Holy Father's decision in full obedience".[13]

Consecration of four bishops

[edit]

On 3 June, Lefebvre wrote from Écône, stating that he intended to proceed with the consecrations. On 9 June, the Pope replied to him with a personal letter, appealing to him not to proceed with a design that "would be seen as nothing other than a schismatic act, the theological and canonical consequences of which are known to you".[14]

On 17 June, Cardinal Bernardin Gantin, Prefect of the Congregation for Bishops sent the proposed bishops a formal canonical warning that they would automatically incur the penalty of excommunication if they were ordained by Lefebvre without papal permission.[15]

On 29 June, Ratzinger sent a telegram to Lefebvre to say that "For the love of Christ and His Church, the Holy Father asks you paternally and firmly to depart today for Rome, without proceeding on 30 June with the episcopal ordinations that you have announced".[16][17]

On 30 June, Lefebvre consecrated four SSPX priests: Bernard Fellay, Bernard Tissier de Mallerais, Richard Williamson and Alfonso de Galarreta.[18] A later SSPX account said that Bishop Antônio de Castro Mayer participated with his "crucial presence" and was "found at Archbishop Lefebvre's side", but did not specifically describe him as participating in the consecration ritual.[19] However, another SSPX article says both Lefebvre and de Castro Mayer consecrated the bishops.[20]

Episcopal lineage

[edit]

The lineage originated by the 1988 consecrations amounts to 10 bishops as of 2019, out of whom 8 are alive:

Excommunications

[edit]

Two hours after the consecration, the Holy See released a statement saying Lefebvre and the four bishops he consecrated had excommunicated themselves by defying papal authority and by ignoring warnings including a last-minute appeal from John Paul II.[25]

On the following day, 1 July 1988, the Vatican's Congregation for Bishops issued a decree signed by Cardinal Bernardin Gantin, Prefect of the Congregation, declaring that Lefebvre, Fellay, Tissier de Mallerais, Williamson, de Galarreta, and de Castro Mayer had incurred automatic excommunication.[26]

On 2 July, Pope John Paul II, in his apostolic letter Ecclesia Dei, condemned the Archbishop's action, The Pope stated that, since schism is defined in canon 751 of the 1983 Code of Canon Law as "withdrawal of submission to the Supreme Pontiff or from communion with the members of the Church subject to him", the consecration "constitute[d] a schismatic act". The Pope declared: "In performing such an act, notwithstanding the formal canonical warning sent to them by the Cardinal Prefect of the Congregation for Bishops on 17 June last, Mons. Lefebvre and the priests Bernard Fellay, Bernard Tissier de Mallerais, Richard Williamson, and Alfonso de Galarreta have incurred the grave penalty of excommunication envisaged by ecclesiastical law", a reference to canon 1382 of the 1983 Code of Canon Law.[27]

Lefebvre declared that he had not withdrawn his submission to the Pope, and claimed that canons 1323 and 1324 of the Code absolved him of culpability because of the crisis in the Church.[28]

Cardinal Darío Castrillón Hoyos considered that the consecration was not a schismatic act, on the basis that Lefebvre was merely consecrating auxiliary bishops rather than attempting to establish a parallel church.[29] In line with general canonical opinion,[30] the Holy See holds that Archbishop Lefebvre committed a schismatic act, but not that he created a schismatic Church.

Accordingly, when Cardinal Edward Idris Cassidy presented a revised edition of the Vatican's Directory for the Application of Principles and Norms on Ecumenism, he stated that "[t]he situation of the members of [the SSPX] is an internal matter of the Catholic Church". Viewing Lefebvre's action as schismatic, a number of former members and supporters of the SSPX resigned or withdrew their support from the Society and joined the newly founded (and Vatican-approved) Priestly Fraternity of St. Peter.[31]

Lifting of excommunications

[edit]

By a decree of 21 January 2009, issued in response to a request that Fellay made on behalf of all four bishops whom Lefebvre had consecrated, the Prefect of the Congregation for Bishops, by the power expressly granted to him by Pope Benedict XVI, remitted the automatic excommunication that the four bishops had thereby incurred, though notably Lefebvre's name was not included in the decree.[32] The document also expressed the wish that this would be followed speedily by full communion of the whole of the Society of Saint Pius X with the Church, thus bearing witness, by the proof of visible unity, to true loyalty and true recognition of the Pope's Magisterium and authority.[33]

