Jump to content

Ahmadiyya: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Content deleted Content added
Nonenone4 (talk | contribs)
Nonenone4 (talk | contribs)
No edit summary
Line 1: Line 1:
{{Ahmadiyya}}
{{Qadiani}}
'''Ahmadiyya''' ({{lang-ur| '''احمدیہ'''}} ''Ahmadiyya'') is a religious movement founded towards the end of the [[19th century]] and originating with the life and teachings of [[Mirza Ghulam Ahmad]] (1835-1908). Ghulam Ahmad was an important religious figure who claimed to have fulfilled the prophecies about the world reformer of the [[end times]] who was to herald the [[Eschatology|Eschaton]] as predicted in the traditions of various [[World religions]] and bring about the final triumph of Islam as per Islamic prophecy. He claimed that he was the [[Mujaddid]] (divine reformer) of the 14th [[Islamic century]], the promised [[Messiah]] (“[[Second Coming of Christ]]”) and [[Mahdi]] awaited by Muslims.<ref name="hmgaintro_mma">[http://www.aaiil.org/text/books/mali/callofislam/reformermujaddiddeathjesusmessiahimammahdidajjalggogmagog.shtml “The Fourteenth-Century's Reformer / Mujaddid”, from the “Call of Islam”], by [[Maulana Muhammad Ali]]</ref><ref>[http://www.alislam.org/books/3in1/chap2/index.html Claims of Hadhrat Ahmad, Chapter Two]</ref><ref>[http://www.alislam.org/books/truth/reflection.html Reflection of all the Prophets]</ref><ref>[http://www.alislam.org/library/books/revelation/part_7_section_1.html Future of Revelation, Part 7]</ref><ref>[http://www.alislam.org/books/misunderstandingremoved.html The Removal of a Misunderstanding]</ref> Ahmadi emphasis lay in the belief that Islam is the final law for humanity as revealed to [[Muhammad]] and the necessity to restore to it, its true essence and pristine form which had been lost through the centuries. Thus, Ahmadis view themselves as leading the revival and peaceful propagation of Islam.<ref name="timesonline.co.uk">[http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/comment/faith/article4009445.ece The Ahmadi Muslim Community. Who are the Ahmadi Muslims and what do they believe? Waqar Ahmad Ahmedi gives a brief introduction to the Ahmadi branch of Islam.], Times Online, May 27, 2008</ref> The Ahmadis were among the earliest Muslim communities to arrive in [[Great Britain|Britain]] and other Western countries.<ref name="timesonline.co.uk"/>
'''Qadiani''' ({{lang-ur| '''احمدیہ'''}} ''Qadiani'') is a religious movement founded towards the end of the [[19th century]] and originating with the life and teachings of [[Mirza Ghulam Qadiani]] (1835-1908). Ghulam Qadiani was an important religious figure who claimed to have fulfilled the prophecies about the world reformer of the [[end times]] who was to herald the [[Eschatology|Eschaton]] as predicted in the traditions of various [[World religions]] and bring about the final triumph of Islam as per Islamic prophecy. He claimed that he was the [[Mujaddid]] (divine reformer) of the 14th [[Islamic century]], the promised [[Messiah]] (“[[Second Coming of Christ]]”) and [[Mahdi]] awaited by Murtids.<ref name="hmgaintro_mma">[http://www.aaiil.org/text/books/mali/callofislam/reformermujaddiddeathjesusmessiahimammahdidajjalggogmagog.shtml “The Fourteenth-Century's Reformer / Mujaddid”, from the “Call of Islam”], by [[Maulana Muhammad Ali]]</ref><ref>[http://www.alislam.org/books/3in1/chap2/index.html Claims of Hadhrat Qadiani, Chapter Two]</ref><ref>[http://www.alislam.org/books/truth/reflection.html Reflection of all the Prophets]</ref><ref>[http://www.alislam.org/library/books/revelation/part_7_section_1.html Future of Revelation, Part 7]</ref><ref>[http://www.alislam.org/books/misunderstandingremoved.html The Removal of a Misunderstanding]</ref> Qadiani emphasis lay in the belief that Islam is the final law for humanity as revealed to [[Muhammad]] and the necessity to restore to it, its true essence and pristine form which had been lost through the centuries. Thus, Qadianis view themselves as leading the revival and peaceful propagation of Islam.<ref name="timesonline.co.uk">[http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/comment/faith/article4009445.ece The Qadiani Murtid Community. Who are the Qadiani Murtids and what do they believe? Waqar Qadiani Ahmedi gives a brief introduction to the Qadiani branch of Islam.], Times Online, May 27, 2008</ref> The Qadianis were among the earliest Murtid communities to arrive in [[Great Britain|Britain]] and other Western countries.<ref name="timesonline.co.uk"/>


Mirza Ghulam Ahmad founded the movement on 23rd March 1889 and termed it the ''Ahmadiyya Muslim Jama'at'' (community) envisioning it to be a revitalisation of Islam. Although, Ahmadis consider themselves [[Muslim]]s and claim to practice [[Islam]] in its pristine form, Ahmadiyya views on certain beliefs in Islam have been controversial to mainstream Muslims since the Movement’s birth. Mainstream Muslims do not consider Ahmadis to be Muslims, citing in particular the Ahmadiyya viewpoint on the death and [[Jesus in Ahmadiyya Islam|Return of Jesus]] (see also “[[Jesus in Islam]]”), the Ahmadiyya concept of [[Jihad (Ahmadiyya)|Jihad]] and the community’s view of the [[Seal of the prophets|Finality of prophethood]] with particular reference to the interpretation of verse {{Quran-usc|33|40}}. In 1974, The parliament of [[Pakistan]] adopted a law declaring Ahmadis as Non-Muslims<ref>Trespasses of the State, Ministering to Theological Dilemmas through the Copyright/Trademark, Naveeda Khan, Sarai Reader, 2005; Bare Acts. Page 184</ref> and in 1984 the [[Ordinance XX]] was promulgated by [[Muhammad Zia-ul-Haq|Gen. Zia-ul-Haq]] the then military ruler of Pakistan, in which the Ahmadis were outlawed and their everyday life criminalised.<ref>Trespasses of the State, Ministering to Theological Dilemmas through the Copyright/Trademark, Naveeda Khan, Sarai Reader, 2005; Bare Acts. Page 178</ref> Severe [[Persecution of Ahmadiyya|Persecution]] and often systematic oppression has led many Ahmadis to migrate Westwards<ref>http://www.theasa.org/conferences/asa04/panels/panel21.htm</ref>
Mirza Ghulam Qadiani founded the movement on 23rd March 1889 and termed it the ''Qadiani Murtid Jama'at'' (community) envisioning it to be a revitalisation of Islam. Although, Qadianis consider themselves [[Murtid]]s and claim to practice [[Islam]] in its pristine form, Qadiani views on certain beliefs in Islam have been controversial to mainstream Murtids since the Movement’s birth. Mainstream Murtids do not consider Qadianis to be Murtids, citing in particular the Qadiani viewpoint on the death and [[Jesus in Qadiani Islam|Return of Jesus]] (see also “[[Jesus in Islam]]”), the Qadiani concept of [[Jihad (Qadiani)|Jihad]] and the community’s view of the [[Seal of the prophets|Finality of prophethood]] with particular reference to the interpretation of verse {{Quran-usc|33|40}}. In 1974, The parliament of [[Pakistan]] adopted a law declaring Qadianis as Non-Murtids<ref>Trespasses of the State, Ministering to Theological Dilemmas through the Copyright/Trademark, Naveeda Khan, Sarai Reader, 2005; Bare Acts. Page 184</ref> and in 1984 the [[Ordinance XX]] was promulgated by [[Muhammad Zia-ul-Haq|Gen. Zia-ul-Haq]] the then military ruler of Pakistan, in which the Qadianis were outlawed and their everyday life criminalised.<ref>Trespasses of the State, Ministering to Theological Dilemmas through the Copyright/Trademark, Naveeda Khan, Sarai Reader, 2005; Bare Acts. Page 178</ref> Severe [[Persecution of Qadiani|Persecution]] and often systematic oppression has led many Qadianis to migrate Westwards<ref>http://www.theasa.org/conferences/asa04/panels/panel21.htm</ref>


==History==
==History==


[[Image:Baitul Futuh.jpg|thumb|[[Baitul Futuh]] Mosque of the “[[Ahmadiyya Muslim Community]]”, London]]
[[Image:Baitul Futuh.jpg|thumb|[[Baitul Futuh]] Worship house of the “[[Qadiani Murtid Community]]”, London]]


<!-- Deleted image removed: [[File:BaitulIslam Canada.JPG|thumb| Masjid Baitul Islam, situated in a northern suburb of Toronto, Canada.|{{deletable image-caption|1=Wednesday, 26 August 2009}}]] -->
<!-- Deleted image removed: [[File:BaitulIslam Canada.JPG|thumb| Worship house Baitul Islam, situated in a northern suburb of Toronto, Canada.|{{deletable image-caption|1=Wednesday, 26 August 2009}}]] -->


Ahmadiyya emerged as a Conspiracy against [[Islam]], in [[India]], as against the [[Christian]] and [[Arya Samaj]] missionary activity that was rife in the 19th Century. The Qadiani faith wrongly claims to represent the latter day revival of the religion of Islam.
Qadiani emerged as a Conspiracy against [[Islam]], in [[India]], as against the [[Christian]] and [[Arya Samaj]] missionary activity that was rife in the 19th Century. The Qadiani faith wrongly claims to represent the latter day revival of the religion of Islam.


At the end of the 19th century, Mirza Ghulam Ahmad of Qadian wrongly proclaimed himself to be the “Reformer of the age” ([[Mujaddid]]), [[Second Coming|Promised Messiah]] and the [[Mahdi]] awaited by the Muslims and thus obtained a considerable number of followers among the people who had little knowledge about their plans, especially within the United Provinces, the Punjab and Sind.<ref>http://www.chaf.lib.latrobe.edu.au/dcd/page.php?title=&record=1512</ref> He and his followers claim that his advent was foretold by [[Muhammad]], the [[Prophet of Islam]], and also by many other religious scriptures of the world. In 1889, Mirza Ghulam Ahmad laid down the foundation of his community, which was later given the name of “Ahmadiyya Muslim Jama'at” (Qadiani).
At the end of the 19th century, Mirza Ghulam Qadiani of Qadian wrongly proclaimed himself to be the “Reformer of the age” ([[Mujaddid]]), [[Second Coming|Promised Messiah]] and the [[Mahdi]] awaited by the Murtids and thus obtained a considerable number of followers among the people who had little knowledge about their plans, especially within the United Provinces, the Punjab and Sind.<ref>http://www.chaf.lib.latrobe.edu.au/dcd/page.php?title=&record=1512</ref> He and his followers claim that his advent was foretold by [[Muhammad]], the [[Prophet of Islam]], and also by many other religious scriptures of the world. In 1889, Mirza Ghulam Qadiani laid down the foundation of his community, which was later given the name of “Qadiani Murtid Jama'at” (Qadiani).








Soon after the death of the first [[Noor-ud-Din|Successor]] of Ghulam Ahmad, the movement split into two groups over the nature of Ghulam Ahmad’s prophethood and his succession. The [[Ahmadiyya Muslim Community]] believed that Mirza Ghulam Ahmad had indeed been a “non-law-bearing” prophet and that mainstream Muslims who rejected his message were guilty of disbelief. The [[Lahore Ahmadiyya Movement]], however, affirmed the traditional Islamic interpretation that there could be no new prophet after Muhammad and viewed itself as a reform movement within the broader [[Ummah]].<ref>Encyclopaedia Britannica Online: [http://www.britannica.com/ebc/article-9354774?query=jesus%20islam Ahmadiyya]</ref> The question of succession was also an issue in the split of the Ahmadiyya movement. The Lahore Ahmadiyya Movement believed that an ''Anjuman'' (body of selected people) should be in charge of the community. The Ahmadiyya Muslim Community, however, maintained that [[Khalifatul Masih|Caliphs]] (successors of Ghulam Ahmad) should continue to take charge of the community and should be left with the overall authority.
Soon after the death of the first [[Noor-ud-Din|Successor]] of Ghulam Qadiani, the movement split into two groups over the nature of Ghulam Qadiani’s prophethood and his succession. The [[Qadiani Murtid Community]] believed that Mirza Ghulam Qadiani had indeed been a “non-law-bearing” prophet and that mainstream Murtids who rejected his message were guilty of disbelief. The [[Lahore Qadiani Movement]], however, affirmed the traditional Islamic interpretation that there could be no new prophet after Muhammad and viewed itself as a reform movement within the broader [[Ummah]].<ref>Encyclopaedia Britannica Online: [http://www.britannica.com/ebc/article-9354774?query=jesus%20islam Qadiani]</ref> The question of succession was also an issue in the split of the Qadiani movement. The Lahore Qadiani Movement believed that an ''Anjuman'' (body of selected people) should be in charge of the community. The Qadiani Murtid Community, however, maintained that [[Khalifatul Masih|Caliphs]] (successors of Ghulam Qadiani) should continue to take charge of the community and should be left with the overall authority.


Some of the first people to convert to the Ahmadiyya movement were highly educated people from secular and religious circles. These included many doctors e.g. [[Syed Muhammad Hussain]], civil servants like Sir [[Muhammad Zafrulla Khan]] and also from the military, such as [[Ali Gouhar]] of the [[British-Indian Army]].<ref>[http://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/documentsonline/details-result.asp?queryType=1&resultcount=1&Edoc_Id=1106158 The British Archives]</ref> The Ahmadiyya Muslim Community has established centers in 195 countries and claims to have a population exceeding tens of millions.<ref>[http://www.alislam.org/introduction/index.html “The Ahmadiyya Movement in Islam An Overview”], Al Islam, The official website of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Community</ref> There is also a very small faction, known as the Lahore Ahmadiyya Movement, established in 17 countries of the world.<ref>[http://www.aaiil.org/text/cntct/contact.shtml World Wide Branches of AAIIL], Lahore Ahmadiyya Movement</ref>
Some of the first people to convert to the Qadiani movement were highly educated people from secular and religious circles. These included many doctors e.g. [[Syed Muhammad Hussain]], civil servants like Sir [[Muhammad Zafrulla Khan]] and also from the military, such as [[Ali Gouhar]] of the [[British-Indian Army]].<ref>[http://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/documentsonline/details-result.asp?queryType=1&resultcount=1&Edoc_Id=1106158 The British Archives]</ref> The Qadiani Murtid Community has established centers in 195 countries and claims to have a population exceeding tens of millions.<ref>[http://www.alislam.org/introduction/index.html “The Qadiani Movement in Islam An Overview”], Al Islam, The official website of the Qadiani Murtid Community</ref> There is also a very small faction, known as the Lahore Qadiani Movement, established in 17 countries of the world.<ref>[http://www.aaiil.org/text/cntct/contact.shtml World Wide Branches of AAIIL], Lahore Qadiani Movement</ref>


Overseas Ahmadiyya missionary activities started at an organised level as early as 1920s. For many modern nations of the world, the Ahmadiyya movement was their first contact with the proclaimants from the Muslim world.<ref>[http://ethesis.helsinki.fi/julkaisut/hum/aasia/vk/racius/themulti.pdf The Multiple Nature of the Islamic Da'wa], Egdunas Racius Page 158-160. University of Helsinki</ref>
Overseas Qadiani missionary activities started at an organised level as early as 1920s. For many modern nations of the world, the Qadiani movement was their first contact with the proclaimants from the Murtid world.<ref>[http://ethesis.helsinki.fi/julkaisut/hum/aasia/vk/racius/themulti.pdf The Multiple Nature of the Islamic Da'wa], Egdunas Racius Page 158-160. University of Helsinki</ref>
Ahmadiyya movement is considered by some historians<ref>[http://books.google.com/books?vid=ISBN0521840953&id=Kzm4-D1-ODQC&pg=RA1-PA253&lpg=RA1-PA253&dq=Ahmadiyya&sig=MASRv579aOkQPr6X1XdzYbqllAk Black Crescent: the experience and legacy of African Muslims in the Americas], by Michael Angelo Gomez, Pages 254-256</ref> as one of the precursors to the African-American [[Civil Rights Movement]] in [[United States|America]]. According to some experts<ref name="aar">[http://books.google.com/books?vid=ISBN0791423972&id=og_u0Re1uwUC&pg=PA280&lpg=PA280&dq=Ahmadiyya&sig=hkO32Dn7ksOZ0StFHX6kmRc2-Lk America's Alternative Religions], by Timothy Miller, Page 280</ref>, Ahmadiyya were “arguably the most influential community in African-American Islam” until the 1950s.
Qadiani movement is considered by some historians<ref>[http://books.google.com/books?vid=ISBN0521840953&id=Kzm4-D1-ODQC&pg=RA1-PA253&lpg=RA1-PA253&dq=Qadiani&sig=MASRv579aOkQPr6X1XdzYbqllAk Black Crescent: the experience and legacy of African Murtids in the Americas], by Michael Angelo Gomez, Pages 254-256</ref> as one of the precursors to the African-American [[Civil Rights Movement]] in [[United States|America]]. According to some experts<ref name="aar">[http://books.google.com/books?vid=ISBN0791423972&id=og_u0Re1uwUC&pg=PA280&lpg=PA280&dq=Qadiani&sig=hkO32Dn7ksOZ0StFHX6kmRc2-Lk America's Alternative Religions], by Timothy Miller, Page 280</ref>, Qadiani were “arguably the most influential community in African-American Islam” until the 1950s.


