Draft:Immunocapitalism

Immunocapitalism describes the ways in which disease outbreaks and the acquisition of immunity are leveraged for economic and political gain. The concept highlights the intersection of health, capitalism, and power, demonstrating how social and economic inequalities are exacerbated by epidemics. In some cases, individuals actively attempt to contract a disease in order to become immune to it, because of resulting benefits to their social status.

Origin of term

Santa Clara University anthropologist Mythri Jegathesan states the term was first coined by Stanford historian Kathryn Olivarius. In her paper, "Immunity, Capital, and Power in Antebellum New Orleans," published in The American Historical Review in 2019, Olivarius examined 19th-century New Orleans, where yellow fever outbreaks were rampant. She further explored the concept in her 2022 book, Necropolis: Disease, Power, and Capitalism in the Cotton Kingdom. In both works, Olivarius argues that white New Orleans elites exploited the disease to their advantage, creating a system where immunity, or the lack thereof, became a form of capital. Those who were 'acclimated' to yellow fever, having survived the disease, were granted a form of social and economic capital, while the 'unacclimated', often marginalized groups, were exploited and seen as expendable. This historical context provides a framework for understanding how health inequalities can be exploited for economic and political gain.  

It was further used during the COVID-19 pandemic, with Assistant Director of the Britain-based Nuffield Council on Bioethics Pete Mills declaring in a June 2020 report on the "Ethics of immunity testing" that "It is conceivable that some businesses, such as those in the hospitality sector, may preferentially start to employ a seropositive workforce... Economic incentives invite ‘immunocapitalism’, which puts a premium on immunity status, for example, making it worth an employer taking on an ‘immune’ worker in the belief that they are less likely to fall sick or to infect co-workers or customers.

Examples

• Yellow Fever in New Orleans: As described in Necropolis and Olivarius' earlier article, white elites in 19th-century New Orleans who survived yellow fever (and thus gained immunity) used their status to control the city's economy and politics. Immigrants and enslaved black people, lacking immunity, were seen as expendable and were forced into dangerous working conditions. A white man's perceived immunity became a form of social and economic capital. His health status translated into increased job opportunities, higher wages, easier promotions, and greater access to financial products like credit and insurance.
• COVID-19 Pandemic: The COVID-19 pandemic brought the concept of immunocapitalism into focus, raising discussions among academic philosophers about the potential for discrimination and commodification of immunity, invoking Olivarius' research. In The Pandemic Information Gap: The Brutal Economics of COVID-19, University of Toronto economist Joshua Gans states that "One could imagine innovative ways of rationing access to [COVID-19] tests when they are scarce, say, by testing in conjunction with blood donations, thereby encouraging that activity as people try to establish their immunocapital" Throughout his book, Gans cites Olivarius' work as a case study in what happens when immunity is commodified whereby lessons learned can be applied to the COVID pandemic.