Fellay, superior general of SSPX, issued a statement in which the society expressed its "filial gratitude to the Holy Father for this gesture which, beyond the Priestly Society of Saint Pius X, will benefit the whole Church", and that the "[SSPX] wishes always to be more able to help the pope to remedy the unprecedented crisis which presently shakes the Catholic world, and which Pope John Paul II had designated as a state of 'silent apostasy'".[34]

Some expressed surprise at the favour that the Pope had thus shown to bishops holding such positions, with particular regard to Bishop Williamson, who was accused as a Holocaust denier. The inclusion of this bishop presented problems for Catholic-Jewish relations, culminating in the Chief Rabbinate of Israel temporarily severing ties with the Vatican in protest.[35] On 19 March 2015 Williamson was excommunicated latae sententiae following his unauthorized ordination of Jean-Michel Faure as a bishop in Nova Friburgo, Brazil. This act, done without papal mandate, also resulted in Faure's excommunication, reflecting their rejection of Roman authorities.[36]

References

[edit]
  1. ^ "Code of Canon Law: text - IntraText CT". www.intratext.com. Retrieved 29 December 2018.
  2. ^ "Code of Canon Law". Vatican. Archived from the original on 16 June 2019.
  3. ^ "Code of Canon Law: text - IntraText CT". www.intratext.com. Retrieved 29 December 2018.
  4. ^ "Library : The Excommunication of Followers of Archbishop Lefebvre". www.catholicculture.org. Retrieved 1 July 2018.
  5. ^ Pope Pius XII (1958). "Ad Apostolorum Principis". Acta Apostolicae Sedis. 50: 601–614.
  6. ^ Pope Pius IX (1873). "Quartus supra". Acta Sanctae Sedis. 7: 244–274.
  7. ^ Pope Pius VI (1791). "Quod aliquantum". Holy See.
  8. ^ "But by 1983 he was in the United States, sounding out his priests on the possibility of consecrating bishops. He asked each in turn for his view on the subject. Those Society superiors who had objected to what he and they knew would be a formally schismatic act, in a year's time were all removed from their positions. They were replaced by those priests who had gone along with the idea." Thomas W. Case, The Society of St. Pius X Gets Sick, Fidelity, October 1992. Retrieved from [1] on 5 October 2017.
  9. ^ Letters in response to "The Society of St. Pius X Gets Sick", Fidelity, December 1992. Retrieved from [2] on 5 October 2017.
  10. ^ See the sermon "Bishops to Save the Church", Marcel Lefebvre, June 1987.
  11. ^ Protocol of Agreement between the Holy See and the Priestly Society of Saint Pius X Archived 19 February 2002 at the Wayback Machine This is an English translation of the original French
  12. ^ "That is why, taking into account the strong will of the present Roman authorities to reduce Tradition to nought, to gather the world to the spirit of Vatican II and the spirit of Assisi, we have preferred to withdraw ourselves and to say that we could not continue. It was not possible. We would have evidently been under the authority of Cardinal Ratzinger, President of the Roman Commission, which would have directed us; we were putting ourselves into his hands, and consequently putting ourselves into the hands of those who wish to draw us into the spirit of the Council and the spirit of Assisi. This was simply not possible." Sermon on the occasion of the Episcopal Consecration, Marcel Lefebvre, June 1988
  13. ^ The full text of this letter, and of the whole exchange of correspondence from 8 April to 19 June can be found at SSPX site DICI Archived 31 January 2009 at the Wayback Machine
  14. ^ "Lettre de Jean-Paul II à Mgr Lefebvre du 9 juin 1988 • La Porte Latine". La Porte Latine (in French). 9 June 1988. Retrieved 9 November 2021.
  15. ^ "Monition canonique du cardinal Gantin du 17 juin 1988 • La Porte Latine". La Porte Latine (in French). 17 June 1988. Retrieved 9 November 2021.