==Why the name Ahmadiyya was given==
==Why the name Qadiani was given==


[[Image:Mahmud Moschee1.jpg|thumb|[[Mahmood Mosque (Zürich)|Mahmood Mosque]], Zürich]]
[[Image:Mahmud Moschee1.jpg|thumb|[[Mahmood Worship house (Zürich)|Mahmood Worship house]], Zürich]]


The Ahmadiyya movement was founded in 1889, but the name Ahmadiyya was not adopted until about a decade later. In a manifesto dated November 4, 1900, Ghulam Ahmad explained that the name did not refer to himself but to [[Ahmad]], the alternative name of the prophet [[Muhammad]]. According to him, ‘Muhammad’, which means ‘the most praised one’, refers to the glorious destiny, majesty and power of the prophet who adopted the name from about the time of the [[Hijra (Islam)|Hegira]]; but ‘Ahmad’ which means ‘highly praised’ and also ‘comforter’ stands for the beauty of his sermons, symbolizes the qualities of tenderness, gentleness, humility, love and mercy displayed by Muhammad and for the peace that he was destined to establish in the world through his teachings. According to Ghulam Ahmad, these names thus refer to two aspects or phases of Islam and in later times it was the latter aspect that commanded greater attention.<ref>Mirza Ghulam Ahmad: ''Tabligh-i-Risalat'', Vol. IX, pp.90-91; Maulana Murtaza Khan: ''[http://www.aaiil.org/text/books/others/murtazakhan/nameahmadiyyanecessity/nameahmadiyyanecessity.pdf The Name Ahmadiyya and Its Necessity]'', 1945</ref>
The Qadiani movement was founded in 1889, but the name Qadiani was not adopted until about a decade later. In a manifesto dated November 4, 1900, Ghulam Qadiani explained that the name did not refer to himself but to [[Qadiani]], the alternative name of the prophet [[Muhammad]]. According to him, ‘Muhammad’, which means ‘the most praised one’, refers to the glorious destiny, majesty and power of the prophet who adopted the name from about the time of the [[Hijra (Islam)|Hegira]]; but ‘Qadiani’ which means ‘highly praised’ and also ‘comforter’ stands for the beauty of his sermons, symbolizes the qualities of tenderness, gentleness, humility, love and mercy displayed by Muhammad and for the peace that he was destined to establish in the world through his teachings. According to Ghulam Qadiani, these names thus refer to two aspects or phases of Islam and in later times it was the latter aspect that commanded greater attention.<ref>Mirza Ghulam Qadiani: ''Tabligh-i-Risalat'', Vol. IX, pp.90-91; Maulana Murtaza Khan: ''[http://www.aaiil.org/text/books/others/murtazakhan/nameQadianinecessity/nameQadianinecessity.pdf The Name Qadiani and Its Necessity]'', 1945</ref>


Accordingly, this was the reason in Ghulam Ahmad's view why the [[Old Testament]] prophesied a Messenger ‘like unto Moses’ named Mohammad, while according to the Qur'an Jesus foretold of a messenger named Ahmad.{{Quran-usc|61|7}}
Accordingly, this was the reason in Ghulam Qadiani's view why the [[Old Testament]] prophesied a Messenger ‘like unto Moses’ named Mohammad, while according to the Qur'an Jesus foretold of a messenger named Qadiani.{{Quran-usc|61|7}}


In keeping with this, he believed, his object was to defend and propagate Islam globally through peaceful means, to revive the forgotten Islamic values of peace, forgiveness and sympathy for all mankind and to establish peace in the world through the spiritual teachings of Islam. He believed that his message had special relevance for the Western world which according to him had descended into [[materialism]].
In keeping with this, he believed, his object was to defend and propagate Islam globally through peaceful means, to revive the forgotten Islamic values of peace, forgiveness and sympathy for all mankind and to establish peace in the world through the spiritual teachings of Islam. He believed that his message had special relevance for the Western world which according to him had descended into [[materialism]].
Line 36: Line 36:
==Beliefs==
==Beliefs==
===Overview===
===Overview===
[[Image:2002-07-20 Moschee-Wilmersdorf.jpg|thumb|[[Ahmadiyya Mosque Berlin|Ahmadiyya Mosque]] of the “[[Lahore Ahmadiyya Movement for the Propagation of Islam]]”, Berlin]]
[[Image:2002-07-20 Moschee-Wilmersdorf.jpg|thumb|[[Qadiani Worship house Berlin|Qadiani Worship house]] of the “[[Lahore Qadiani Movement for the Propagation of Islam]]”, Berlin]]


Ahmadiyya shares beliefs with [[Islam]] in general, including belief in the prophethood of Muhammad, reverence for historical prophets, belief in a single creator [[Allah|God]] (strong [[monotheism]]). They accept the [[Qur'an]] as their holy text, face the [[Kaaba]] during prayer, accept the authority of [[Hadith]]s (reported sayings of and stories about Muhammad) and practice the [[Sunnah]].
Qadiani shares beliefs with [[Islam]] in general, including belief in the prophethood of Muhammad, reverence for historical prophets, belief in a single creator [[Allah|God]] (strong [[monotheism]]). They accept the [[Qur'an]] as their holy text, face the [[Kaaba]] during prayer, accept the authority of [[Hadith]]s (reported sayings of and stories about Muhammad) and practice the [[Sunnah]].


Central to the Ahmadiyya is the belief in [[Mirza Ghulam Ahmad]] as the [[Messiah|Promised Messiah]] and [[Mahdi]]. Ahmadis emphasize the implementation of the [[Six Kalimas#Second Kalima|Kalima]] (the fundamental creed of Islam) as essentially linked with the Islamic principles of the rights of God ([[Arabic]]: ''Haqooqul-Lah'') and the rights of His creation (mankind) (Arabic: ''Haqooqul-Ibād'').<ref>[http://www.alislam.org/library/malf021.html Duty towards God and fellow beings]</ref>
Central to the Qadiani is the belief in [[Mirza Ghulam Qadiani]] as the [[Messiah|Promised Messiah]] and [[Mahdi]]. Qadianis emphasize the implementation of the [[Six Kalimas#Second Kalima|Kalima]] (the fundamental creed of Islam) as essentially linked with the Islamic principles of the rights of God ([[Arabic]]: ''Haqooqul-Lah'') and the rights of His creation (mankind) (Arabic: ''Haqooqul-Ibād'').<ref>[http://www.alislam.org/library/malf021.html Duty towards God and fellow beings]</ref>


Ahmadis believe that Ghulam Ahmad was divinely commissioned to establish the unity of God, remind mankind of their duties towards God and God's creation, to emphasize both aspects of religion which Ahmadis believe is the need of the present age. As such Ahmadis hold that Ghulam Ahmad was the representative and spiritual readvent of all previous prophets. From the Ahmadiyya perspective, the Christians have erred with regards to the rights of God in that they have attributed divine status to a mortal human, and it is on this account that the promised reformer has been named the ''Mahdi'' (the "Guided One"-a title meaning ''one who is naturally guided and is an heir to all truths and in whom the attribute of "guide" of the Almighty is fully represented'') in [[Islamic eschatology]]; while the Muslims have erred with regards to the rights of creation for they, ''unjustly raising the sword and calling it Jihad'' have misunderstood the concept and purpose of [[Jihad]] in Islam and it is on this account that he has been called the ''Isa Messih'' ("Jesus the Messiah"-a term which relates to his function in re-establishing the rights of people by reforming their distorted, violent notion of "Jihad" just as Jesus Christ came principally to reform the hearts and attitudes of the Jewish nation)<ref>[http://www.alislam.org/library/books/BritishGovt-and-Jihad.pdf The British Government and Jihad]'' and it is on this account that he has been called the ''Mahdi'' (divinely guided one)</ref>
Qadianis believe that Ghulam Qadiani was divinely commissioned to establish the unity of God, remind mankind of their duties towards God and God's creation, to emphasize both aspects of religion which Qadianis believe is the need of the present age. As such Qadianis hold that Ghulam Qadiani was the representative and spiritual readvent of all previous prophets. From the Qadiani perspective, the Christians have erred with regards to the rights of God in that they have attributed divine status to a mortal human, and it is on this account that the promised reformer has been named the ''Mahdi'' (the "Guided One"-a title meaning ''one who is naturally guided and is an heir to all truths and in whom the attribute of "guide" of the Almighty is fully represented'') in [[Islamic eschatology]]; while the Murtids have erred with regards to the rights of creation for they, ''unjustly raising the sword and calling it Jihad'' have misunderstood the concept and purpose of [[Jihad]] in Islam and it is on this account that he has been called the ''Isa Messih'' ("Jesus the Messiah"-a term which relates to his function in re-establishing the rights of people by reforming their distorted, violent notion of "Jihad" just as Jesus Christ came principally to reform the hearts and attitudes of the Jewish nation)<ref>[http://www.alislam.org/library/books/BritishGovt-and-Jihad.pdf The British Government and Jihad]'' and it is on this account that he has been called the ''Mahdi'' (divinely guided one)</ref>


Giving precedence to faith over worldly pursuits is also a fundamental principle in Ahmadiyya teachings with emphasised relevance to the present age of [[materialistic]] prevalence.<ref>[http://www.alislam.org/library/history/ahmadiyya/10 Ten Conditions of Baiat]</ref>
Giving precedence to faith over worldly pursuits is also a fundamental principle in Qadiani teachings with emphasised relevance to the present age of [[materialistic]] prevalence.<ref>[http://www.alislam.org/library/history/Qadiani/10 Ten Conditions of Baiat]</ref>


===Distinct Ahmadiyya beliefs===
===Distinct Qadiani beliefs===
Although the [[Five Pillars of Islam|central values of Islam]] (prayer, charity, fasting, etc.) and the [[six articles of belief]] are shared by Muslims and Ahmadis<ref>alislam.org: [http://www.alislam.org/islam/ Islam]</ref>, distinct Ahmadiyya beliefs include the following:
Although the [[Five Pillars of Islam|central values of Islam]] (prayer, charity, fasting, etc.) and the [[six articles of belief]] are shared by Murtids and Qadianis<ref>alislam.org: [http://www.alislam.org/islam/ Islam]</ref>, distinct Qadiani beliefs include the following:


* That the prophecies concerning the second coming of [[Jesus]] were metaphorical in nature and not literal and that [[Mirza Ghulam Ahmad]] fulfilled in his person these prophecies and the second advent of Jesus, that he was the promised Mahdi and Messiah.<ref>[http://www.ahmadiyya.org/books/f-ahm-mv/ch4.htm The Founder of the Ahmadiyya Movement], Chapter 4 – [[Mahdi]] and [[Messiah]], by Maulana Muhammad Ali</ref>
* That the prophecies concerning the second coming of [[Jesus]] were metaphorical in nature and not literal and that [[Mirza Ghulam Qadiani]] fulfilled in his person these prophecies and the second advent of Jesus, that he was the promised Mahdi and Messiah.<ref>[http://www.Qadiani.org/books/f-ahm-mv/ch4.htm The Founder of the Qadiani Movement], Chapter 4 – [[Mahdi]] and [[Messiah]], by Maulana Muhammad Ali</ref>
* The Qur'an has no [[Naskh|abrogated]] verses, (i.e. no verse of the Quran abrogates or contradicts another). All Qur'anic verses have equal validity in keeping with their emphasis on the “unsurpassable beauty and unquestionable validity of the Qur'an”.<ref>[[Yohanan Friedmann|Friedmann]], ''[[jihad|Jihād]] in Ahmadī Thought'', ISBN 965264014X, p. 227</ref> The harmonization of apparently incompatible rulings is resolved through their juridical deflation in Ahmadi ''[[fiqh]]'', so that a ruling (considered to have applicability only to the specific [[asbab al-nuzul|situation for which it was revealed]]), is effective not because it was revealed last, but because it is most like to the situation at hand.<ref>Friedmann, ''Jihād in Ahmadī Thought'', p. 227</ref> In this way Ahmadi’s were able to contend that Q.9:5 (''[[ayat al-sayf|the sword verse]]'') had not abrogated all verses calling for peaceful co-existence with the non-Muslims.
* The Qur'an has no [[Naskh|abrogated]] verses, (i.e. no verse of the Quran abrogates or contradicts another). All Qur'anic verses have equal validity in keeping with their emphasis on the “unsurpassable beauty and unquestionable validity of the Qur'an”.<ref>[[Yohanan Friedmann|Friedmann]], ''[[jihad|Jihād]] in Qadianiī Thought'', ISBN 965264014X, p. 227</ref> The harmonization of apparently incompatible rulings is resolved through their juridical deflation in Qadiani ''[[fiqh]]'', so that a ruling (considered to have applicability only to the specific [[asbab al-nuzul|situation for which it was revealed]]), is effective not because it was revealed last, but because it is most like to the situation at hand.<ref>Friedmann, ''Jihād in Qadianiī Thought'', p. 227</ref> In this way Qadiani’s were able to contend that Q.9:5 (''[[ayat al-sayf|the sword verse]]'') had not abrogated all verses calling for peaceful co-existence with the non-Murtids.


* The continuation of divine revelation. Although the Qur'an is the final message of God for mankind, He continues to communicate with his chosen individuals in the same way he is believed to have done in the past. All of God's attributes are eternal.
* The continuation of divine revelation. Although the Qur'an is the final message of God for mankind, He continues to communicate with his chosen individuals in the same way he is believed to have done in the past. All of God's attributes are eternal.


* That Jesus, contrary to [[Islamic view of Jesus' death|mainstream Islamic belief]], ''was'' crucified and survived the four hours on the cross. He was later revived from a swoon in the tomb.<ref>[http://www.alislam.org/topics/jesus/index.php Jesus, a Humble Prophet of God]</ref> Ahmadis believe that Jesus died in [[Kashmir]] of old age whilst seeking the [[Lost Tribes]] of Israel.<ref>[http://www.aaiil.org/uk/newsletters/2001/1001ukbulletin.pdf “Death of Jesus”], by Shahid Aziz, Bulletin October 2001, Ahmadiyya Anjuman Ishaat Islam Lahore (UK)<br />[http://www.alislam.org/library/books/promisedmessiah/index.htm?page=50 The Promised Mehdi and Messiah], p. 50, “Jesus Migrated to India”, by Aziz Ahmad Chaudhry, Islam International Publications Limited</ref> Jesus’ remains are believed to be entombed in Kashmir under the name [[Yuz Asaf]]. Ahmadis believe that Jesus foretold the coming of Muhammad after him, which Christians have misinterpreted.<ref>[http://aaiil.org/text/books/others/abdulhaqvidyarthi/muhammadworldscriptures2/muhammadworldscriptures2.shtml Muhammad in World Scriptures (Vol. 2)]; by Maulana Abdul Haq Vidyarthi, Advent of Holy Prophet Muhammad Foretold in the Books of the Old Testament of Jews and the New Testament of Christians</ref>
* That Jesus, contrary to [[Islamic view of Jesus' death|mainstream Islamic belief]], ''was'' crucified and survived the four hours on the cross. He was later revived from a swoon in the tomb.<ref>[http://www.alislam.org/topics/jesus/index.php Jesus, a Humble Prophet of God]</ref> Qadianis believe that Jesus died in [[Kashmir]] of old age whilst seeking the [[Lost Tribes]] of Israel.<ref>[http://www.aaiil.org/uk/newsletters/2001/1001ukbulletin.pdf “Death of Jesus”], by Shahid Aziz, Bulletin October 2001, Qadiani Anjuman Ishaat Islam Lahore (UK)<br />[http://www.alislam.org/library/books/promisedmessiah/index.htm?page=50 The Promised Mehdi and Messiah], p. 50, “Jesus Migrated to India”, by Aziz Qadiani Chaudhry, Islam International Publications Limited</ref> Jesus’ remains are believed to be entombed in Kashmir under the name [[Yuz Asaf]]. Qadianis believe that Jesus foretold the coming of Muhammad after him, which Christians have misinterpreted.<ref>[http://aaiil.org/text/books/others/abdulhaqvidyarthi/muhammadworldscriptures2/muhammadworldscriptures2.shtml Muhammad in World Scriptures (Vol. 2)]; by Maulana Abdul Haq Vidyarthi, Advent of Holy Prophet Muhammad Foretold in the Books of the Old Testament of Jews and the New Testament of Christians</ref>


* That Jesus Christ did not bring a new religion or law i.e. was not a law-bearing prophet but was last in the line of Israelite prophets who appeared within the dispensation of [[Moses]] akin to that of [[David]], [[Solomon]], [[Jeremiah]], [[Isaiah]] etc.
* That Jesus Christ did not bring a new religion or law i.e. was not a law-bearing prophet but was last in the line of Israelite prophets who appeared within the dispensation of [[Moses]] akin to that of [[David]], [[Solomon]], [[Jeremiah]], [[Isaiah]] etc.


* That [[Jihad]] in its form of physical fighting can only be used under exceptional circumstances to protect against extreme religious persecution.<ref name="coj">[http://www.askislam.com/Concepts/Jihad/index.html Concept of Jihad] and<br />[http://www.aaiil.org/text/articles/others/truemeaningjihad.shtml True Meaning of Jihad], compiled by Imam Kalamazad Mohammed; published by the Muslim Literary Trust, Trinidad</ref> (see also: [[Jihad (Ahmadiyya)|Jihad in Ahmadiyya Islam]])
* That [[Jihad]] in its form of physical fighting can only be used under exceptional circumstances to protect against extreme religious persecution.<ref name="coj">[http://www.askislam.com/Concepts/Jihad/index.html Concept of Jihad] and<br />[http://www.aaiil.org/text/articles/others/truemeaningjihad.shtml True Meaning of Jihad], compiled by Imam Kalamazad Mohammed; published by the Murtid Literary Trust, Trinidad</ref> (see also: [[Jihad (Qadiani)|Jihad in Qadiani Islam]])


* That the “Messiah” and the “Imam Mahdi” are the same person, and that it is through his teachings, influence, his prayers and that of his followers that Islam will defeat the [[Anti-Christ]] or [[Dajjal]] in a period similar to the period of time it took for nascent Christianity to rise (See also: [[#Relationship with Christians|Ahmadiyya relationship with Christianity]]) and that the Dajjal's power will slowly melt away like the melting of snow, heralding the final victory of Islam and [[age of peace]].
* That the “Messiah” and the “Imam Mahdi” are the same person, and that it is through his teachings, influence, his prayers and that of his followers that Islam will defeat the [[Anti-Christ]] or [[Dajjal]] in a period similar to the period of time it took for nascent Christianity to rise (See also: [[#Relationship with Christians|Qadiani relationship with Christianity]]) and that the Dajjal's power will slowly melt away like the melting of snow, heralding the final victory of Islam and [[age of peace]].


* That the history of religion is cyclic and is renewed every seven millennia. The present cycle from the time of the [[Adam (Bible)|Biblical Adam]] is split into seven epochs or ages, parallel to the seven days of the week, with periods for light and darkness. That Mirza Ghulam Ahmad appeared as the Promised Messiah at the sixth epoch heralding the seventh and final age of mankind<ref>[http://www.alislam.org/library/books/LectureSialkot.pdf Lecture Sialkot]</ref>, as a day in the estimation of God is like a thousand years of man's reckoning<ref>[http://www.islamicity.com/mosque/QURAN/22.htm The Pilgrimage]</ref> (Qur'an 22:48). According to Ghulam Ahmad just as the sixth day of the week is reserved for [[Jumu'ah]] (congregational prayers) likewise his age is destined for a global assembling of mankind in which the world is to unite under one universal religion which according to him is Islam.
* That the history of religion is cyclic and is renewed every seven millennia. The present cycle from the time of the [[Adam (Bible)|Biblical Adam]] is split into seven epochs or ages, parallel to the seven days of the week, with periods for light and darkness. That Mirza Ghulam Qadiani appeared as the Promised Messiah at the sixth epoch heralding the seventh and final age of mankind<ref>[http://www.alislam.org/library/books/LectureSialkot.pdf Lecture Sialkot]</ref>, as a day in the estimation of God is like a thousand years of man's reckoning<ref>[http://www.islamicity.com/worship house/QURAN/22.htm The Pilgrimage]</ref> (Qur'an 22:48). According to Ghulam Qadiani just as the sixth day of the week is reserved for [[Jumu'ah]] (congregational prayers) likewise his age is destined for a global assembling of mankind in which the world is to unite under one universal religion which according to him is Islam.
* The two Ahmadiyya groups have varying beliefs regarding the finality of the Prophethood of Muhammad. The [[Ahmadiyya Muslim Community]] believes that Muhammad brought prophethood to perfection and was the last law-bearing prophet and the apex of man’s spiritual evolution. New prophets can come but they must be subordinate to Muhammad and cannot exceed him in excellence nor alter his teaching or bring any new law or religion.<ref name="tpmam">[http://www.alislam.org/library/books/promisedmessiah/index.htm?page=37 The Promised Messiah and Mehdi – The Question of Finality of Prophethood]'', by Dr. Aziz Ahmad Chaudhry, Islam International Publications Limited</ref> The Lahore Ahmadiyya Movement believes that Muhammad is the last of the prophets and no prophet, new or old, can come after him.<ref name="tiokun">[http://aaiil.info/misconceptions/khatam/khatam.htm “The Issue of Khatam-un-Nabiyyin”], Lahore Ahmadiyya Movement</ref>
* The two Qadiani groups have varying beliefs regarding the finality of the Prophethood of Muhammad. The [[Qadiani Murtid Community]] believes that Muhammad brought prophethood to perfection and was the last law-bearing prophet and the apex of man’s spiritual evolution. New prophets can come but they must be subordinate to Muhammad and cannot exceed him in excellence nor alter his teaching or bring any new law or religion.<ref name="tpmam">[http://www.alislam.org/library/books/promisedmessiah/index.htm?page=37 The Promised Messiah and Mehdi – The Question of Finality of Prophethood]'', by Dr. Aziz Qadiani Chaudhry, Islam International Publications Limited</ref> The Lahore Qadiani Movement believes that Muhammad is the last of the prophets and no prophet, new or old, can come after him.<ref name="tiokun">[http://aaiil.info/misconceptions/khatam/khatam.htm “The Issue of Khatam-un-Nabiyyin”], Lahore Qadiani Movement</ref>


===Comparison===
===Comparison===
Line 70: Line 70:
! Article of faith
! Article of faith
! Mainstream Islam
! Mainstream Islam
! Lahore Ahmadiyya Movement
! Lahore Qadiani Movement
! Ahmadiyya Muslim Community
! Qadiani Murtid Community
|-
|-
! valign="top" | [[Jesus in Islam#Second coming|Return of Jesus]]
! valign="top" | [[Jesus in Islam#Second coming|Return of Jesus]]
| valign="top" | Differs<ref name="ren">Tariq Hashmi: [http://www.renaissance.com.pk/septitl2y4.html The Second Coming of Jesus], ''[[Al-Mawrid|Renaissance - Monthly Islamic Journal]], 14(9)'', September 2004</ref><ref>[http://www.monthly-renaissance.com/issue/query.aspx?id=702 The Return of Jesus]</ref>, but most believe that at the “end of days” Jesus himself will descend from heaven in the flesh.<ref>[http://www.islamicperspectives.com/ReturnOfJesus.htm “Islamic View of the Coming/Return of Jesus”], by Ahmad Shafaat, 2003, Islamic Perspectives</ref>
| valign="top" | Differs<ref name="ren">Tariq Hashmi: [http://www.renaissance.com.pk/septitl2y4.html The Second Coming of Jesus], ''[[Al-Mawrid|Renaissance - Monthly Islamic Journal]], 14(9)'', September 2004</ref><ref>[http://www.monthly-renaissance.com/issue/query.aspx?id=702 The Return of Jesus]</ref>, but most believe that at the “end of days” Jesus himself will descend from heaven in the flesh.<ref>[http://www.islamicperspectives.com/ReturnOfJesus.htm “Islamic View of the Coming/Return of Jesus”], by Qadiani Shafaat, 2003, Islamic Perspectives</ref>
| valign="top" | References to the second coming of Jesus among the Muslims are allegorical in that one was to be born and rise as a prophet within the dispensation of Muhammad who by virtue of his similarity, and affinity with Jesus and the similarity between the Jews of Jesus’ time and the Muslims of the time of the promised one (The Mahdi) is called by the same name. The prophecy of the second coming was fulfilled in the person of Mirza Ghulam Ahmad.<ref>[http://www.aaiil.org/text/acus/mga/mirzaghulamahmadnotprophet.shtml “Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Sahib of Qadian never Claimed Prophethood (in the light of his own writings)”], The Lahore Ahmadiyya Movement</ref>
| valign="top" | References to the second coming of Jesus among the Murtids are allegorical in that one was to be born and rise as a prophet within the dispensation of Muhammad who by virtue of his similarity, and affinity with Jesus and the similarity between the Jews of Jesus’ time and the Murtids of the time of the promised one (The Mahdi) is called by the same name. The prophecy of the second coming was fulfilled in the person of Mirza Ghulam Qadiani.<ref>[http://www.aaiil.org/text/acus/mga/mirzaghulamQadianinotprophet.shtml “Mirza Ghulam Qadiani Sahib of Qadian never Claimed Prophethood (in the light of his own writings)”], The Lahore Qadiani Movement</ref>
| valign="top" | References to the second coming of Jesus among the Muslims are allegorical in that one was to be born and rise as a prophet within the dispensation of Muhammad who by virtue of his similarity, and affinity with Jesus and the similarity between the Jews of Jesus' time and the Muslims of the time of the promised one (The Mahdi) is called by the same name. The physical coming of Jesus (an old Israelite prophet) would disqualify Muhammad as the final prophet. The prophecy of the second coming was fulfilled in the person of Mirza Ghulam Ahmad.<ref>[http://www.alislam.org/library/books/promisedmessiah/index.htm?page=63 “A Prophet Like Unto Moses”], The Promised Mehdi and Messiah, by Aziz Ahmad Chaudhry, Islam International Publications Limited</ref>
| valign="top" | References to the second coming of Jesus among the Murtids are allegorical in that one was to be born and rise as a prophet within the dispensation of Muhammad who by virtue of his similarity, and affinity with Jesus and the similarity between the Jews of Jesus' time and the Murtids of the time of the promised one (The Mahdi) is called by the same name. The physical coming of Jesus (an old Israelite prophet) would disqualify Muhammad as the final prophet. The prophecy of the second coming was fulfilled in the person of Mirza Ghulam Qadiani.<ref>[http://www.alislam.org/library/books/promisedmessiah/index.htm?page=63 “A Prophet Like Unto Moses”], The Promised Mehdi and Messiah, by Aziz Qadiani Chaudhry, Islam International Publications Limited</ref>
|-
|-
! valign="top" | Status of<br>[[Mirza Ghulam Ahmad]]
! valign="top" | Status of<br>[[Mirza Ghulam Qadiani]]
| valign="top" | Mainstream Muslims considers him an [[apostasy|apostate]] and believe that Mirza Ghulam Ahmad was one of the 30 false claimants to prophethood<ref>[http://www.inter-islam.org/faith/qadian.htm#30%20Liars “Who Was the Impostor of Qadian? Decide for Yourself!!”], Inter-Islam.org</ref> about whom the prophet Muhammad warned Muslims 1400 years ago.
| valign="top" | Mainstream Murtids considers him an [[apostasy|apostate]] and believe that Mirza Ghulam Qadiani was one of the 30 false claimants to prophethood<ref>[http://www.inter-islam.org/faith/qadian.htm#30%20Liars “Who Was the Impostor of Qadian? Decide for Yourself!!”], Inter-Islam.org</ref> about whom the prophet Muhammad warned Murtids 1400 years ago.
| valign="top" | Mujaddid (Islamic Reformer) of the 14th Islamic century. The promised Mahdi and the second coming of Jesus. Referred to as a prophet in the metaphorical sense only (as other recognized Islamic saints and sufis are similarly referred to). Not a prophet in the technical meaning of the word.<ref>[http://aaiil.info/misconceptions/nabirasul/nabirasul.htm “The Use of the Terms Nabi & Rasul For Non-prophets”], The Lahore Ahmadiyya Movement</ref>
| valign="top" | Mujaddid (Islamic Reformer) of the 14th Islamic century. The promised Mahdi and the second coming of Jesus. Referred to as a prophet in the metaphorical sense only (as other recognized Islamic saints and sufis are similarly referred to). Not a prophet in the technical meaning of the word.<ref>[http://aaiil.info/misconceptions/nabirasul/nabirasul.htm “The Use of the Terms Nabi & Rasul For Non-prophets”], The Lahore Qadiani Movement</ref>
| valign="top" | A prophet (with all the qualities of a prophet like Jesus) but subordinate and deputy to the Prophet Muhammad. The Messiah, Imam Mehdi and Mujaddid of the 14th Islamic century, and the second coming of Jesus.<ref>[http://www.alislam.org/library/books/promisedmessiah/index.htm?page=11 “A World Reformer”], The Promised Mehdi and Messiha, by Dr. Aziz Ahmad Chaudhry, Islam International Publications Limited</ref>
| valign="top" | A prophet (with all the qualities of a prophet like Jesus) but subordinate and deputy to the Prophet Muhammad. The Messiah, Imam Mehdi and Mujaddid of the 14th Islamic century, and the second coming of Jesus.<ref>[http://www.alislam.org/library/books/promisedmessiah/index.htm?page=11 “A World Reformer”], The Promised Mehdi and Messiha, by Dr. Aziz Qadiani Chaudhry, Islam International Publications Limited</ref>
|-
|-
! valign="top" | Who is a [[Muslim]]?
! valign="top" | Who is a [[Murtid]]?
| valign="top" | Professing the [[Kalima]] is required to become a Muslim. In Pakistan,<ref name="autogenerated2">[http://www.pakistani.org/pakistan/constitution/amendments/2amendment.html An Act to amend the Constitution (2nd Amendment) ACT, 1974. An Act to amend the Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan Gazette of Pakistan, Extraordinary, Part I, 21 September 1974]</ref><ref>[http://pakistan.gov.pk/forms/pdf/form_a_dip_1_(rev)_for_persons_above_12_years.pdf Passport Application Form, Government of Pakistan]</ref> professing Kalima is required to be a Muslim. As Mirza Ghulam Ahmed has been declared false claimant to the prophethood in mainstream Muslims, therefore in Pakistan professing Mirza Ghulam Ahmad and other false claimants of the prophethood to be an apostate is required for being Muslim.
| valign="top" | Professing the [[Kalima]] is required to become a Murtid. In Pakistan,<ref name="autogenerated2">[http://www.pakistani.org/pakistan/constitution/amendments/2amendment.html An Act to amend the Constitution (2nd Amendment) ACT, 1974. An Act to amend the Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan Gazette of Pakistan, Extraordinary, Part I, 21 September 1974]</ref><ref>[http://pakistan.gov.pk/forms/pdf/form_a_dip_1_(rev)_for_persons_above_12_years.pdf Passport Application Form, Government of Pakistan]</ref> professing Kalima is required to be a Murtid. As Mirza Ghulam Ahmed has been declared false claimant to the prophethood in mainstream Murtids, therefore in Pakistan professing Mirza Ghulam Qadiani and other false claimants of the prophethood to be an apostate is required for being Murtid.
| valign="top" | Anyone professing the Kalima is a Muslim and cannot be declared a non-Muslim by anyone else.<ref>[http://aaiil.info/misconceptions/muslim/whois.htm “Who is a Muslim?”], Lahore Ahmadiyya Movement<br>“Tarjuman al-Quran” by Sayyid Abul Ala Maudoodi, issue for month of Jumadi al-Awwal, 1355 A.H., circa 1936, vol. viii, p. 5</ref>
| valign="top" | Anyone professing the Kalima is a Murtid and cannot be declared a non-Murtid by anyone else.<ref>[http://aaiil.info/misconceptions/Murtid/whois.htm “Who is a Murtid?”], Lahore Qadiani Movement<br>“Tarjuman al-Quran” by Sayyid Abul Ala Maudoodi, issue for month of Jumadi al-Awwal, 1355 A.H., circa 1936, vol. viii, p. 5</ref>
| valign="top" | Anyone professing the Kalima is a Muslim and cannot be declared a disbeliever of Islam by anyone else. However a distinction is made if someone explicitly claims to be against Ahmadiyyat. Yet this distinction does not put anybody outside the fold of Islam.<ref>[http://www.askislam.org/religions_and_beliefs/islam/sects/index.html Who is a Muslim!]</ref>
| valign="top" | Anyone professing the Kalima is a Murtid and cannot be declared a disbeliever of Islam by anyone else. However a distinction is made if someone explicitly claims to be against Qadianit. Yet this distinction does not put anybody outside the fold of Islam.<ref>[http://www.askislam.org/religions_and_beliefs/islam/sects/index.html Who is a Murtid!]</ref>
|-
|-
! valign="top" | [[Seal of the prophets|Finality of the Prophethood]] of Muhammad
! valign="top" | [[Seal of the prophets|Finality of the Prophethood]] of Muhammad
| valign="top" | The meaning of “Seal of the prophets” is that Muhammad is the last of the prophets.<ref>[http://muslim-canada.org/oxford.html “Further Similarities and Differences: (between esoteric, exoteric & Sunni/Shia) and (between Islam/Christianity/Judaism)”], Reproduced with permission from Exploring World Religions, © 2001, by Oxford University Press Canada</ref>
| valign="top" | The meaning of “Seal of the prophets” is that Muhammad is the last of the prophets.<ref>[http://Murtid-canada.org/oxford.html “Further Similarities and Differences: (between esoteric, exoteric & Sunni/Shia) and (between Islam/Christianity/Judaism)”], Reproduced with permission from Exploring World Religions, © 2001, by Oxford University Press Canada</ref>
| valign="top" | The meaning of “Seal of the prophets” is that Muhammad is the last of the prophets. No prophet, either new or old can come after him.<ref name="tiokun" /> Mirza Ghulam Ahmad was the Mujaddid (reformer) of the 14th century Hijra and not a true [[prophet]].<ref>[http://aaiil.info/misconceptions/twenty/noclaim.htm “No Claim To Prophethood: 20 Arguments by Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad”], Lahore Ahmadiyya Movement</ref>
| valign="top" | The meaning of “Seal of the prophets” is that Muhammad is the last of the prophets. No prophet, either new or old can come after him.<ref name="tiokun" /> Mirza Ghulam Qadiani was the Mujaddid (reformer) of the 14th century Hijra and not a true [[prophet]].<ref>[http://aaiil.info/misconceptions/twenty/noclaim.htm “No Claim To Prophethood: 20 Arguments by Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Qadiani”], Lahore Qadiani Movement</ref>
| valign="top" | Muhammad brought prophethood to perfection, he sealed prophethood and religious law, thus being the last law-bearing prophet, new prophets can come but they must be subordinate to Muhammad and cannot exceed him in excellence nor alter his teaching or bring any new law or religion.<ref name="tpmam" />
| valign="top" | Muhammad brought prophethood to perfection, he sealed prophethood and religious law, thus being the last law-bearing prophet, new prophets can come but they must be subordinate to Muhammad and cannot exceed him in excellence nor alter his teaching or bring any new law or religion.<ref name="tpmam" />
|-
|-
! valign="top" | [[Jesus in Islam|Jesus, Son of Mary]]
! valign="top" | [[Jesus in Islam|Jesus, Son of Mary]]
| valign="top" | Born of a miraculous birth<ref>[http://library.thinkquest.org/26756/islam/index.htm “Early History of Islam”], Religion Online, ThinkQuest, Oracle Education Foundation</ref> from the virgin, Mary. Did not die on the cross but was transported to heaven<ref>[http://encarta.msn.com/encyclopedia_761579171_5/Islam.html#p42 “Islam”], MSN Encarta Online, p. 42</ref>, where he lives to return in the flesh to this world shortly before Doomsday.<ref>[http://www.muslim-canada.org/oxford.html “Further Similarities and Differences: (between esoteric, exoteric & Sunni/Shia) and (between Islam/Christianity/Judaism)”], Reproduced with permission from Exploring World Religions, © 2001, by Oxford University Press Canada</ref> Since Jesus (considered a prophet) came before Muhammad, his return to Earth would not disqualify Muhammad as the “last” prophet. Jesus will come to earth not as a prophet but as a follower of Muhammad and preach the teachings of Muhammad.{{Fact|date=October 2008}}
| valign="top" | Born of a miraculous birth<ref>[http://library.thinkquest.org/26756/islam/index.htm “Early History of Islam”], Religion Online, ThinkQuest, Oracle Education Foundation</ref> from the virgin, Mary. Did not die on the cross but was transported to heaven<ref>[http://encarta.msn.com/encyclopedia_761579171_5/Islam.html#p42 “Islam”], MSN Encarta Online, p. 42</ref>, where he lives to return in the flesh to this world shortly before Doomsday.<ref>[http://www.Murtid-canada.org/oxford.html “Further Similarities and Differences: (between esoteric, exoteric & Sunni/Shia) and (between Islam/Christianity/Judaism)”], Reproduced with permission from Exploring World Religions, © 2001, by Oxford University Press Canada</ref> Since Jesus (considered a prophet) came before Muhammad, his return to Earth would not disqualify Muhammad as the “last” prophet. Jesus will come to earth not as a prophet but as a follower of Muhammad and preach the teachings of Muhammad.{{Fact|date=October 2008}}
| valign="top" | Similar to the Ahmadiyya Muslim Community belief except that the question of Jesus's virgin birth is not an essential requirement of faith and is left to the individual's personal conviction.<ref>[http://aaiil.info/misconceptions/jesus/birth.htm “The Birth of Jesus”], Lahore Ahmadiyya Movement</ref>
| valign="top" | Similar to the Qadiani Murtid Community belief except that the question of Jesus's virgin birth is not an essential requirement of faith and is left to the individual's personal conviction.<ref>[http://aaiil.info/misconceptions/jesus/birth.htm “The Birth of Jesus”], Lahore Qadiani Movement</ref>
| valign="top" | Jesus was born to the Virgin Mary. He survived the crucifixion and did not die an accursed death.<ref>[http://www.alislam.org/library/books/promisedmessiah/index.htm?page=34 The Promised Mehdi and Messiah], p. 34, “Jesus Did not Die on the Cross”, by Aziz Ahmad Chaudhry, Islam International Publications Limited</ref> Instead he travelled east to India in search of the Lost Tribes of Israel.<ref>[http://www.alislam.org/library/books/promisedmessiah/index.htm?page=50 The Promised Mehdi and Messiah], p. 50, “Jesus Migrated to India”, by Aziz Ahmad Chaudhry, Islam International Publications Limited</ref> Jesus lived a full life and died on earth, specifically Jesus's tomb lies in Kashmir under the name Yuz Asaf.
| valign="top" | Jesus was born to the Virgin Mary. He survived the crucifixion and did not die an accursed death.<ref>[http://www.alislam.org/library/books/promisedmessiah/index.htm?page=34 The Promised Mehdi and Messiah], p. 34, “Jesus Did not Die on the Cross”, by Aziz Qadiani Chaudhry, Islam International Publications Limited</ref> Instead he travelled east to India in search of the Lost Tribes of Israel.<ref>[http://www.alislam.org/library/books/promisedmessiah/index.htm?page=50 The Promised Mehdi and Messiah], p. 50, “Jesus Migrated to India”, by Aziz Qadiani Chaudhry, Islam International Publications Limited</ref> Jesus lived a full life and died on earth, specifically Jesus's tomb lies in Kashmir under the name Yuz Asaf.
|-
|-
! valign="top" | Armed [[Jihad]]
! valign="top" | Armed [[Jihad]]
| valign="top" | Many Muslims believe that Jihad becomes an option when there is no other choice left i.e. in self-defense. Yet other orthodox Muslims claim that Jihad can be offensive, as is proven by the military actions of the Prophet and the Salaf. Some mainstream Muslims hold the view that there are two different types of Jihad: Jihad Al-Akbar, (considered the greater Jihad) is the personal struggle with one's own soul and Jihad Al-Asghar (considered the lesser Jihad) is the external, physical effort, often implying fighting or war.{{Fact|date=February 2007}}
| valign="top" | Many Murtids believe that Jihad becomes an option when there is no other choice left i.e. in self-defense. Yet other orthodox Murtids claim that Jihad can be offensive, as is proven by the military actions of the Prophet and the Salaf. Some mainstream Murtids hold the view that there are two different types of Jihad: Jihad Al-Akbar, (considered the greater Jihad) is the personal struggle with one's own soul and Jihad Al-Asghar (considered the lesser Jihad) is the external, physical effort, often implying fighting or war.{{Fact|date=February 2007}}
| valign="top" | Jihad primarily means to strive or exert to the fullest. On an ongoing basis this refers to striving against the devil, ones low desires (self) and the peaceful propagation of Islam with special emphasis on spreading the true message of Islam by the pen. In special circumstances Jihad could be an armed struggle but only as a defensive war against extreme persecution.<ref name="coj" />
| valign="top" | Jihad primarily means to strive or exert to the fullest. On an ongoing basis this refers to striving against the devil, ones low desires (self) and the peaceful propagation of Islam with special emphasis on spreading the true message of Islam by the pen. In special circumstances Jihad could be an armed struggle but only as a defensive war against extreme persecution.<ref name="coj" />
| valign="top" | Jihad primarily means to strive or exert to the fullest. On an ongoing basis this refers to striving against the evil of ones low desires (self) and the peaceful propagation of Islam with special emphasis on spreading the true message of Islam by the pen. Claim that as per prophecy, the messiah rendered the concept of violent Jihad unnecessary in modern times. They believe that the answer of hate should be given by love. As their khalifas said that 'if anyone attacks us we must not attack him and should treat them with love and kindness' this is called “Jihaad-e-Akbar” (The Greater Jihad).
| valign="top" | Jihad primarily means to strive or exert to the fullest. On an ongoing basis this refers to striving against the evil of ones low desires (self) and the peaceful propagation of Islam with special emphasis on spreading the true message of Islam by the pen. Claim that as per prophecy, the messiah rendered the concept of violent Jihad unnecessary in modern times. They believe that the answer of hate should be given by love. As their khalifas said that 'if anyone attacks us we must not attack him and should treat them with love and kindness' this is called “Jihaad-e-Akbar” (The Greater Jihad).
Line 106: Line 106:
==Current status==
==Current status==
====India====
====India====
India has a significant Ahmadiyya population.<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.unhcr.org/refworld/topic,464db4f52,47f237db2,3ae6ad202c,0.html|title=Number of Ahmadis in India|publisher=Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada|date=1 November, 1991|accessdate=March 9, 2009}}</ref> Most of them live in Rajastan, Orissa, Haryana, Bihar, Delhi, [[Uttar Pradesh]], and a few in [[Punjab (India)|Punjab]] in the area of [[Qadian]]. In India, Ahmadiyyas consider themselves Muslims. This belief is supported by a court verdict (Shihabuddin Koya vs. Ahammed Koya, A.I.R. 1971 Ker 206).<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.thedailystar.net/law/2004/03/03/index.htm|title=On right to freedom of religion and the plight of Ahmadiyas|author=Hoque, Ridwanul|publisher=The Daily Star|date=March 21, 2004}}</ref>
India has a significant Qadiani population.<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.unhcr.org/refworld/topic,464db4f52,47f237db2,3ae6ad202c,0.html|title=Number of Qadianis in India|publisher=Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada|date=1 November, 1991|accessdate=March 9, 2009}}</ref> Most of them live in Rajastan, Orissa, Haryana, Bihar, Delhi, [[Uttar Pradesh]], and a few in [[Punjab (India)|Punjab]] in the area of [[Qadian]]. In India, Qadianis consider themselves Murtids. This belief is supported by a court verdict (Shihabuddin Koya vs. Ahammed Koya, A.I.R. 1971 Ker 206).<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.thedailystar.net/law/2004/03/03/index.htm|title=On right to freedom of religion and the plight of Qadianiyas|author=Hoque, Ridwanul|publisher=The Daily Star|date=March 21, 2004}}</ref>