  16. ^ Montalbano, William D. (1 July 1988). "Rebel Prelate Consecrates Bishops in Catholic Schism". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved 9 November 2021.
  17. ^ "Télégramme du cardinal Ratzinger à Mgr Lefebvre du 29 juin 1988 • La Porte Latine". La Porte Latine. 29 June 1988.
  18. ^ Greenhouse, Steven (1 July 1988). "Rebel Archbishop Anoints 4 Bishops". New York Times. Retrieved 12 October 2021.
  19. ^ "Bishop Antonio de Castro Mayer". Society of St. Pius X. 27 June 2013. Retrieved 12 October 2021. This brief biography originally appeared in the July 1991 issue of The Angelus upon Bishop De Castro Mayer's death.[permanent dead link‍]
  20. ^ "The SSPX's bishops". 15 November 2014.
  21. ^ https://web.archive.org/web/20150413092155/http://www.catholicnews.com/data/stories/cns/1501193.htm
  22. ^ "Fourth Bishop | St. Marcel Initiative". stmarcelinitiative.com. 11 March 2017. Retrieved 13 March 2017.
  23. ^ "Ex-Lefebvrist prelate illicitly consecrates a fourth bishop". international.la-croix.com. 11 January 2023. Retrieved 19 May 2023.
  24. ^ "Eleison Comments DCCCXXXV". St. Marcel Initiative. 15 July 2023. Archived from the original on 20 July 2023. Retrieved 15 July 2023.
  25. ^ "Vatican Excommunicates Lefebvre and Four Bishops He Consecrated With AM-Lefebvre Bjt". AP News. 30 June 1988. Archived from the original on 28 November 2020. Retrieved 3 June 2021.
  26. ^ "Decree of excommunication on Marcel Lefebvre". www.cin.org.
  27. ^ Pope John Paul II. "Ecclesia Dei adflicta". Acta Apostolicae Sedis. 80: 1495–1498.
  28. ^ "In the state of necessity the duty to provide help arises independently of the cause of that necessity" The 1988 Consecrations, si si no no, SSPX Asia, September 1999 No. 34
  29. ^ Castrillón Hoyos, Darío (2005). "Rapprochement by unhasty stages, but not too slow either". 30giorni.it. Interview with Gianni Cardinale. Rome. Archived from the original on 13 February 2006. Unfortunately Monsignor Lefebvre went ahead with the consecration and hence the situation of separation came about, even if it was not a formal schism.
  30. ^ Archbishop Lefebvre and Canons 1323:4° and 1324 §:5° A Canonical Study - Second Draft Edition by Peter John Vere. His study concludes: "In conclusion, having exhausted the issue from a canonical perspective, despite the Lefebvrite Movement's attempts to argue canons 1323 and 1324, there can be no doubt Archbishop Lefebvre incurred the latae sententiae excommunication reserved to the Holy See due his act of schism in consecrating bishops illicitly against the expressed instructions of the Roman Pontiff."
  31. ^ "The Priestly Fraternity of St. Peter was founded in July 1988 by 12 clerics who had been members or associates of the Society of St. Pius X. Why did they leave? They left when Archbishop Lefebvre decided to consecrate four bishops against the express will of the Holy Father." A Response to Christopher Ferrara Father Arnaud Devillers, Superior General, Priestly Fraternity of St. Peter – Summer 2002
  32. ^ "Decree remitting the excommunication "latae sententiae" of the Bishops of the Society of St Pius X". www.vatican.va. Retrieved 3 June 2021.
  33. ^ "Pope lifts excommunications of 4 bishops". NBC News. 25 January 2009. Retrieved 3 June 2021.
  34. ^ Fellay, Bernard (24 January 2009). Written at Menzingen, CH. "Press release from the Superior General of the Priestly Society of Saint Pius X" (Press release). Paris, FR: Priestly Society of Saint Pius X. Archived from the original on 24 January 2009.
  35. ^ Israel's chief rabbinate severs ties with Vatican, 24 January 2009.
  36. ^ Glatz, Carol (19 March 2015). "Bishop Williamson is excommunicated after illicitly ordaining a bishop". Catholic Herald. Archived from the original on 17 January 2019. Retrieved 21 June 2024.
Retrieved from "https://wiki.riteme.site/w/index.php?title=Écône_consecrations&oldid=1261707579"