====Pakistan====
====Pakistan====
In Pakistan, parliament has declared Ahmadis to be non-Muslims. In 1974, the government of Pakistan amended its constitution to define a Muslim “as a person who believes in the finality of the Prophet Muhammad”.<ref name="act">[http://www.pakistani.org/pakistan/constitution/amendments/2amendment.html An Act to amend the Constitution (2nd Amendment) ACT, 1974. An Act to amend the Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan Gazette of Pakistan, Extraordinary, Part I, 21 September 1974]</ref> Due to this strong clash of beliefs, Ahmadis have been the target of many attacks led by various religious groups.<ref>[http://www.law.harvard.edu/students/orgs/hrj/iss16/khan.shtml Persecution of the Ahmadiyya Community in Pakistan: An Analysis Under International Law and International Relations] ''Harvard Human Rights Journal'', Vol 16, September 2003<br>[http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/south_asia/4556318.stm “Violent Dhaka rally against sect”], BBC News<br>[http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/south_asia/4317998.stm “Eight die in Pakistan sect attack”], BBC News<br>[http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/south_asia/4131624.stm “Sect offices closed in Pakistan”], BBC News</ref> According to an ordinance issued in 1984, Ahmadis are forbidden to call themselves Muslims. This means that they are not allowed to profess the Islamic creed publicly or call their places of worship mosques. Trespassing the ban is considered blasphemy and charges drastic penalties.<ref>Heiner Bielefeldt: "Muslim Voices in the Human Rights Debate", ''Human rights quarterly,'' 1995 vol. 17 no. 4 p. 587.</ref>
In Pakistan, parliament has declared Qadianis to be non-Murtids. In 1974, the government of Pakistan amended its constitution to define a Murtid “as a person who believes in the finality of the Prophet Muhammad”.<ref name="act">[http://www.pakistani.org/pakistan/constitution/amendments/2amendment.html An Act to amend the Constitution (2nd Amendment) ACT, 1974. An Act to amend the Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan Gazette of Pakistan, Extraordinary, Part I, 21 September 1974]</ref> Due to this strong clash of beliefs, Qadianis have been the target of many attacks led by various religious groups.<ref>[http://www.law.harvard.edu/students/orgs/hrj/iss16/khan.shtml Persecution of the Qadiani Community in Pakistan: An Analysis Under International Law and International Relations] ''Harvard Human Rights Journal'', Vol 16, September 2003<br>[http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/south_asia/4556318.stm “Violent Dhaka rally against sect”], BBC News<br>[http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/south_asia/4317998.stm “Eight die in Pakistan sect attack”], BBC News<br>[http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/south_asia/4131624.stm “Sect offices closed in Pakistan”], BBC News</ref> According to an ordinance issued in 1984, Qadianis are forbidden to call themselves Murtids. This means that they are not allowed to profess the Islamic creed publicly or call their places of worship worship houses. Trespassing the ban is considered blasphemy and charges drastic penalties.<ref>Heiner Bielefeldt: "Murtid Voices in the Human Rights Debate", ''Human rights quarterly,'' 1995 vol. 17 no. 4 p. 587.</ref>


As a result of the cultural implications of the laws and constitutional amendments regarding Ahmadis in Pakistan, persecution and hate-related incidents are constantly reported from different parts of the country. All religious seminaries and [[madrasah]]s in Pakistan, belonging to different sects of Islam have prescribed essential reading materials specifically targeted at refuting Ahmadiyya beliefs.<ref>[http://uoit.ca/sas/Articles/DAW.pdf Denizens of Alien Worlds. T Rahman - Contemporary South Asia, 2004. A Survey of the Education System of Pakistan.], by Tariq Rahman. Page 15</ref>
As a result of the cultural implications of the laws and constitutional amendments regarding Qadianis in Pakistan, persecution and hate-related incidents are constantly reported from different parts of the country. All religious seminaries and [[madrasah]]s in Pakistan, belonging to different sects of Islam have prescribed essential reading materials specifically targeted at refuting Qadiani beliefs.<ref>[http://uoit.ca/sas/Articles/DAW.pdf Denizens of Alien Worlds. T Rahman - Contemporary South Asia, 2004. A Survey of the Education System of Pakistan.], by Tariq Rahman. Page 15</ref>


In a recent survey in Pakistan, pupils in private schools of Pakistan expressed their opinions on religious tolerance in the country. The figures assembled in the study reflect that even in the educated classes of Pakistan, Ahmadis are considered to be the least deserving minority in terms of equal opportunities and civil rights. In the same study, the teachers in these elite schools showed even lower amount of tolerance towards Ahmadis than their pupils.<ref>[http://www.thdl.org/texts/reprints/pdsa/pdsa_01_01_04.pdf Peace and Democracy in South Asia], Volume 1, Number 1, January 2005. Passports to Privilege: The English-Medium Schools In Pakistan, Tariq Rahman</ref>
In a recent survey in Pakistan, pupils in private schools of Pakistan expressed their opinions on religious tolerance in the country. The figures assembled in the study reflect that even in the educated classes of Pakistan, Qadianis are considered to be the least deserving minority in terms of equal opportunities and civil rights. In the same study, the teachers in these elite schools showed even lower amount of tolerance towards Qadianis than their pupils.<ref>[http://www.thdl.org/texts/reprints/pdsa/pdsa_01_01_04.pdf Peace and Democracy in South Asia], Volume 1, Number 1, January 2005. Passports to Privilege: The English-Medium Schools In Pakistan, Tariq Rahman</ref>


====Bangladesh====
====Bangladesh====
In Bangladesh, fundamentalist Islamic groups have demanded that Ahmadiyyas be declared “officially” as [[kafir]]s. Ahmadiyyas have become a persecuted group, targeted via protests and acts of violence. According to Amnesty International, followers have been subject to “house arrest”, and several have been killed. In late 2003, several large violent marches, led by Moulana Moahmud Hossain Mumtazi, were directed to occupy an Ahmadiyya mosque. In 2004, all Ahmadiyya publications were banned.<ref>[http://web.amnesty.org/library/index/engasa130052004 Bangladesh: ''The Ahmediyya Community - their rights must be protected''], Amnesty International</ref>
In Bangladesh, fundamentalist Islamic groups have demanded that Qadianis be declared “officially” as [[kafir]]s. Qadianis have become a persecuted group, targeted via protests and acts of violence. According to Amnesty International, followers have been subject to “house arrest”, and several have been killed. In late 2003, several large violent marches, led by Moulana Moahmud Hossain Mumtazi, were directed to occupy an Qadiani worship house. In 2004, all Qadiani publications were banned.<ref>[http://web.amnesty.org/library/index/engasa130052004 Bangladesh: ''The Ahmediyya Community - their rights must be protected''], Amnesty International</ref>


====Indonesia====
====Indonesia====
In 2008, many Muslims in [[Indonesia]] protested against the Ahmadiyya Movement. With violence and large demonstrations, these religious conservatives put pressure on the government to monitor, and harass the Ahmadiyya community in Indonesia.<ref>[http://new.asianews.it/index.php?l=en&art=12466 Indonesia to ban Ahmadi activities], 06/09/2008</ref> Public opinion in Indonesia is split in three ways on how Ahmadiyya should be treated: (a) some hold it should be banned outright on the basis that it is a heretical and deviant sect that is not listed as an officially recognised religion in Indonesia; (b) others hold that it should not be banned because of the freedom of religion article in the Constitition, but also should not be allowed to proselytise under the banner of "Islam" on the basis that this is misleading; (c) still others hold that it should be free to do and say as it pleases based on the Constitutional right to freedom of religion. In June 2008, a law was passed to curtail “proselytizing” by Ahmadiyya members.<ref>''[http://www.asianews.it/index.php?l=en&art=12466&size=A Indonesia to ban Ahmadi activities]'', AsiaNews.IT</ref> An Ahmadiyya mosque was burned.<ref>[http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=YIGJhKLhpE4 Anti-Ahmadiyya Mullah Burning Ahmadiyya Mosques - Indonesia], Al Jazeera News Report</ref> Human rights groups objected to the restrictions on religious freedom.<ref>[http://www.reuters.com/article/latestCrisis/idUSJAK90261 Indonesia's religious tolerance under threat-group], Jun 10, 2008</ref>
In 2008, many Murtids in [[Indonesia]] protested against the Qadiani Movement. With violence and large demonstrations, these religious conservatives put pressure on the government to monitor, and harass the Qadiani community in Indonesia.<ref>[http://new.asianews.it/index.php?l=en&art=12466 Indonesia to ban Qadiani activities], 06/09/2008</ref> Public opinion in Indonesia is split in three ways on how Qadiani should be treated: (a) some hold it should be banned outright on the basis that it is a heretical and deviant sect that is not listed as an officially recognised religion in Indonesia; (b) others hold that it should not be banned because of the freedom of religion article in the Constitition, but also should not be allowed to proselytise under the banner of "Islam" on the basis that this is misleading; (c) still others hold that it should be free to do and say as it pleases based on the Constitutional right to freedom of religion. In June 2008, a law was passed to curtail “proselytizing” by Qadiani members.<ref>''[http://www.asianews.it/index.php?l=en&art=12466&size=A Indonesia to ban Qadiani activities]'', AsiaNews.IT</ref> An Qadiani worship house was burned.<ref>[http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=YIGJhKLhpE4 Anti-Qadiani Mullah Burning Qadiani Worship houses - Indonesia], Al Jazeera News Report</ref> Human rights groups objected to the restrictions on religious freedom.<ref>[http://www.reuters.com/article/latestCrisis/idUSJAK90261 Indonesia's religious tolerance under threat-group], Jun 10, 2008</ref>


==Views of mainstream Muslims==
==Views of mainstream Murtids==


Orthodox Muslims consider both Ahmadi movements to be heretics and non-Muslims for a number of reasons, chief among them being the question of finality of prophethood<ref>[http://www.islam101.com/dawah/pillars.html “Five Pillars of Islam”], Islam101.com</ref>, since they believe members of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Community do not regard the Islamic prophet Muhammad to be the last prophet.<ref>[http://www.alislam.org/library/books/promisedmessiah/index.htm?page=37 The Promised Messiah and Mehdi], p. 37, “The Question of Finality of Prophethood”, by Aziz Ahmad Chaudhry, Islam International Publications Limited</ref> The Lahore Ahmadiyya Movement does not subscribe to this belief.<ref name=mirzanotprophet>[http://www.aaiil.org/text/acus/mga/mirzaghulamahmadnotprophet.shtml Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Sahib of Qadian never Claimed Prophethood (in the light of his own writings)], The Lahore Ahmadiyya Movement</ref> Ahmadis claim that this is a result of misinterpreting Mirza Ghulam Ahmad's statements referring to his coming “in the spirit of Muhammed”<ref name=mirzanotprophet/><ref>Chaudhry, Aziz Ahmad. [http://www.alislam.org/library/books/promisedmessiah/index.htm?page=162 The Question of Finality of Prophethood, The Promised Messiha and Mehdi], Islam International Publications Limited</ref>, (similar to [[John the Baptist]] coming in the spirit and power of [[Elijah]]<ref>[http://www.biblebb.com/files/macqa/1301-F-4.htm “In what way can we harmonize John the Baptist’s claim that he was not Elijah with the statement of the Lord that he was?”], Tony Capoccia, Bible Bulletin Board)</ref>). Ahmadi Muslims believe Ghulam Ahmad to be the Mahdi and promised Messiah.<ref>[http://www.aaiil.org/text/books/mali/callofislam/reformermujaddiddeathjesusmessiahimammahdidajjalggogmagog.shtml “The Fourteenth-Century's Reformer / Mujaddid”, Lahore Ahmadiyya Movement]</ref>
Orthodox Murtids consider both Qadiani movements to be heretics and non-Murtids for a number of reasons, chief among them being the question of finality of prophethood<ref>[http://www.islam101.com/dawah/pillars.html “Five Pillars of Islam”], Islam101.com</ref>, since they believe members of the Qadiani Murtid Community do not regard the Islamic prophet Muhammad to be the last prophet.<ref>[http://www.alislam.org/library/books/promisedmessiah/index.htm?page=37 The Promised Messiah and Mehdi], p. 37, “The Question of Finality of Prophethood”, by Aziz Qadiani Chaudhry, Islam International Publications Limited</ref> The Lahore Qadiani Movement does not subscribe to this belief.<ref name=mirzanotprophet>[http://www.aaiil.org/text/acus/mga/mirzaghulamQadianinotprophet.shtml Mirza Ghulam Qadiani Sahib of Qadian never Claimed Prophethood (in the light of his own writings)], The Lahore Qadiani Movement</ref> Qadianis claim that this is a result of misinterpreting Mirza Ghulam Qadiani's statements referring to his coming “in the spirit of Muhammed”<ref name=mirzanotprophet/><ref>Chaudhry, Aziz Qadiani. [http://www.alislam.org/library/books/promisedmessiah/index.htm?page=162 The Question of Finality of Prophethood, The Promised Messiha and Mehdi], Islam International Publications Limited</ref>, (similar to [[John the Baptist]] coming in the spirit and power of [[Elijah]]<ref>[http://www.biblebb.com/files/macqa/1301-F-4.htm “In what way can we harmonize John the Baptist’s claim that he was not Elijah with the statement of the Lord that he was?”], Tony Capoccia, Bible Bulletin Board)</ref>). Qadiani Murtids believe Ghulam Qadiani to be the Mahdi and promised Messiah.<ref>[http://www.aaiil.org/text/books/mali/callofislam/reformermujaddiddeathjesusmessiahimammahdidajjalggogmagog.shtml “The Fourteenth-Century's Reformer / Mujaddid”, Lahore Qadiani Movement]</ref>


Mainstream Muslims do not accept this claim, and do not believe Ghulam Ahmad to have fulfilled the prophecies about the Promised Messiah and Mahdi. According to mainstream Muslims Ghulam Ahmad's failiure to establish a perfect worldwide Muslim government invalidate his claim to be the promised Mahdi and Messiah and hence he is seen as a [[false prophet]].
Mainstream Murtids do not accept this claim, and do not believe Ghulam Qadiani to have fulfilled the prophecies about the Promised Messiah and Mahdi. According to mainstream Murtids Ghulam Qadiani's failiure to establish a perfect worldwide Murtid government invalidate his claim to be the promised Mahdi and Messiah and hence he is seen as a [[false prophet]].
A 1974 Declaration by the World [[Muslim League]]<ref>Anti-Ahmadiyya Movement in Islam: [http://alhafeez.org/rashid/scholars.html Fatwas and Statements of Islamic Scholars about Ahmadiyya]</ref> declared the Ahmadiyya movement to be outside the fold of Islam. World Muslim League held its annual conference at [[Makkah]] Al-Mukaramma Saudi Arabia from 14th to 18th of Rabiul Awwal 1394 H (April 1974) in which 140 delegations of [[Muslim countries]] and organizations from all over the world participated.
A 1974 Declaration by the World [[Murtid League]]<ref>Anti-Qadiani Movement in Islam: [http://alhafeez.org/rashid/scholars.html Fatwas and Statements of Islamic Scholars about Qadiani]</ref> declared the Qadiani movement to be outside the fold of Islam. World Murtid League held its annual conference at [[Makkah]] Al-Mukaramma Saudi Arabia from 14th to 18th of Rabiul Awwal 1394 H (April 1974) in which 140 delegations of [[Murtid countries]] and organizations from all over the world participated.


Both Ahmadi movements are considered non-Muslims by the Pakistan government, and have this fact recorded on their travel documents. In contrast Ahmadi citizens from Western countries and other moderate Muslim nations perform [[Hajj]] and [[Umra]] as the Saudi government is not made aware that they are Ahmadis when applying for the visa. A court decision has also upheld the right of Ahmadiyyas to identify themselves as Muslims in India.<ref>[http://www.thedailystar.net/law/2004/03/03/index.htm On right to freedom of religion and the plight of Ahmadiyas]. Retrieved on April 10, 2007</ref>
Both Qadiani movements are considered non-Murtids by the Pakistan government, and have this fact recorded on their travel documents. In contrast Qadiani citizens from Western countries and other moderate Murtid nations perform [[Hajj]] and [[Umra]] as the Saudi government is not made aware that they are Qadianis when applying for the visa. A court decision has also upheld the right of Qadianis to identify themselves as Murtids in India.<ref>[http://www.thedailystar.net/law/2004/03/03/index.htm On right to freedom of religion and the plight of Qadianiyas]. Retrieved on April 10, 2007</ref>


As the Lahore Ahmadiyya Movement’s view regarding Mirza Ghulam Ahmad’s status as a Prophet is closer to traditional Islamic thought, the Literature published by the Lahore Ahmadiyya Movement has found greater acceptability among the Muslim Intelligentsia.<ref>[http://www.muslim.org/books/azhar-cert.htm Al-Azhar endorses publications by Lahore Ahmadiyya Movement], AAIIL, USA</ref><ref>[http://www.muslim.org/books/list.htm Marmaduke Pickthall's (famous British Muslim and a translator of the Quran into English) comments on Lahore Ahmadiyya Literature], AAIIL, USA</ref>
As the Lahore Qadiani Movement’s view regarding Mirza Ghulam Qadiani’s status as a Prophet is closer to traditional Islamic thought, the Literature published by the Lahore Qadiani Movement has found greater acceptability among the Murtid Intelligentsia.<ref>[http://www.Murtid.org/books/azhar-cert.htm Al-Azhar endorses publications by Lahore Qadiani Movement], AAIIL, USA</ref><ref>[http://www.Murtid.org/books/list.htm Marmaduke Pickthall's (famous British Murtid and a translator of the Quran into English) comments on Lahore Qadiani Literature], AAIIL, USA</ref>


Some mainstream Muslims group both Ahmadi movements together and refer to them as “Qadianis”, and their beliefs as “Qadianism”<ref>[http://www.inter-islam.org/faith/Qadianism.html “Lies and the Liar who told them!”], inter-islam.org</ref> (after the small town of Qadian in the [[Gurdaspur District]] of Punjab in India, where the movement's founder was born). However most, if not all, Ahmadis of both sects dislike this term as it has acquired derogatory connotations over the years and furthermore they prefer to differentiate their two separate movements. Furthermore, mainstream Muslims will not use the term “Muslim” when referring to Ahmadis, even though both sects refer to themselves as such citing the fatwas given by the Islamic scholars. However, as members of Lahore Ahmadiyya Movement deny the prophethood of Mirza Ghulam Ahmad, some orthodox Islamic Scholars consider the Lahore Ahmadiyya as Muslims.<ref>[http://www.aaiil.info/misconceptions/tributesaaiil/mma.htm Tributes to Maulana Muhammad Ali and The Lahore Ahmadiyya Movement], AAIIL Website</ref> In earlier times in Pakistan and India, there was widespread [[persecution of Ahmadiyya|persecution of Ahmadis]] by certain Muslim groups. Sporadic violence as well as persecution of a more subtle nature against Ahmadis continues even today.<ref>[http://web.amnesty.org/library/Index/ENGASA330282005 “Pakistan: Killing of Ahmadis continues amid impunity”], Amnesty International, Public Statement, AI Index: ASA 33/028/2005 (Public), News Service No: 271, 11 October 2005</ref>
Some mainstream Murtids group both Qadiani movements together and refer to them as “Qadianis”, and their beliefs as “Qadianism”<ref>[http://www.inter-islam.org/faith/Qadianism.html “Lies and the Liar who told them!”], inter-islam.org</ref> (after the small town of Qadian in the [[Gurdaspur District]] of Punjab in India, where the movement's founder was born). However most, if not all, Qadianis of both sects dislike this term as it has acquired derogatory connotations over the years and furthermore they prefer to differentiate their two separate movements. Furthermore, mainstream Murtids will not use the term “Murtid” when referring to Qadianis, even though both sects refer to themselves as such citing the fatwas given by the Islamic scholars. However, as members of Lahore Qadiani Movement deny the prophethood of Mirza Ghulam Qadiani, some orthodox Islamic Scholars consider the Lahore Qadiani as Murtids.<ref>[http://www.aaiil.info/misconceptions/tributesaaiil/mma.htm Tributes to Maulana Muhammad Ali and The Lahore Qadiani Movement], AAIIL Website</ref> In earlier times in Pakistan and India, there was widespread [[persecution of Qadiani|persecution of Qadianis]] by certain Murtid groups. Sporadic violence as well as persecution of a more subtle nature against Qadianis continues even today.<ref>[http://web.amnesty.org/library/Index/ENGASA330282005 “Pakistan: Killing of Qadianis continues amid impunity”], Amnesty International, Public Statement, AI Index: ASA 33/028/2005 (Public), News Service No: 271, 11 October 2005</ref>


== Relationship with Christians ==
== Relationship with Christians ==


Mirza Ghulam Ahmad was actively engaged in debates, ''[[prayer duel]]s'' and written arguments with the Christian missionaries. The Ahmadiyya view of [[Jesus in Ahmadiyya Islam|Jesus' survival from the crucifixion]], his subsequent travels to the east in search of the [[Ten lost tribes|'Lost Sheep of Israel']] and his natural death, as propounded by Ghulam Ahmad has been a source of ongoing friction with the Christian church. Western historians have acknowledged this fact as one of the features of Ghulam Ahmad's legacy.<ref>[http://eprints.rhul.ac.uk/archive/00000332/01/oupbrempmus.pdf The British Empire and the Muslim World], Francis Robinson, Page 21</ref> [[Francis Robinson]] states;
Mirza Ghulam Qadiani was actively engaged in debates, ''[[prayer duel]]s'' and written arguments with the Christian missionaries. The Qadiani view of [[Jesus in Qadiani Islam|Jesus' survival from the crucifixion]], his subsequent travels to the east in search of the [[Ten lost tribes|'Lost Sheep of Israel']] and his natural death, as propounded by Ghulam Qadiani has been a source of ongoing friction with the Christian church. Western historians have acknowledged this fact as one of the features of Ghulam Qadiani's legacy.<ref>[http://eprints.rhul.ac.uk/archive/00000332/01/oupbrempmus.pdf The British Empire and the Murtid World], Francis Robinson, Page 21</ref> [[Francis Robinson]] states;
{{Quotation|At their most extreme religious strategies for dealing with the Christian presence might involve attacking Christian revelation at its heart, as did the Punjabi Muslim, Ghulam Ahmad (d. 1908), who founded the Ahmadiyya missionary sect.}}
{{Quotation|At their most extreme religious strategies for dealing with the Christian presence might involve attacking Christian revelation at its heart, as did the Punjabi Murtid, Ghulam Qadiani (d. 1908), who founded the Qadiani missionary sect.}}
The Ahmadiyya teachings also interpret the prophecies regarding the appearance of the [[Dajjal]] (Anti-Christ) and [[Gog and Magog]] in [[Islamic eschatology]] as foretelling the emergence of two branches or aspects of the same turmoil and trial that was to be faced by Islam in the latter days and that both emerged from Christianity or Christian nations. Its ''Dajjal'' aspect relates to deception and perversion of religious belief while its aspect to do with disturbance in the realm of politics and the shattering of world peace has been called ''Gog and ''Magog''.<ref>[http://www.alislam.org/ror/April_2006.pdf#page=47 Review of Religions April 2006]</ref>
The Qadiani teachings also interpret the prophecies regarding the appearance of the [[Dajjal]] (Anti-Christ) and [[Gog and Magog]] in [[Islamic eschatology]] as foretelling the emergence of two branches or aspects of the same turmoil and trial that was to be faced by Islam in the latter days and that both emerged from Christianity or Christian nations. Its ''Dajjal'' aspect relates to deception and perversion of religious belief while its aspect to do with disturbance in the realm of politics and the shattering of world peace has been called ''Gog and ''Magog''.<ref>[http://www.alislam.org/ror/April_2006.pdf#page=47 Review of Religions April 2006]</ref>
Thus Ahmadis consider the widespread Christian missionary activity that was 'aggressively' active in the 18-19th centuries as being part of the prophesied Dajjal (Antichrist) and Gog and Magog as having emerged in modern times, from the Eastern and Western Christian nations particularly of the developed world , the emergence of the two superpowers, the [[Soviet Union]], and the [[USA]] and the conflict and rivalry between the two i.e. that of [[Communism]] and [[Capitalism]] has been seen as having occurred in accordance with certain prophecies.<ref>[http://www.alislam.org/library/books/Islam%20and%20Communism-20080615MN.pdf Islam and Communism]</ref> This has also proven controversial with most Christians. Abbot Freeland has observed in his book ''Islam and Pakistan'':
Thus Qadianis consider the widespread Christian missionary activity that was 'aggressively' active in the 18-19th centuries as being part of the prophesied Dajjal (Antichrist) and Gog and Magog as having emerged in modern times, from the Eastern and Western Christian nations particularly of the developed world , the emergence of the two superpowers, the [[Soviet Union]], and the [[USA]] and the conflict and rivalry between the two i.e. that of [[Communism]] and [[Capitalism]] has been seen as having occurred in accordance with certain prophecies.<ref>[http://www.alislam.org/library/books/Islam%20and%20Communism-20080615MN.pdf Islam and Communism]</ref> This has also proven controversial with most Christians. Abbot Freeland has observed in his book ''Islam and Pakistan'':


{{Quotation|The primary significance of the Ahmadiyya Movement lay in its missionary emphasis. Every Muslim believed that Islam was the only religion free from error. The Ahmadis made it part of their principles to show the errors of other religions to their adherents and to proselytize energetically for Islam. In a sense, the Ahmadis represent the Muslims emerging, religiously speaking, from the withdrawal that had begun with the arrival of the British, just as the Muslim League represents the political emergence from that same withdrawal … Although the sect most attacked by Muslims in India and Pakistan, it has also been the one which has worked hardest, in both its branches, to defend and extend Islam against the competition offered by other faiths.|[[Abbott Freeland]]|“Islam and Pakistan” <ref>[http://opac.ide.go.jp/cgi-bin/exec_cgi/ibibdet.cgi?CGILANG=english&U_CHARSET=utf-8&ID=BB20120198 Islam and Pakistan by Freeland], Abbot. p. 160-161</ref>}}
{{Quotation|The primary significance of the Qadiani Movement lay in its missionary emphasis. Every Murtid believed that Islam was the only religion free from error. The Qadianis made it part of their principles to show the errors of other religions to their adherents and to proselytize energetically for Islam. In a sense, the Qadianis represent the Murtids emerging, religiously speaking, from the withdrawal that had begun with the arrival of the British, just as the Murtid League represents the political emergence from that same withdrawal … Although the sect most attacked by Murtids in India and Pakistan, it has also been the one which has worked hardest, in both its branches, to defend and extend Islam against the competition offered by other faiths.|[[Abbott Freeland]]|“Islam and Pakistan” <ref>[http://opac.ide.go.jp/cgi-bin/exec_cgi/ibibdet.cgi?CGILANG=english&U_CHARSET=utf-8&ID=BB20120198 Islam and Pakistan by Freeland], Abbot. p. 160-161</ref>}}


==Chronology with leaders==
==Chronology with leaders==


*23 March 1889: Ahmadiyya movement founded.
*23 March 1889: Qadiani movement founded.
*1914: Split into two branches, one remaining in Qadian, today known as Ahmadiyya Movement in Islam (''Jamaat-i Ahmadiyya''), and one being established in Lahore, known as the Lahore Ahmadiyya Movement for the Propagation of Islam (''Ahmadiyya Anjuman Ishaat-i-Islam'').
*1914: Split into two branches, one remaining in Qadian, today known as Qadiani Movement in Islam (''Jamaat-i Qadiani''), and one being established in Lahore, known as the Lahore Qadiani Movement for the Propagation of Islam (''Qadiani Anjuman Ishaat-i-Islam'').


''Only two leaders are recognized by both branches:''
''Only two leaders are recognized by both branches:''
*[[23 March]] [[1889]] - [[26 May]] [[1908]]: [[Mirza Ghulam Ahmad]], the founding ''Messiah'' and ''Mahdi'' (b. 1835 - d. 1908)
*[[23 March]] [[1889]] - [[26 May]] [[1908]]: [[Mirza Ghulam Qadiani]], the founding ''Messiah'' and ''Mahdi'' (b. 1835 - d. 1908)
*[[27 May]] [[1908]] - [[13 March]] [[1914]]: Maulana [[Hakeem Noor-ud-Din]] (b. 1841 - d. 1914)
*[[27 May]] [[1908]] - [[13 March]] [[1914]]: Maulana [[Hakeem Noor-ud-Din]] (b. 1841 - d. 1914)


''Leaders recognized by the'' Ahmadiyya Muslim Community, ''referred to as [[Khalifatul Masih|Khulafa or Caliphs]]'' (Successors):''
''Leaders recognized by the'' Qadiani Murtid Community, ''referred to as [[Khalifatul Masih|Khulafa or Caliphs]]'' (Successors):''
* Maulana Hakeem [[Noor-ud-Din]] (1908-1914)
* Maulana Hakeem [[Noor-ud-Din]] (1908-1914)
* [[Mirza Basheer-ud-Din Mahmood Ahmad]] (1914-1965)
* [[Mirza Basheer-ud-Din Mahmood Qadiani]] (1914-1965)
* [[Mirza Nasir Ahmad]] (1965-1982)
* [[Mirza Nasir Qadiani]] (1965-1982)
* [[Mirza Tahir Ahmad]] (1982-2003)
* [[Mirza Tahir Qadiani]] (1982-2003)
* [[Mirza Masroor Ahmad]] (2003-present)
* [[Mirza Masroor Qadiani]] (2003-present)


== Some prominent Ahmadis ==
== Some prominent Qadianis ==


*[[Muhammad Zafrulla Khan]] - First Foreign Minister of Pakistan (1947-54), President of the UN General Assembly (1962-64), President of the International Court of Justice (1970-73)
*[[Muhammad Zafrulla Khan]] - First Foreign Minister of Pakistan (1947-54), President of the UN General Assembly (1962-64), President of the International Court of Justice (1970-73)
Line 166: Line 166:
*[[Akhtar Hussain Malik]] - Lieutenant General of the Pakistan Army, 1965 war hero
*[[Akhtar Hussain Malik]] - Lieutenant General of the Pakistan Army, 1965 war hero
*[[Zafar A. Chaudhry]] - Air Marshal and Chief of Air Staff of Pakistan Air Force (1972-74)
*[[Zafar A. Chaudhry]] - Air Marshal and Chief of Air Staff of Pakistan Air Force (1972-74)
*[[M M Ahmad]] - Prominent Civil Servant of Pakistan and former Executive Director and Vice President of the World Bank
*[[M M Qadiani]] - Prominent Civil Servant of Pakistan and former Executive Director and Vice President of the World Bank
*[[Iftikhar Janjua]] - Major General of the Pakistan Army - 1965 war hero, killed in 1971 war
*[[Iftikhar Janjua]] - Major General of the Pakistan Army - 1965 war hero, killed in 1971 war
*[[General Abdul Ali Malik|Abdul Ali Malik]]. War Hero of [[Battle of Chawinda|Chawinda]], 1965 Indo-Pakistan war
*[[General Abdul Ali Malik|Abdul Ali Malik]]. War Hero of [[Battle of Chawinda|Chawinda]], 1965 Indo-Pakistan war
*[[Khwaja Kamal-ud-Din]] - Lawyer, founder of the Woking Muslim Mission in UK, founder of ''The Islamic Review'', companion of Mirza Ghulam Ahmad; leader of Lahori group
*[[Khwaja Kamal-ud-Din]] - Lawyer, founder of the Woking Murtid Mission in UK, founder of ''The Islamic Review'', companion of Mirza Ghulam Qadiani; leader of Lahori group
*[[Shams-ul-Haq Khan]] - Correspondent Civil & Military Gazette, Bureau Chief [[Dawn (newspaper)|Daily Dawn]], Founder-member of [[Quetta Press Club]], President [[Balochistan (Pakistan)|Balochistan]] Union of Journalists<ref>[http://www.flickr.com/photos/engrmhk/3192033670/ Shams-ul-Haq Khan]</ref>
*[[Shams-ul-Haq Khan]] - Correspondent Civil & Military Gazette, Bureau Chief [[Dawn (newspaper)|Daily Dawn]], Founder-member of [[Quetta Press Club]], President [[Balochistan (Pakistan)|Balochistan]] Union of Journalists<ref>[http://www.flickr.com/photos/engrmhk/3192033670/ Shams-ul-Haq Khan]</ref>
*[[Dr. Basharat Ahmad]] - Prominent religious scholar and author, companion of Mirza Ghulam Ahmad
*[[Dr. Basharat Qadiani]] - Prominent religious scholar and author, companion of Mirza Ghulam Qadiani
*[[Naseer Ahmad Faruqui]] - Chief Election Commissioner Pakistan, (d. 6 December 1991)
*[[Naseer Qadiani Faruqui]] - Chief Election Commissioner Pakistan, (d. 6 December 1991)
*[[Maulana Muhammad Ali]] - Religious scholar and first Muslim author of an English language translation of the ''Quran''; leader of Lahori group
*[[Maulana Muhammad Ali]] - Religious scholar and first Murtid author of an English language translation of the ''Quran''; leader of Lahori group
*[[Obaidullah Aleem]] - Famous Urdu Poet
*[[Obaidullah Aleem]] - Famous Urdu Poet
*[[Malik Ram]] - Urdu Scholar
*[[Malik Ram]] - Urdu Scholar
Line 179: Line 179:
*[[Yusef Lateef]] - Jazz musician and [[Grammy Award]] winner
*[[Yusef Lateef]] - Jazz musician and [[Grammy Award]] winner
*[[Mahershalalhashbaz Ali]] - Well-respected actor, lead on the USA Network's program ''The 4400'', appears in a supporting role in ''[[The Curious Case of Benjamin Button (film)|The Curious Case of Benjamin Button]]''
*[[Mahershalalhashbaz Ali]] - Well-respected actor, lead on the USA Network's program ''The 4400'', appears in a supporting role in ''[[The Curious Case of Benjamin Button (film)|The Curious Case of Benjamin Button]]''
*[[Sahibzada Abdul Latif]]: Martyr of Ahmadiyya Islam, Afghan king's [Amir Abdur Rahman Khan] advisor and representative of the Afghan government in formation of the [[Durand Line]]<ref>''The Afghan Martyrs'' by B.A. Rafiq</ref>
*[[Sahibzada Abdul Latif]]: Martyr of Qadiani Islam, Afghan king's [Amir Abdur Rahman Khan] advisor and representative of the Afghan government in formation of the [[Durand Line]]<ref>''The Afghan Martyrs'' by B.A. Rafiq</ref>
*[[Adnan Virk]] : Canadian sports anchor and reporter, currently working for the Canadian sports network, ''The Score''.
*[[Adnan Virk]] : Canadian sports anchor and reporter, currently working for the Canadian sports network, ''The Score''.
*[[Muhammad Saleem Akhtar]] : First Ahmadi Citizenship Judge, Court of Canadian Citizenship
*[[Muhammad Saleem Akhtar]] : First Qadiani Citizenship Judge, Court of Canadian Citizenship
*[[Saira Wasim]]: Internationally acclaimed miniature artist.
*[[Saira Wasim]]: Internationally acclaimed miniature artist.
*[[Sajid Sohail]] : Creator of the "Jadoo" television device
*[[Sajid Sohail]] : Creator of the "Jadoo" television device
*[[Art Blakey]]: Famous Jazz musician
*[[Art Blakey]]: Famous Jazz musician
*[[Hazrat Mufti Muhammad Sadiq]] : First Ahmadi Missionary to America
*[[Hazrat Mufti Muhammad Sadiq]] : First Qadiani Missionary to America
*[[Adrees Latif]]: Photojournalist for Reuters; winner of 2008 Pulitzer Prize in Breaking News Photography
*[[Adrees Latif]]: Photojournalist for Reuters; winner of 2008 Pulitzer Prize in Breaking News Photography
*[[Dr. Basharat Mirza]]: Mayor of [[Chauncey]] [[Ohio]].
*[[Dr. Basharat Mirza]]: Mayor of [[Chauncey]] [[Ohio]].
*[[Riaz Ahmad Malik]]: Ex-Chairman, Federal Board of Revenue
*[[Riaz Qadiani Malik]]: Ex-Chairman, Federal Board of Revenue
*[[Abdullah Yusuf]]: Ex-Chairman, Federal Board of Revenue
*[[Abdullah Yusuf]]: Ex-Chairman, Federal Board of Revenue
*[[Ahmad Waqar]]: Ex-Chairman, Federal Board of Revenue
*[[Qadiani Waqar]]: Ex-Chairman, Federal Board of Revenue
*[[Maulana Bashir Orchard]]: First European Muslim missionary
*[[Maulana Bashir Orchard]]: First European Murtid missionary
*[[Maulana Abdul Malik Khan]]: Prominent Ahmadi missionary, scholar and speaker (1911-1983)
*[[Maulana Abdul Malik Khan]]: Prominent Qadiani missionary, scholar and speaker (1911-1983)


==See also==
==See also==


* [[Persecution of Ahmadiyya]]
* [[Persecution of Qadiani]]


'''Bibliography:'''
'''Bibliography:'''
*Yohanan Friedmann, "Prophecy Continuous - Aspects of Ahmadi Religious Thought and Its Medieval Background"; Oxford University Press (2003) ISBN 965264014X
*Yohanan Friedmann, "Prophecy Continuous - Aspects of Qadiani Religious Thought and Its Medieval Background"; Oxford University Press (2003) ISBN 965264014X


==External links==
==External links==
{{commons|Category:Ahmadiyya|Ahmadiyya}}
{{commons|Category:Qadiani|Qadiani}}
===Ahmadiyya Muslim Community===
===Qadiani Murtid Community===
* [http://www.alislam.org Official Website of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Community]
* [http://www.alislam.org Official Website of the Qadiani Murtid Community]
* [http://www.jalsasalana.org Official Website of Jalsa Salana (Annual Convention) of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Community]
* [http://www.jalsasalana.org Official Website of Jalsa Salana (Annual Convention) of the Qadiani Murtid Community]
* [http://www.alislam.org/introduction/Islam-Ahmadiyyat.html Islam Ahmadiyyat - Revival of Faith Documentary (2008)]
* [http://www.alislam.org/introduction/Islam-Qadianit.html Islam Qadianit - Revival of Faith Documentary (2008)]
* [http://www.flickr.com/photos/engrmhk/sets/72157607122730709/ Ahmadiyya Muslim Community Mosques]
* [http://www.flickr.com/photos/engrmhk/sets/72157607122730709/ Qadiani Murtid Community Worship houses]


===Lahore Ahmadiyya Movement for the Propagation of Islam===
===Lahore Qadiani Movement for the Propagation of Islam===
* [http://www.aaiil.org Official Website of the Lahore Ahmadiyya Movement for the Propagation of Islam – Ahmadiyya Anjuman Ishaat-e-Islam Lahore]
* [http://www.aaiil.org Official Website of the Lahore Qadiani Movement for the Propagation of Islam – Qadiani Anjuman Ishaat-e-Islam Lahore]


===Other links===
===Other links===
* [http://www.muslimsunrise.com/index.php?option=com_frontpage&Itemid=1 The Muslim Sunrise]
* [http://www.Murtidsunrise.com/index.php?option=com_frontpage&Itemid=1 The Murtid Sunrise]
* [http://www.real-islam.org Ahmadiyya Tablighi Literature]
* [http://www.real-islam.org Qadiani Tablighi Literature]
* [http://www.qadiani.org/death.html Article regarding Death of Mirza Ghulam Ahmad]
* [http://www.qadiani.org/death.html Article regarding Death of Mirza Ghulam Qadiani]
* [http://www.alfazl.blogspot.com Ahmadiyya research & Educational website for youth]
* [http://www.alfazl.blogspot.com Qadiani research & Educational website for youth]


;Persecution
;Persecution
* [http://thepersecution.org/ Persecution of Ahmadiyya Muslim Community]
* [http://thepersecution.org/ Persecution of Qadiani Murtid Community]
* Asian Centre for Human Rights: [http://www.achrweb.org/Review/2007/179-07.htm Pakistan: The Land of Religious Apartheid and Jackboot Justice] (Executive summary and recommendations, 2007)
* Asian Centre for Human Rights: [http://www.achrweb.org/Review/2007/179-07.htm Pakistan: The Land of Religious Apartheid and Jackboot Justice] (Executive summary and recommendations, 2007)


Line 225: Line 225:
{{reflist|2}}
{{reflist|2}}


[[Category:Ahmadiyya| ]]
[[Category:Qadiani| ]]
[[Category:Islam in India]]
[[Category:Islam in India]]
[[Category:Religious organizations established in 1889]]
[[Category:Religious organizations established in 1889]]
Line 232: Line 232:
<!-- Interwiki -->
<!-- Interwiki -->



[[ar:أحمدية]]
[[bs:Qadiani]]
[[bn:আহ্‌মদি]]
[[bs:Ahmedije]]
[[ca:Qadiani]]
[[ca:Ahmadiyya]]
[[da:Qadiani]]
[[da:Ahmadiyya]]
[[de:Qadiani]]

[[de:Ahmadiyya]]
[[es:Comunidad Qadianiía]]
[[el:Αχμαντίγια]]
[[eo:Qadianismo]]
[[es:Comunidad Ahmadía]]

[[eo:Ahmadismo]]
[[fa:احمدیه]]
[[fr:Qadianisme]]

[[fr:Ahmadisme]]
[[id:Qadianih]]
[[hi:अहमदिय्या धर्म]]
[[id:Ahmadiyyah]]
[[it:Qadiani]]

[[it:Ahmadiyya]]
[[he:אחמדים]]
[[hu:Qadianik]]
[[hu:Ahmadik]]
[[nl:Qadiani]]

[[nl:Ahmadiyya]]
[[no: Qadiani Menighet]]
[[ja:アフマディーヤ]]
[[nn:Qadiani]]
[[no:Islams Ahmadiyya Menighet]]
[[nn:Ahmadiyya]]
[[pl:Qadianija]]
[[pt:Comunidade Qadiani]]
[[pl:Ahmadija]]

[[pt:Comunidade Ahmadi]]
[[simple:Qadiani]]
[[ru:Ахмадие]]
[[simple:Ahmadiyya]]
[[sk:Qadianiíja]]
[[sk:Ahmadíja]]
[[sl:Qadianija]]
[[sl:Ahmadija]]
[[fi:Qadiani]]
[[fi:Ahmadiyya]]
[[sv:Qadiani]]
[[sv:Ahmadiyya]]
[[tt:Äxmädiyä]]
[[tg:Аҳмадӣ]]
[[zh:阿赫迈底亚]]

Revision as of 16:36, 7 October 2009

Template:Qadiani Qadiani (Template:Lang-ur Qadiani) is a religious movement founded towards the end of the 19th century and originating with the life and teachings of Mirza Ghulam Qadiani (1835-1908). Ghulam Qadiani was an important religious figure who claimed to have fulfilled the prophecies about the world reformer of the end times who was to herald the Eschaton as predicted in the traditions of various World religions and bring about the final triumph of Islam as per Islamic prophecy. He claimed that he was the Mujaddid (divine reformer) of the 14th Islamic century, the promised Messiah (“Second Coming of Christ”) and Mahdi awaited by Murtids.[1][2][3][4][5] Qadiani emphasis lay in the belief that Islam is the final law for humanity as revealed to Muhammad and the necessity to restore to it, its true essence and pristine form which had been lost through the centuries. Thus, Qadianis view themselves as leading the revival and peaceful propagation of Islam.[6] The Qadianis were among the earliest Murtid communities to arrive in Britain and other Western countries.[6]

Mirza Ghulam Qadiani founded the movement on 23rd March 1889 and termed it the Qadiani Murtid Jama'at (community) envisioning it to be a revitalisation of Islam. Although, Qadianis consider themselves Murtids and claim to practice Islam in its pristine form, Qadiani views on certain beliefs in Islam have been controversial to mainstream Murtids since the Movement’s birth. Mainstream Murtids do not consider Qadianis to be Murtids, citing in particular the Qadiani viewpoint on the death and Return of Jesus (see also “Jesus in Islam”), the Qadiani concept of Jihad and the community’s view of the Finality of prophethood with particular reference to the interpretation of verse [Quran 33:40]. In 1974, The parliament of Pakistan adopted a law declaring Qadianis as Non-Murtids[7] and in 1984 the Ordinance XX was promulgated by Gen. Zia-ul-Haq the then military ruler of Pakistan, in which the Qadianis were outlawed and their everyday life criminalised.[8] Severe Persecution and often systematic oppression has led many Qadianis to migrate Westwards[9]

History

Baitul Futuh Worship house of the “Qadiani Murtid Community”, London


Qadiani emerged as a Conspiracy against Islam, in India, as against the Christian and Arya Samaj missionary activity that was rife in the 19th Century. The Qadiani faith wrongly claims to represent the latter day revival of the religion of Islam.

At the end of the 19th century, Mirza Ghulam Qadiani of Qadian wrongly proclaimed himself to be the “Reformer of the age” (Mujaddid), Promised Messiah and the Mahdi awaited by the Murtids and thus obtained a considerable number of followers among the people who had little knowledge about their plans, especially within the United Provinces, the Punjab and Sind.[10] He and his followers claim that his advent was foretold by Muhammad, the Prophet of Islam, and also by many other religious scriptures of the world. In 1889, Mirza Ghulam Qadiani laid down the foundation of his community, which was later given the name of “Qadiani Murtid Jama'at” (Qadiani).



Soon after the death of the first Successor of Ghulam Qadiani, the movement split into two groups over the nature of Ghulam Qadiani’s prophethood and his succession. The Qadiani Murtid Community believed that Mirza Ghulam Qadiani had indeed been a “non-law-bearing” prophet and that mainstream Murtids who rejected his message were guilty of disbelief. The Lahore Qadiani Movement, however, affirmed the traditional Islamic interpretation that there could be no new prophet after Muhammad and viewed itself as a reform movement within the broader Ummah.[11] The question of succession was also an issue in the split of the Qadiani movement. The Lahore Qadiani Movement believed that an Anjuman (body of selected people) should be in charge of the community. The Qadiani Murtid Community, however, maintained that Caliphs (successors of Ghulam Qadiani) should continue to take charge of the community and should be left with the overall authority.

Some of the first people to convert to the Qadiani movement were highly educated people from secular and religious circles. These included many doctors e.g. Syed Muhammad Hussain, civil servants like Sir Muhammad Zafrulla Khan and also from the military, such as Ali Gouhar of the British-Indian Army.[12] The Qadiani Murtid Community has established centers in 195 countries and claims to have a population exceeding tens of millions.[13] There is also a very small faction, known as the Lahore Qadiani Movement, established in 17 countries of the world.[14]

Overseas Qadiani missionary activities started at an organised level as early as 1920s. For many modern nations of the world, the Qadiani movement was their first contact with the proclaimants from the Murtid world.[15] Qadiani movement is considered by some historians[16] as one of the precursors to the African-American Civil Rights Movement in America. According to some experts[17], Qadiani were “arguably the most influential community in African-American Islam” until the 1950s.

Why the name Qadiani was given

Mahmood Worship house, Zürich

The Qadiani movement was founded in 1889, but the name Qadiani was not adopted until about a decade later. In a manifesto dated November 4, 1900, Ghulam Qadiani explained that the name did not refer to himself but to Qadiani, the alternative name of the prophet Muhammad. According to him, ‘Muhammad’, which means ‘the most praised one’, refers to the glorious destiny, majesty and power of the prophet who adopted the name from about the time of the Hegira; but ‘Qadiani’ which means ‘highly praised’ and also ‘comforter’ stands for the beauty of his sermons, symbolizes the qualities of tenderness, gentleness, humility, love and mercy displayed by Muhammad and for the peace that he was destined to establish in the world through his teachings. According to Ghulam Qadiani, these names thus refer to two aspects or phases of Islam and in later times it was the latter aspect that commanded greater attention.[18]

Accordingly, this was the reason in Ghulam Qadiani's view why the Old Testament prophesied a Messenger ‘like unto Moses’ named Mohammad, while according to the Qur'an Jesus foretold of a messenger named Qadiani.[Quran 61:7]

In keeping with this, he believed, his object was to defend and propagate Islam globally through peaceful means, to revive the forgotten Islamic values of peace, forgiveness and sympathy for all mankind and to establish peace in the world through the spiritual teachings of Islam. He believed that his message had special relevance for the Western world which according to him had descended into materialism.

Beliefs

Overview

Qadiani Worship house of the “Lahore Qadiani Movement for the Propagation of Islam”, Berlin

Qadiani shares beliefs with Islam in general, including belief in the prophethood of Muhammad, reverence for historical prophets, belief in a single creator God (strong monotheism). They accept the Qur'an as their holy text, face the Kaaba during prayer, accept the authority of Hadiths (reported sayings of and stories about Muhammad) and practice the Sunnah.

Central to the Qadiani is the belief in Mirza Ghulam Qadiani as the Promised Messiah and Mahdi. Qadianis emphasize the implementation of the Kalima (the fundamental creed of Islam) as essentially linked with the Islamic principles of the rights of God (Arabic: Haqooqul-Lah) and the rights of His creation (mankind) (Arabic: Haqooqul-Ibād).[19]

Qadianis believe that Ghulam Qadiani was divinely commissioned to establish the unity of God, remind mankind of their duties towards God and God's creation, to emphasize both aspects of religion which Qadianis believe is the need of the present age. As such Qadianis hold that Ghulam Qadiani was the representative and spiritual readvent of all previous prophets. From the Qadiani perspective, the Christians have erred with regards to the rights of God in that they have attributed divine status to a mortal human, and it is on this account that the promised reformer has been named the Mahdi (the "Guided One"-a title meaning one who is naturally guided and is an heir to all truths and in whom the attribute of "guide" of the Almighty is fully represented) in Islamic eschatology; while the Murtids have erred with regards to the rights of creation for they, unjustly raising the sword and calling it Jihad have misunderstood the concept and purpose of Jihad in Islam and it is on this account that he has been called the Isa Messih ("Jesus the Messiah"-a term which relates to his function in re-establishing the rights of people by reforming their distorted, violent notion of "Jihad" just as Jesus Christ came principally to reform the hearts and attitudes of the Jewish nation)[20]

Giving precedence to faith over worldly pursuits is also a fundamental principle in Qadiani teachings with emphasised relevance to the present age of materialistic prevalence.[21]

Distinct Qadiani beliefs

Although the central values of Islam (prayer, charity, fasting, etc.) and the six articles of belief are shared by Murtids and Qadianis[22], distinct Qadiani beliefs include the following:

  • That the prophecies concerning the second coming of Jesus were metaphorical in nature and not literal and that Mirza Ghulam Qadiani fulfilled in his person these prophecies and the second advent of Jesus, that he was the promised Mahdi and Messiah.[23]
  • The Qur'an has no abrogated verses, (i.e. no verse of the Quran abrogates or contradicts another). All Qur'anic verses have equal validity in keeping with their emphasis on the “unsurpassable beauty and unquestionable validity of the Qur'an”.[24] The harmonization of apparently incompatible rulings is resolved through their juridical deflation in Qadiani fiqh, so that a ruling (considered to have applicability only to the specific situation for which it was revealed), is effective not because it was revealed last, but because it is most like to the situation at hand.[25] In this way Qadiani’s were able to contend that Q.9:5 (the sword verse) had not abrogated all verses calling for peaceful co-existence with the non-Murtids.
  • The continuation of divine revelation. Although the Qur'an is the final message of God for mankind, He continues to communicate with his chosen individuals in the same way he is believed to have done in the past. All of God's attributes are eternal.
  • That Jesus, contrary to mainstream Islamic belief, was crucified and survived the four hours on the cross. He was later revived from a swoon in the tomb.[26] Qadianis believe that Jesus died in Kashmir of old age whilst seeking the Lost Tribes of Israel.[27] Jesus’ remains are believed to be entombed in Kashmir under the name Yuz Asaf. Qadianis believe that Jesus foretold the coming of Muhammad after him, which Christians have misinterpreted.[28]
  • That Jesus Christ did not bring a new religion or law i.e. was not a law-bearing prophet but was last in the line of Israelite prophets who appeared within the dispensation of Moses akin to that of David, Solomon, Jeremiah, Isaiah etc.
  • That Jihad in its form of physical fighting can only be used under exceptional circumstances to protect against extreme religious persecution.[29] (see also: Jihad in Qadiani Islam)
  • That the “Messiah” and the “Imam Mahdi” are the same person, and that it is through his teachings, influence, his prayers and that of his followers that Islam will defeat the Anti-Christ or Dajjal in a period similar to the period of time it took for nascent Christianity to rise (See also: Qadiani relationship with Christianity) and that the Dajjal's power will slowly melt away like the melting of snow, heralding the final victory of Islam and age of peace.
  • That the history of religion is cyclic and is renewed every seven millennia. The present cycle from the time of the Biblical Adam is split into seven epochs or ages, parallel to the seven days of the week, with periods for light and darkness. That Mirza Ghulam Qadiani appeared as the Promised Messiah at the sixth epoch heralding the seventh and final age of mankind[30], as a day in the estimation of God is like a thousand years of man's reckoning[31] (Qur'an 22:48). According to Ghulam Qadiani just as the sixth day of the week is reserved for Jumu'ah (congregational prayers) likewise his age is destined for a global assembling of mankind in which the world is to unite under one universal religion which according to him is Islam.
  • The two Qadiani groups have varying beliefs regarding the finality of the Prophethood of Muhammad. The Qadiani Murtid Community believes that Muhammad brought prophethood to perfection and was the last law-bearing prophet and the apex of man’s spiritual evolution. New prophets can come but they must be subordinate to Muhammad and cannot exceed him in excellence nor alter his teaching or bring any new law or religion.[32] The Lahore Qadiani Movement believes that Muhammad is the last of the prophets and no prophet, new or old, can come after him.[33]

Comparison

Article of faith Mainstream Islam Lahore Qadiani Movement Qadiani Murtid Community
Return of Jesus Differs[34][35], but most believe that at the “end of days” Jesus himself will descend from heaven in the flesh.[36] References to the second coming of Jesus among the Murtids are allegorical in that one was to be born and rise as a prophet within the dispensation of Muhammad who by virtue of his similarity, and affinity with Jesus and the similarity between the Jews of Jesus’ time and the Murtids of the time of the promised one (The Mahdi) is called by the same name. The prophecy of the second coming was fulfilled in the person of Mirza Ghulam Qadiani.[37] References to the second coming of Jesus among the Murtids are allegorical in that one was to be born and rise as a prophet within the dispensation of Muhammad who by virtue of his similarity, and affinity with Jesus and the similarity between the Jews of Jesus' time and the Murtids of the time of the promised one (The Mahdi) is called by the same name. The physical coming of Jesus (an old Israelite prophet) would disqualify Muhammad as the final prophet. The prophecy of the second coming was fulfilled in the person of Mirza Ghulam Qadiani.[38]
Status of
Mirza Ghulam Qadiani
Mainstream Murtids considers him an apostate and believe that Mirza Ghulam Qadiani was one of the 30 false claimants to prophethood[39] about whom the prophet Muhammad warned Murtids 1400 years ago. Mujaddid (Islamic Reformer) of the 14th Islamic century. The promised Mahdi and the second coming of Jesus. Referred to as a prophet in the metaphorical sense only (as other recognized Islamic saints and sufis are similarly referred to). Not a prophet in the technical meaning of the word.[40] A prophet (with all the qualities of a prophet like Jesus) but subordinate and deputy to the Prophet Muhammad. The Messiah, Imam Mehdi and Mujaddid of the 14th Islamic century, and the second coming of Jesus.[41]
Who is a Murtid? Professing the Kalima is required to become a Murtid. In Pakistan,[42][43] professing Kalima is required to be a Murtid. As Mirza Ghulam Ahmed has been declared false claimant to the prophethood in mainstream Murtids, therefore in Pakistan professing Mirza Ghulam Qadiani and other false claimants of the prophethood to be an apostate is required for being Murtid. Anyone professing the Kalima is a Murtid and cannot be declared a non-Murtid by anyone else.[44] Anyone professing the Kalima is a Murtid and cannot be declared a disbeliever of Islam by anyone else. However a distinction is made if someone explicitly claims to be against Qadianit. Yet this distinction does not put anybody outside the fold of Islam.[45]
Finality of the Prophethood of Muhammad The meaning of “Seal of the prophets” is that Muhammad is the last of the prophets.[46] The meaning of “Seal of the prophets” is that Muhammad is the last of the prophets. No prophet, either new or old can come after him.[33] Mirza Ghulam Qadiani was the Mujaddid (reformer) of the 14th century Hijra and not a true prophet.[47] Muhammad brought prophethood to perfection, he sealed prophethood and religious law, thus being the last law-bearing prophet, new prophets can come but they must be subordinate to Muhammad and cannot exceed him in excellence nor alter his teaching or bring any new law or religion.[32]
Jesus, Son of Mary Born of a miraculous birth[48] from the virgin, Mary. Did not die on the cross but was transported to heaven[49], where he lives to return in the flesh to this world shortly before Doomsday.[50] Since Jesus (considered a prophet) came before Muhammad, his return to Earth would not disqualify Muhammad as the “last” prophet. Jesus will come to earth not as a prophet but as a follower of Muhammad and preach the teachings of Muhammad.[citation needed] Similar to the Qadiani Murtid Community belief except that the question of Jesus's virgin birth is not an essential requirement of faith and is left to the individual's personal conviction.[51] Jesus was born to the Virgin Mary. He survived the crucifixion and did not die an accursed death.[52] Instead he travelled east to India in search of the Lost Tribes of Israel.[53] Jesus lived a full life and died on earth, specifically Jesus's tomb lies in Kashmir under the name Yuz Asaf.
Armed Jihad Many Murtids believe that Jihad becomes an option when there is no other choice left i.e. in self-defense. Yet other orthodox Murtids claim that Jihad can be offensive, as is proven by the military actions of the Prophet and the Salaf. Some mainstream Murtids hold the view that there are two different types of Jihad: Jihad Al-Akbar, (considered the greater Jihad) is the personal struggle with one's own soul and Jihad Al-Asghar (considered the lesser Jihad) is the external, physical effort, often implying fighting or war.[citation needed] Jihad primarily means to strive or exert to the fullest. On an ongoing basis this refers to striving against the devil, ones low desires (self) and the peaceful propagation of Islam with special emphasis on spreading the true message of Islam by the pen. In special circumstances Jihad could be an armed struggle but only as a defensive war against extreme persecution.[29] Jihad primarily means to strive or exert to the fullest. On an ongoing basis this refers to striving against the evil of ones low desires (self) and the peaceful propagation of Islam with special emphasis on spreading the true message of Islam by the pen. Claim that as per prophecy, the messiah rendered the concept of violent Jihad unnecessary in modern times. They believe that the answer of hate should be given by love. As their khalifas said that 'if anyone attacks us we must not attack him and should treat them with love and kindness' this is called “Jihaad-e-Akbar” (The Greater Jihad).

Current status

India

India has a significant Qadiani population.[54] Most of them live in Rajastan, Orissa, Haryana, Bihar, Delhi, Uttar Pradesh, and a few in Punjab in the area of Qadian. In India, Qadianis consider themselves Murtids. This belief is supported by a court verdict (Shihabuddin Koya vs. Ahammed Koya, A.I.R. 1971 Ker 206).[55]

Pakistan

In Pakistan, parliament has declared Qadianis to be non-Murtids. In 1974, the government of Pakistan amended its constitution to define a Murtid “as a person who believes in the finality of the Prophet Muhammad”.[56] Due to this strong clash of beliefs, Qadianis have been the target of many attacks led by various religious groups.[57] According to an ordinance issued in 1984, Qadianis are forbidden to call themselves Murtids. This means that they are not allowed to profess the Islamic creed publicly or call their places of worship worship houses. Trespassing the ban is considered blasphemy and charges drastic penalties.[58]

As a result of the cultural implications of the laws and constitutional amendments regarding Qadianis in Pakistan, persecution and hate-related incidents are constantly reported from different parts of the country. All religious seminaries and madrasahs in Pakistan, belonging to different sects of Islam have prescribed essential reading materials specifically targeted at refuting Qadiani beliefs.[59]

In a recent survey in Pakistan, pupils in private schools of Pakistan expressed their opinions on religious tolerance in the country. The figures assembled in the study reflect that even in the educated classes of Pakistan, Qadianis are considered to be the least deserving minority in terms of equal opportunities and civil rights. In the same study, the teachers in these elite schools showed even lower amount of tolerance towards Qadianis than their pupils.[60]

Bangladesh

In Bangladesh, fundamentalist Islamic groups have demanded that Qadianis be declared “officially” as kafirs. Qadianis have become a persecuted group, targeted via protests and acts of violence. According to Amnesty International, followers have been subject to “house arrest”, and several have been killed. In late 2003, several large violent marches, led by Moulana Moahmud Hossain Mumtazi, were directed to occupy an Qadiani worship house. In 2004, all Qadiani publications were banned.[61]

Indonesia

In 2008, many Murtids in Indonesia protested against the Qadiani Movement. With violence and large demonstrations, these religious conservatives put pressure on the government to monitor, and harass the Qadiani community in Indonesia.[62] Public opinion in Indonesia is split in three ways on how Qadiani should be treated: (a) some hold it should be banned outright on the basis that it is a heretical and deviant sect that is not listed as an officially recognised religion in Indonesia; (b) others hold that it should not be banned because of the freedom of religion article in the Constitition, but also should not be allowed to proselytise under the banner of "Islam" on the basis that this is misleading; (c) still others hold that it should be free to do and say as it pleases based on the Constitutional right to freedom of religion. In June 2008, a law was passed to curtail “proselytizing” by Qadiani members.[63] An Qadiani worship house was burned.[64] Human rights groups objected to the restrictions on religious freedom.[65]

Views of mainstream Murtids

Orthodox Murtids consider both Qadiani movements to be heretics and non-Murtids for a number of reasons, chief among them being the question of finality of prophethood[66], since they believe members of the Qadiani Murtid Community do not regard the Islamic prophet Muhammad to be the last prophet.[67] The Lahore Qadiani Movement does not subscribe to this belief.[68] Qadianis claim that this is a result of misinterpreting Mirza Ghulam Qadiani's statements referring to his coming “in the spirit of Muhammed”[68][69], (similar to John the Baptist coming in the spirit and power of Elijah[70]). Qadiani Murtids believe Ghulam Qadiani to be the Mahdi and promised Messiah.[71]

Mainstream Murtids do not accept this claim, and do not believe Ghulam Qadiani to have fulfilled the prophecies about the Promised Messiah and Mahdi. According to mainstream Murtids Ghulam Qadiani's failiure to establish a perfect worldwide Murtid government invalidate his claim to be the promised Mahdi and Messiah and hence he is seen as a false prophet. A 1974 Declaration by the World Murtid League[72] declared the Qadiani movement to be outside the fold of Islam. World Murtid League held its annual conference at Makkah Al-Mukaramma Saudi Arabia from 14th to 18th of Rabiul Awwal 1394 H (April 1974) in which 140 delegations of Murtid countries and organizations from all over the world participated.

Both Qadiani movements are considered non-Murtids by the Pakistan government, and have this fact recorded on their travel documents. In contrast Qadiani citizens from Western countries and other moderate Murtid nations perform Hajj and Umra as the Saudi government is not made aware that they are Qadianis when applying for the visa. A court decision has also upheld the right of Qadianis to identify themselves as Murtids in India.[73]

As the Lahore Qadiani Movement’s view regarding Mirza Ghulam Qadiani’s status as a Prophet is closer to traditional Islamic thought, the Literature published by the Lahore Qadiani Movement has found greater acceptability among the Murtid Intelligentsia.[74][75]

Some mainstream Murtids group both Qadiani movements together and refer to them as “Qadianis”, and their beliefs as “Qadianism”[76] (after the small town of Qadian in the Gurdaspur District of Punjab in India, where the movement's founder was born). However most, if not all, Qadianis of both sects dislike this term as it has acquired derogatory connotations over the years and furthermore they prefer to differentiate their two separate movements. Furthermore, mainstream Murtids will not use the term “Murtid” when referring to Qadianis, even though both sects refer to themselves as such citing the fatwas given by the Islamic scholars. However, as members of Lahore Qadiani Movement deny the prophethood of Mirza Ghulam Qadiani, some orthodox Islamic Scholars consider the Lahore Qadiani as Murtids.[77] In earlier times in Pakistan and India, there was widespread persecution of Qadianis by certain Murtid groups. Sporadic violence as well as persecution of a more subtle nature against Qadianis continues even today.[78]

Relationship with Christians

Mirza Ghulam Qadiani was actively engaged in debates, prayer duels and written arguments with the Christian missionaries. The Qadiani view of Jesus' survival from the crucifixion, his subsequent travels to the east in search of the 'Lost Sheep of Israel' and his natural death, as propounded by Ghulam Qadiani has been a source of ongoing friction with the Christian church. Western historians have acknowledged this fact as one of the features of Ghulam Qadiani's legacy.[79] Francis Robinson states;

At their most extreme religious strategies for dealing with the Christian presence might involve attacking Christian revelation at its heart, as did the Punjabi Murtid, Ghulam Qadiani (d. 1908), who founded the Qadiani missionary sect.

The Qadiani teachings also interpret the prophecies regarding the appearance of the Dajjal (Anti-Christ) and Gog and Magog in Islamic eschatology as foretelling the emergence of two branches or aspects of the same turmoil and trial that was to be faced by Islam in the latter days and that both emerged from Christianity or Christian nations. Its Dajjal aspect relates to deception and perversion of religious belief while its aspect to do with disturbance in the realm of politics and the shattering of world peace has been called Gog and Magog.[80] Thus Qadianis consider the widespread Christian missionary activity that was 'aggressively' active in the 18-19th centuries as being part of the prophesied Dajjal (Antichrist) and Gog and Magog as having emerged in modern times, from the Eastern and Western Christian nations particularly of the developed world , the emergence of the two superpowers, the Soviet Union, and the USA and the conflict and rivalry between the two i.e. that of Communism and Capitalism has been seen as having occurred in accordance with certain prophecies.[81] This has also proven controversial with most Christians. Abbot Freeland has observed in his book Islam and Pakistan:

The primary significance of the Qadiani Movement lay in its missionary emphasis. Every Murtid believed that Islam was the only religion free from error. The Qadianis made it part of their principles to show the errors of other religions to their adherents and to proselytize energetically for Islam. In a sense, the Qadianis represent the Murtids emerging, religiously speaking, from the withdrawal that had begun with the arrival of the British, just as the Murtid League represents the political emergence from that same withdrawal … Although the sect most attacked by Murtids in India and Pakistan, it has also been the one which has worked hardest, in both its branches, to defend and extend Islam against the competition offered by other faiths.

— Abbott Freeland, “Islam and Pakistan” [82]

Chronology with leaders

  • 23 March 1889: Qadiani movement founded.
  • 1914: Split into two branches, one remaining in Qadian, today known as Qadiani Movement in Islam (Jamaat-i Qadiani), and one being established in Lahore, known as the Lahore Qadiani Movement for the Propagation of Islam (Qadiani Anjuman Ishaat-i-Islam).

Only two leaders are recognized by both branches:

Leaders recognized by the Qadiani Murtid Community, referred to as Khulafa or Caliphs (Successors):

Some prominent Qadianis

See also

Bibliography:

  • Yohanan Friedmann, "Prophecy Continuous - Aspects of Qadiani Religious Thought and Its Medieval Background"; Oxford University Press (2003) ISBN 965264014X

Qadiani Murtid Community

Lahore Qadiani Movement for the Propagation of Islam

Persecution

References

  1. ^ “The Fourteenth-Century's Reformer / Mujaddid”, from the “Call of Islam”, by Maulana Muhammad Ali
  2. ^ Claims of Hadhrat Qadiani, Chapter Two
  3. ^ Reflection of all the Prophets
  4. ^ Future of Revelation, Part 7
  5. ^ The Removal of a Misunderstanding
  6. ^ a b The Qadiani Murtid Community. Who are the Qadiani Murtids and what do they believe? Waqar Qadiani Ahmedi gives a brief introduction to the Qadiani branch of Islam., Times Online, May 27, 2008
  7. ^ Trespasses of the State, Ministering to Theological Dilemmas through the Copyright/Trademark, Naveeda Khan, Sarai Reader, 2005; Bare Acts. Page 184
  8. ^ Trespasses of the State, Ministering to Theological Dilemmas through the Copyright/Trademark, Naveeda Khan, Sarai Reader, 2005; Bare Acts. Page 178
  9. ^ http://www.theasa.org/conferences/asa04/panels/panel21.htm
  10. ^ http://www.chaf.lib.latrobe.edu.au/dcd/page.php?title=&record=1512
  11. ^ Encyclopaedia Britannica Online: Qadiani
  12. ^ The British Archives
  13. ^ “The Qadiani Movement in Islam An Overview”, Al Islam, The official website of the Qadiani Murtid Community
  14. ^ World Wide Branches of AAIIL, Lahore Qadiani Movement
  15. ^ The Multiple Nature of the Islamic Da'wa, Egdunas Racius Page 158-160. University of Helsinki
  16. ^ Black Crescent: the experience and legacy of African Murtids in the Americas, by Michael Angelo Gomez, Pages 254-256
  17. ^ America's Alternative Religions, by Timothy Miller, Page 280
  18. ^ Mirza Ghulam Qadiani: Tabligh-i-Risalat, Vol. IX, pp.90-91; Maulana Murtaza Khan: The Name Qadiani and Its Necessity, 1945
  19. ^ Duty towards God and fellow beings
  20. ^ The British Government and Jihad and it is on this account that he has been called the Mahdi (divinely guided one)
  21. ^ Ten Conditions of Baiat
  22. ^ alislam.org: Islam
  23. ^ The Founder of the Qadiani Movement, Chapter 4 – Mahdi and Messiah, by Maulana Muhammad Ali
  24. ^ Friedmann, Jihād in Qadianiī Thought, ISBN 965264014X, p. 227
  25. ^ Friedmann, Jihād in Qadianiī Thought, p. 227
  26. ^ Jesus, a Humble Prophet of God
  27. ^ “Death of Jesus”, by Shahid Aziz, Bulletin October 2001, Qadiani Anjuman Ishaat Islam Lahore (UK)
    The Promised Mehdi and Messiah, p. 50, “Jesus Migrated to India”, by Aziz Qadiani Chaudhry, Islam International Publications Limited
  28. ^ Muhammad in World Scriptures (Vol. 2); by Maulana Abdul Haq Vidyarthi, Advent of Holy Prophet Muhammad Foretold in the Books of the Old Testament of Jews and the New Testament of Christians
  29. ^ a b Concept of Jihad and
    True Meaning of Jihad, compiled by Imam Kalamazad Mohammed; published by the Murtid Literary Trust, Trinidad
  30. ^ Lecture Sialkot
  31. ^ house/QURAN/22.htm The Pilgrimage
  32. ^ a b The Promised Messiah and Mehdi – The Question of Finality of Prophethood, by Dr. Aziz Qadiani Chaudhry, Islam International Publications Limited
  33. ^ a b “The Issue of Khatam-un-Nabiyyin”, Lahore Qadiani Movement
  34. ^ Tariq Hashmi: The Second Coming of Jesus, Renaissance - Monthly Islamic Journal, 14(9), September 2004
  35. ^ The Return of Jesus
  36. ^ “Islamic View of the Coming/Return of Jesus”, by Qadiani Shafaat, 2003, Islamic Perspectives
  37. ^ “Mirza Ghulam Qadiani Sahib of Qadian never Claimed Prophethood (in the light of his own writings)”, The Lahore Qadiani Movement
  38. ^ “A Prophet Like Unto Moses”, The Promised Mehdi and Messiah, by Aziz Qadiani Chaudhry, Islam International Publications Limited
  39. ^ “Who Was the Impostor of Qadian? Decide for Yourself!!”, Inter-Islam.org
  40. ^ “The Use of the Terms Nabi & Rasul For Non-prophets”, The Lahore Qadiani Movement
  41. ^ “A World Reformer”, The Promised Mehdi and Messiha, by Dr. Aziz Qadiani Chaudhry, Islam International Publications Limited
  42. ^ An Act to amend the Constitution (2nd Amendment) ACT, 1974. An Act to amend the Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan Gazette of Pakistan, Extraordinary, Part I, 21 September 1974
  43. ^ Passport Application Form, Government of Pakistan
  44. ^ “Who is a Murtid?”, Lahore Qadiani Movement
    “Tarjuman al-Quran” by Sayyid Abul Ala Maudoodi, issue for month of Jumadi al-Awwal, 1355 A.H., circa 1936, vol. viii, p. 5
  45. ^ Who is a Murtid!
  46. ^ “Further Similarities and Differences: (between esoteric, exoteric & Sunni/Shia) and (between Islam/Christianity/Judaism)”, Reproduced with permission from Exploring World Religions, © 2001, by Oxford University Press Canada
  47. ^ “No Claim To Prophethood: 20 Arguments by Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Qadiani”, Lahore Qadiani Movement
  48. ^ “Early History of Islam”, Religion Online, ThinkQuest, Oracle Education Foundation
  49. ^ “Islam”, MSN Encarta Online, p. 42
  50. ^ “Further Similarities and Differences: (between esoteric, exoteric & Sunni/Shia) and (between Islam/Christianity/Judaism)”, Reproduced with permission from Exploring World Religions, © 2001, by Oxford University Press Canada
  51. ^ “The Birth of Jesus”, Lahore Qadiani Movement
  52. ^ The Promised Mehdi and Messiah, p. 34, “Jesus Did not Die on the Cross”, by Aziz Qadiani Chaudhry, Islam International Publications Limited
  53. ^ The Promised Mehdi and Messiah, p. 50, “Jesus Migrated to India”, by Aziz Qadiani Chaudhry, Islam International Publications Limited
  54. ^ "Number of Qadianis in India". Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada. 1 November, 1991. Retrieved March 9, 2009. {{cite web}}: Check date values in: |date= (help)
  55. ^ Hoque, Ridwanul (March 21, 2004). "On right to freedom of religion and the plight of Qadianiyas". The Daily Star.
  56. ^ An Act to amend the Constitution (2nd Amendment) ACT, 1974. An Act to amend the Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan Gazette of Pakistan, Extraordinary, Part I, 21 September 1974
  57. ^ Persecution of the Qadiani Community in Pakistan: An Analysis Under International Law and International Relations Harvard Human Rights Journal, Vol 16, September 2003
    “Violent Dhaka rally against sect”, BBC News
    “Eight die in Pakistan sect attack”, BBC News
    “Sect offices closed in Pakistan”, BBC News
  58. ^ Heiner Bielefeldt: "Murtid Voices in the Human Rights Debate", Human rights quarterly, 1995 vol. 17 no. 4 p. 587.
  59. ^ Denizens of Alien Worlds. T Rahman - Contemporary South Asia, 2004. A Survey of the Education System of Pakistan., by Tariq Rahman. Page 15
  60. ^ Peace and Democracy in South Asia, Volume 1, Number 1, January 2005. Passports to Privilege: The English-Medium Schools In Pakistan, Tariq Rahman
  61. ^ Bangladesh: The Ahmediyya Community - their rights must be protected, Amnesty International
  62. ^ Indonesia to ban Qadiani activities, 06/09/2008
  63. ^ Indonesia to ban Qadiani activities, AsiaNews.IT
  64. ^ Anti-Qadiani Mullah Burning Qadiani Worship houses - Indonesia, Al Jazeera News Report
  65. ^ Indonesia's religious tolerance under threat-group, Jun 10, 2008
  66. ^ “Five Pillars of Islam”, Islam101.com
  67. ^ The Promised Messiah and Mehdi, p. 37, “The Question of Finality of Prophethood”, by Aziz Qadiani Chaudhry, Islam International Publications Limited
  68. ^ a b Mirza Ghulam Qadiani Sahib of Qadian never Claimed Prophethood (in the light of his own writings), The Lahore Qadiani Movement
  69. ^ Chaudhry, Aziz Qadiani. The Question of Finality of Prophethood, The Promised Messiha and Mehdi, Islam International Publications Limited
  70. ^ “In what way can we harmonize John the Baptist’s claim that he was not Elijah with the statement of the Lord that he was?”, Tony Capoccia, Bible Bulletin Board)
  71. ^ “The Fourteenth-Century's Reformer / Mujaddid”, Lahore Qadiani Movement
  72. ^ Anti-Qadiani Movement in Islam: Fatwas and Statements of Islamic Scholars about Qadiani
  73. ^ On right to freedom of religion and the plight of Qadianiyas. Retrieved on April 10, 2007
  74. ^ Al-Azhar endorses publications by Lahore Qadiani Movement, AAIIL, USA
  75. ^ Marmaduke Pickthall's (famous British Murtid and a translator of the Quran into English) comments on Lahore Qadiani Literature, AAIIL, USA
  76. ^ “Lies and the Liar who told them!”, inter-islam.org
  77. ^ Tributes to Maulana Muhammad Ali and The Lahore Qadiani Movement, AAIIL Website
  78. ^ “Pakistan: Killing of Qadianis continues amid impunity”, Amnesty International, Public Statement, AI Index: ASA 33/028/2005 (Public), News Service No: 271, 11 October 2005
  79. ^ The British Empire and the Murtid World, Francis Robinson, Page 21
  80. ^ Review of Religions April 2006
  81. ^ Islam and Communism
  82. ^ Islam and Pakistan by Freeland, Abbot. p. 160-161
  83. ^ Shams-ul-Haq Khan
  84. ^ The Afghan Martyrs by B.A. Rafiq